Sunday, November 3, 2019

Our faith in this narrative: "Natural Disasters" by Alexis Schaitkin

One of the themes I keep coming back to on this blog is to ask the question of whether literature is good for us. It's not just an important question for those who study literature; because humans so naturally turn everything into a story, the same questions about whether literature is good for us can apply to a number of human cognitive processes that involve us telling ourselves stories in order to understand what is happening to us. 

For literature specifically, at least some of the trade-offs are fairly clear. We sacrifice verisimilitude in order to create stories where most events serve a general purpose, be it a purpose of plot, character development, or theme. There are advantages to this; we can deeply examine a particular problem of the human condition by focusing a story entirely on that one problem. But it can also lead to a faulty belief in those who read a lot of stories that the events in their actual lives are, as in a well written story, all are there for a reason. It can lead us to read our lives like they are stories with an externally determined meaning rather than an open narrative we must fill based on our own sense of values. We can, in other words, misread our lives as being one type of narrative when the brute facts of the case imply something else.

Maybe there are some instances where not insisting too much on the truths of our lives helps contribute to survival, such as the person living under unavoidable trauma who finds a way to believe they are living a different life than the one they are. I'm not an orphan being shuffled from one foster home to the next; I'm a prince whose real parents are coming to get him. I'm not in a concentration camp; I'm in an extreme weight loss camp, and once I hit my goal weight, I can go home.

But these few marginal cases are probably dwarfed by the frequency of the counter-example: the person who is destructively misreading her own life because she continually applies an external story she has imagined over top of it. This makes her misinterpret her life over and over. This was the case with just the last story in BASS 2019, "Audition" by Said Sayrafiezadeh, where the main character kept thinking he was an actor just pretending to be a construction laborer, when in fact he really was a construction laborer. And it's the case with the 16th story as well, "Natural Disasters" by Alexis Schaitkin.

How the narrator misreads her life


Jen, the first-person narrator, is looking back later in life to the time when she and her former husband moved from New York to Oklahoma. Jen's husband, Steven, has just been sent there by the oil company he works for. As soon as Jen hears of the promotion and the move, she begins to create a narrative into which this new event fits. Jen recalls how this was something she did about everything back then. "You see, I lived then guided by the unconscious notion that the story of my life as I was meant to live it was already written in a secret, locked away text. At the end, I would finally be able to open it and read the story that had been written there all along--its arc, its twists and turns, it motifs and themes, it most evocative lines."

This ability to put her life into a secret story has helped both her and Steven to get through the lean years in New York, when they lived off meager means, accompanied by a variety of "manageably unpleasant odors," like mice decomposing in the walls. Their "faith in this narrative" allowed them to "delight even in (their) frequent arguments," and to "enjoy things that were not, in themselves, enjoyable." So reading her life as part of a secret story has had advantages, but it will also cause her to misread the next part of her life, the part in Oklahoma, because she is still trying to see every event as part of this secret narrative.

There's a little bit of this idea going on in the story, but that's not the only idea being developed.

She recalls that both she and Steven were living in Oklahoma "ironically." This partly means that they were living there like stuck-up New York elitists, having a laugh at the unsophisticated locals. She and Steven get a chuckle out of the fact that their neighborhood is called "Amber Ridge," although there is no ridge. But "living ironically" also means, for Jen, that she will think often while she is in Oklahoma as though she isn't really there, or at the very least, like she is just passing through, doing nothing more in Oklahoma than picking up anecdotes to fill the book of her life's story. She tended this collection of anecdotes "with the vigor of an avid hobbyist, savoring the delicious irony of a place that conformed exactly to my hackneyed expectations."

There are two reasons she is collecting these little pieces of Oklahoma life. One is that she thinks thereby she can get some sense of the essence of the Oklahoma part of her life: "I believed that I could nail this place by triangulating among its details, that these typifying images converged upon a deeper truth." That is, she thinks the place is nothing more than the sum of its parts. But there's a deeper reason, and this is where the real critique of fiction as a cognitive process comes in.

God help us, she's a writer


The second reason she collects stories is that she's by nature a writer. This isn't a story about a writer, exactly, although the woman is, by her own admission, good at writing. She takes a job writing those little real estate blurbs--you know the ones, "this two-story craftsman is country living at its finest, a real stunner!" She partly takes this job because she's having difficulty adjusting to life in Oklahoma. It's this difficulty that makes her realize, much later, that there's no such thing as living ironically. You might think it's hilarious that you, with your college education and your gift for bons mots, are living in Oklahoma, but you're still there, the same as everyone else who is there. You don't get to escape feeling depressed. When the giant, open spaces fill you with terror, those open spaces don't realize you don't belong there, that you're not like everybody else.

Jen finds working writing these blurbs for a real estate agent helps calm her symptoms of depression. Maybe because they allow her to not focus so much on the wide, open spaces, but on the limited spaces of the houses. It also helps that Bethany, the real estate agent, seems to teach Jen a thing or two about how to be "apart without seeming to keep herself apart." That is, how to live cognizant of the incongruity of being somewhere, but nonetheless with sincerity and without irony.

When Bethany asks if Jen is a good writer, Jen does not hesitate to say "yes." However, she later qualifies this within her recollection: "I could give the impression of meaning and insight, of grand convergence, and if you weren't paying careful attention you might not notice that beneath the rhythms of thought the argument was facile, even specious."

Isn't that the problem with any good writer? That they can tell us a story so compelling-sounding, we don't realize we've been completely bamboozled by how pleasant the words and images are and so miss how much we've been lied to?

The "part of the story I've been working up to this whole time"


Indeed, although Jen gets better at interpreting the data in her life--learning to respect the women around her for their strange, inner strength that comes to them from God-knows-where, she continues misreading events up to the end. The climax comes when Jen goes out to see the fanciest house she ever visits in order to write her blurb about it. It's right on the edge of the endless prairie, and, unlike all the homes she's been to, there's a man inside instead of a woman. And a good looking one, too. She immediately compares him in her head to every good looking cowboy in every movie she's ever seen. His name, Mac, seems to fit the cowboy image.

Mac is awkward in the home, which Jen attributes to "a certain male cluelessness--he didn't have the instinct to monitor and steer things the way a woman did, I thought." When he seems embarrassed by how nice his home is, she assumes that "he was one of those rich people whose good fortune embarrassed him." She starts inventing theories for why he is living out there all alone.

But she's wrong about all of it, which she doesn't discover until a tornado threatens to break right on top of them, forcing her and Mac to run to the shelter together.

While in the shelter with Mac, Jen can't resist resorting to the "secret book" of her life again. The storm is raging outside. He's close to her, and he's so good looking. He could just reach out, brush back her wet hair, and she'd be his. "I had the exhilarating sense that for the first time I was living a page from the secret text of my life."

No sooner does she imagine this than the storm abates and she learns who he really is and why the house is for sale. It turns out that the place belonged to his brother, who was killed recently in a car accident after safely returning from serving in the military in Desert Storm.  She's misread real life again, because she keeps trying to superimpose the kind of logic that works in fiction on real life.

Does Jen get the moral to her own story?


Jen offers to interpret the meaning of her story for us at the end. It's a tentative but convincing attempt to read the events of her life. She's since gotten divorced from Steven, a divorce that should have been obvious all along, if only she'd be cognizant of the signs. She's moved several times since then. She offers this as part one of what she's learned: "a place and its disasters--its fathomless, inscrutable unknows--are not separable. Oklahoma is its tornadoes, just as Maine, even on the mildest of spring days, is its snows, is a caved roof and a woman asleep in her bed, and then gone. The disaster is always there, because it takes up residence inside of you."

She notes when she reads about Mac's brother's life in an old newspaper that it "sounds like something from a story, almost too...on-the-nose, to be real." She can't even recognize reality, because reality to her now seems like fiction. That's why I'm not sure we ought to trust Jen a few pages later when she returns to her "disasters" understanding of her life. In the penultimate sentence, she theorizes that "Life is not a story at all. It is the disasters we carry within us."

That sounds profound. But is it? By Jen's own admission, she's capable of slipping us crap and making us think, if we're not careful, that it is some kind of deep knowledge. Jen thinks that Oklahoma is somehow not itself now, because by pouring water into the Earth for fracking, it is not suffering earthquakes, meaning its organic disasters have shifted. But does this hold up? Isn't this just another example of Jen trying to force one story onto reality when reality is trying to offer us something else? Earthquakes are very much part of Oklahoma's nature, at least now, because Oklahoma is having earthquakes. So don't come in with your writer's notions of the right and wrong kinds of disasters. These aren't ironic earthquakes.

I'd guess most readers will take Jen at her word by the end. Life is the disasters we carry inside us. She's really overcome her early-life tendency to read a story into everything. She's dropping wisdom on us. But what the hell does "we are the disasters we carry inside us" mean? That sounds like faux wisdom to me, the kind of thing an ersatz guru would drop on his credulous followers. It's Jen now being ironic, or trying to be, about herself as a natural-born writer who relates to the world the way writers do. But she hasn't really transcended this tendency. She's just denied it. Rather than learn to interpret better, she's learned to interpret much worse by falling into even deeper "facile, even specious" thinking.

As if to throw us off the trail that this "we are the disasters" nugget is specious, Jen offers up a strawman interpretation right before her own: "Maybe you think all of this is easy to interpret. A girl left the city and learned a thing or two. A silly young woman hoped to be ravished by a man who was not her husband. A marriage fell apart, and afterward a wife was wiser, though in some ways no better, than she had been before." And right after the "life is the disasters inside us line," she harkens back to her writing as a real-estate blurbist: "(Life) is amazing, it is exquisite, it is a stunning charmer, and it is noted in water and jotted in dust and the wind lifts it away." I think Jen really wants us to side with this reading. 

But I think Jen has missed another reading. Life can be a story. It's just isn't a secret story. It's the story life shows us. It's what we experience, not what we wish we were experiencing. When life is showing us something, we shouldn't ignore that data, preferring the story we've created in our heads. 

Thursday, October 31, 2019

Working class tourist: "Audition" by Said Sayrafiezadeh

Said Sayrafiezadeh's "Audition" is kind of like Michael Jordan, whom the narrator is a fan of, driving to the basket. It goes one way, crosses back, fakes again, pulls back, and before long the would-be critic's ankles are as broken as Craig Ehlo's.



I started off thinking this was going to be a story about class in America. The narrator is the wealthy son of a developer, but his dad wants him to learn the value of a buck when he graduates from high school, so the narrator ends up hauling dry wall for his dad at eight bucks an hour. It's the mid-90s in some mid-sized, middle-of-America city, so that's enough to live on, but the narrator's got bigger dreams. He studied acting in local classes growing up, has done a few small-town theater plays. He wants to fill up his U-haul and head off to LA to make it big as a star, like Seinfeld.

He doesn't want anyone he works with on the construction sites to know he's the boss's dad, so he has to act. His whole work is a role he settles into. He studies the speech patterns and actions of his fellow workers. He imagines he is studying "real life," and this will help him as an actor later. Over time, he convinces himself that he envies his co-workers, because "their problems were immediate, distinct, and resolvable; mine were long-term, existential, and impossible." He is romanticizing his working-class colleagues, using the same language as a well-meaning but pretentious American tourist abroad. When he visits the home of a co-worker, he notes that the inside is much nicer than the outside, and he congratulates himself for having discovered "the kinds of detail that would have eluded a person who had merely driven through the neighborhood without bothering to stop, like the passenger on a cruise ship who thinks he knows the island from the port."

While in that house, the story does one of its changes of direction. The narrator tries crack cocaine with Duncan Dioguardi, a co-worker so hard-up he doesn't have a car to get to work. At this point, it seems to be more a story about a young man's fall than it is about class.

When the narrator gets cast in a play, but starts to realize community theater is, well, community theater, he goes back to Duncan's house to "party" a second time. After smoking crack this time, he goes through three consecutive emotional states: euphoria, panic, and then peace. The euphoria is because he thinks he is "the passenger on the cruise ship who has become acquainted with the island." He feels close to Duncan. He feels optimistic about his prospects. It is early in the evening, as nineteen years old is still early in life. But panic follows euphoria as he is watching an episode of Seinfeld while high:

"Suddenly I was in possession of that thing called clarity. I was watching the most vapid show in the history of television—it had always been vapid and we, the viewers, had always been duped. I could see straight through it now—solipsistic, narcissistic, false reality, easy tropes, barely amusing. The clarity that I thought I’d had moments earlier had not been clarity at all but, rather, its opposite, delusion, which was now being usurped by an all-encompassing awareness, horrible and heavy, through which I understood at once that I was not talented, had never been talented, that my life as a general laborer was proof of this lack of talent, and that being cast in a role with zero lines was not a step toward fame but a step into obscurity in a midsized city. Who but a fool agrees to move through space for three acts without saying a word?"

At this point, I felt like the story was a coming-of-age story of painful yet needed shattered illusions. But the story does one last juke before sticking the jumper. The narrator regains his sense of calm. He is young. The night is young. "It would be night for many more hours to come. I was nineteen. Nineteen was young. I would be young for many more years to come." He goes off to get money for more drugs. So I was left thinking this was the story of a young man's self-delusion, leading him into drugs and a long detour from happiness in life.

Where is the narrator? 


Part of what makes the story so elusive is the uncertain stance of the narrator. From the opening words of the story, "The first time I smoked crack cocaine..." we know that the narrator is older now than he was when the events took place and is looking back on them. But it's unclear how much distance there is between the events and the telling. If we assume he's now twenty-some years older, because we're reading the story in The New Yorker twenty-some years after the time of the story, where is the narrator now? Is he telling this at an NA meeting? Recounting his memoirs as a famous actor? Recollecting to himself the moment when it all went wrong?

As the young man in the story is pulling off his act, spoiled rich kid playing at working-class drone,  the narrator is working with Shakespearean negative capability. He hints at a number of attitudes, but never quite tips his hand as to which one he sides with. Does he think of his younger self with pity, with bemusement, with anger for having messed up the life of the man the narrator now is?

I think it's some of all of those. The younger version of himself has some good reasons to be confused about life. Teens are told to follow their dreams, but also to stay grounded and be realistic about expectations. The narrator's father gave him mixed signals in this vein, sending him to acting classes, acting proud when his son performed in a play, but then immediately discouraging it when he realized his son wanted to do more with acting than make it a hobby.

The narrator as a young man also is stuck in a tough calculus, one I'm still working out in my own life. How do you know when you're dealing with the adversity on the road to accomplishing your goals, as opposed to just holding on to a dream that's never going to happen? How do you know the difference between tenacity and foolish hope? The young man sees Michael Jordan drive to the basket and thinks he never had to wonder these things, that Jordan never heard, as the narrator has from his theater peers, that "it takes as long as it takes."

He's wrong, of course, Jordan famously faced a setback in high school that left most people thinking he'd never even play in college, let alone be considered the best pro of all time. But it's easy to see how the young man could have begun to think that those who've "got it" should be starting to show it by the age he is. He isn't, and he's starting to feel less like a tourist and more like he's actually where he belongs.

Of course, drugs offer the possibility of not thinking about these things, at least for a while longer. By the end of the story, the young man has, somewhat ironically, ended up giving himself one of those "immediate, distinct, and resolvable" problems he used to envy.

Ultimately, the story's not really about where the narrator is now as he tells his story. It's about the moment when it all starts to be too much for him. It's less about how he tried to face the problem and more of a statement of how profound the problem is.




Monday, October 28, 2019

I am whatever they wish to make of me: "Black Corfu" by Karen Russell

If I don't love this story, it's not Karen Russell's fault. It so happens that this past weekend, in addition to preparing to write this post on "Black Corfu," the fourteenth story in the 2018 Best American Short Stories volume, I also saw Parasite, the Korean movie directed by Bong Joon Ho that won the top award at this year's Cannes Film festival. Although Parasite is focused on class almost entirely while "Black Corfu" is about racial prejudices first and class prejudices second, they're in similar territory thematically. They even both make use of an up/down topology for the setting that dramatically and viscerally represents the psychologically different worlds the two classes inhabit. And while "Black Corfu" is a strong showing, Parasite is one of the five best movies I've ever seen. I already loved Memories of a Murder, also by Bong, and this is on that level. So it's hard for me to gush about "Black Corfu" when my heart is so full of Parasite.

Image result for archer phrasing gif


The main character is an unnamed "posthumous doctor" in the early 17th century. He was a smart lad, but he has dark skin, and the social stigma associated with that means he can never be a doctor like he wants to. The "real" doctors (who are so ineffective their patients often die of pneumonia and "throat rattle") live at the top of the hill on the island of Black Corfu in the Adriatic Sea. Our hero can climb no higher than to become a "posthumous doctor," cutting the hamstrings of corpses so they don't turn into werewolves. It's not what he wanted, but he has learned a lesson that nearly all minorities who face prejudice learn: "fit yourself to your circumstances." He also dreams that if he does a really good job, the island's elders will see his valuable contributions and promote him. "Wasn't it possible that a posthumous surgeon might one day be promoted from his abyss to the upper world?" he dreams.

Alas, his dreams are not to be. After decades of never allowing a corpse to turn into a monster, he is assigned a student from another town. This student, Jure, is from the upper class, but is generally unpromising in life, so he has been assigned to learn the trade of posthumous surgeon from our protagonist. Jure is terrified by hacking at the dead, too stupid to learn the trade, and insulted when the old werewolf doctor comments that Jure also has dark skin, so Jure comes up with a scheme to get out of training with the old man: he says that the old man messed up a surgery, and now the red-headed girl he was supposed to have prevented from becoming a werewolf is roaming the island.

It's an absurd claim, but the island shows itself all too willing to believe it. His decades of "never losing a patient" mean nothing. The island swallows the boy's lies, largely because it has barely repressed its instinctive prejudices against the "moor" posthumous surgeon all these years. The "real" doctor who lives up the hill is one of those most strongly against him.

Even the old man's wife ends up believing the lies. She is willing to forgive, but this only enrages the old man, who just wants to be believed, not forgiven. He is unable to fight the "other man," the version of himself everyone thinks is the real him. This "other man" is as monstrous as the werewolves he is supposed to protect them from. "I am whatever they make of me," he observes, so impotent to fight the lies about him that even he is unable to fight the "other man" within his own mind.

Finally, the old surgeon performs the hamstringing surgery on himself, then commits suicide, hoping to prove that he would never fail in the surgery by succeeding on his own body. But his corpse rises from the grave. His werewolf wonders if he has made a mistake.

It's all a metaphor, of course, and the mistake he has made is in believing that society could ever see him as anything other than a monster. He thought he could accommodate them, assuage their fears of monsters, but he never realized that the same people afraid of monsters put him in the same class.

In one of the possibly too-on-point omniscient breaks from the limited point-of-view of most of the story, we get this tie-in to prejudice in the 21st century:

"In later centuries, new etiologies will evolve. Miasma theory will yield to germ theory, superstition to science. Yet every novel treatment breeds an equally novel genetic resilience, as only the hardiest survivors spawn. And so the cure teaches the disease how to evade it."

I'm not quite the alarmist some people are about racism in the age of Trump, but it's clear it's not dead. It's not dead in Europe, either. And those who are still hanging on to the old prejudices are dug in now, hard to get out of their foxholes. In some ways, this short story reminds me of the movie Kingdom of Heaven for the way it invites the reader to see the present alive in the past. Really, the story has a lot going for it. The use of setting and the imaginative connection between the prejudices of the past, which now seem like silly superstition as much as a Monty Python skit about witches, and the prejudices which survive today--all of it is good stuff. It's a good story.

It just isn't Parasite. In conclusion, if you get anything out of this review, it would be to make sure you see the movie Parasite.

Saturday, October 26, 2019

Reva's Cat: "Letter of Apology" by Maria Reva

For an American like me who doesn't know much about Ukraine other than as the current center of Washington's three-ring circus, there are two choices when reading a short story like "Letter of Apology" by Maria Reva (available from Granta here). I can spend hours trying to learn about Ukraine, at least enough to have some deeper understanding of the story, or I can just take what the story tells me about Ukraine and accept and read it on that level. I'm opting for the latter.

I did have to cheat and use what little bit I do know in order to get the time down. I believe the story is set when Ukraine was still part of the Soviet Union, because there is still a KGB and it is still possible for Ukrainians to think they might be sent to Moscow for special duty. It's later in the Soviet Union's life, because there is now a kinder, gentler KGB that wants to convince political thought criminals of the error of their ways rather than just throw them in jail.

What the narrator needs to convince someone to do


The story opens with a joke. Konstantyn Illych Boyko, a popular Ukrainian poet, has told a political joke after a reading. Mikhail Igorovich is the KGB agent assigned to coax a letter of apology out of Boyko. We don't actually get to read the joke, because it's so offensive, it has been proactively expurgated from the file Igorovich gets. The KGB likes it when people apologize on their own, within thirty days, rather than having to put the screws to them. They still use the threat of repercussions to get the apology, but they prefer to dangle the threat over the political offender's head rather than actually use it.



Boyko, unfortunately, is stubborn. Although Igorovich usually gets an apology letter out of the people he is assigned to well before thirty days are up, Boyko insists he has nothing to apologize for. He's a politically pure communist, he says, and he quotes Lenin to prove it.

Igorovich's self-delusion


As Igorovich hounds Boyko, he is in turn hounded by Boyko's wife, Milena Markivna. While Igorovich is following Boyko, meaning to deliver the message that this will not go away until Boyko apologizes, he finds that Markivna is following him. It turns out that Markivna's entire family was erased by the KGB when Markivna was a child. The reader realizes she's probably plotting revenge against the KGB by taking it out on Igorovich, but Igorovich manages to miss the threat because of the extraordinary self-delusion he practices.

Both his mother and his father were also disappeared by the KGB when he was a child. However, unlike Markivna, Igorovich chose to believe the lies people told him about what happened to his parents. He believes his mother was chosen for special duty guarding Lenin's tomb. He later believes his father got to go join her. He is aware that something doesn't quite add up with what he's been told-- "I could not reconcile the immense honor of the invitation with the grief that plagued the family"--but he has managed his whole life to push these doubts down.

One of the characteristics of Igorovich that helps him to repress his own doubts is a common logical fallacy many humans believe, the "just world fallacy." His parents were good people, he thinks, so something good must have happened to them. He suffers from the particular delusion that the world works in an orderly way. It's why he assumed everyone will willingly sign a letter of apology:

"Most people fail to grasp the simple logic of the situation: that once a transgression occurs and a case file opens, the case file triggers a response--in this case, a letter of apology. One document exposes the problem, the second resolves it. One cannot function without the other, just as the bolt cannot function without a nut and a nut cannot function without a bolt." 

It's a moral version of Newtonian physics. Everything is operating according to well-ordered rules. But Igorovich also has a quantum physics-inspired moral stance. While watching the Soviet animated movie Hedgehog in the Fog, because Boyko is also watching it, he considers the meaning of the Hedgehog character wondering whether a white horse would drown if the horse fell asleep in the fog. This triggers a chain of thoughts in the narrator:

I suppose what Hedgehog means is: if the white horse stops moving, we would no longer see it in the white fog. But if we no longer see it, what is its state? Drowned or not? Dead or alive? The question is whether Hedgehog would prefer to keep the fog or have it lift to discover what is behind its thick veil. I would keep the fog. For instance, I cannot know the whereabouts of my parents because they are part of me and therefore part of my personal file and naturally no one can see their own file, just like no one can see the back of their own head. My mother is standing proud among the Honor Guard. My mother is standing elsewhere. She is sitting. She is lying down. She is cleaning an aquarium while riding an elevator. Uncertainty contains an infinite number of certainties. My mother is in all these states at once, and nothing stops me from choosing one. Many people claim they like certainty, but I do not believe this is true – it is uncertainty that gives freedom of mind. And so, while I longed to be reassigned to Moscow, the thought of it shook me to the bones with terror.

Much like in Schrodinger's Cat experiment, Igorovich believes that if he simply never finds out what happened to his parents, he can go on believing anything he wants. He can preserve his belief in a just universe. He can think the KGB isn't capricious, doesn't punish people arbitrarily or wrongly. He can keep doing his job.

The cat eventually gets out of the bag...or box


Igorovich's self-delusion is so strong, he convinces himself that the reason Markivna is following him is because she is a powerful official vetting him for an important job, like the one he thinks his mother had. He thinks the difficulty he is having getting the letter is just part of the test. I won't give away the ending, but his delusion is finally broken. The "letter of apology" we get is his own, apparently told in the form of the short story we have just read. Ultimately, we cannot forever willfully refuse to find out the truth. We cannot leave the cat in the box indefinitely, thinking that as long as we do not observe what happened to it, we can believe whatever we want.

The story has, I imagine, special meaning for Ukraine now as it tries, like so many Latin American countries, to uncover the truth of what happened during decades of state security running amok. The state's KGB archives were opened in 2015, meaning the country has a long slog through paperwork to find out a lot of secrets many want to know.

What meaning does this story have for an American reader? I suppose the notion of resisting state security has some resonance today. Although we aren't living in a police state like 1970s Ukraine, we do have a threat from technology that makes state security potentially far more invasive than at any time in American history. For non-technical citizens like myself, it is tempting to just not pay attention to the issues, to let the cat sit in the box and assume things will work themselves out. But of course, this kind of abandonment of democratic responsibility won't do, and we all have to try as best as we can to watch the state that watches us.

But there's a more direct reading, one that's almost not even political. We all face the temptation to practice the cognitive fallacies Igorovich practiced. We all can be made fools, unable to process data we face if that data wasn't in the files we were given. "Reva's Cat" stresses that the Schrodinger's Cat thought experiment shouldn't be applied wantonly to moral questions.

Wednesday, October 23, 2019

Crime and Punishment, the Reader's Digest Version: "The Plan" by Sigrid Nunez

There is a rather telegraphed moment of foreshadowing in the second paragraph of Sigrid Nunez's "The Plan," the twelfth story in the 2019 Best American Short Stories collection. As it begins, Roden Jones, whose name we do not know yet nor anything about the fact that he is planning to kill his wife, is hanging out outside the Lincoln Center. He is resolving to "get more culture" once "it" is done, although, again, we don't know what "it" is yet. He is looking at the fountain and sees rainbows in the spray. "He had started to walk closer to get a better view, though, of course, as soon as he did that the rainbows disappeared."

All we know at that point is that the story is called "The Plan" and that when the main character looks closely into something, it isn't what he thought anymore. A perceptive reader is already going "best laid plans, something, something gang agley" by now.

Not too much later on, we find out it's a murder story. Not a mystery, but the psychological chronicle of a murder as the murderer plots it and carries it out, much like Crime and Punishment by Dostoevsky or "The Tell-Tale Heart" or "The Cask of Amontillado" by Poe. Generally, a story like this can go one of two ways: it can try to peel back the veil over the mind of the murderer, offering some insight into the human psyche through the example of a mind that is broken, or it can try to thrill or frighten us by minimizing explanations, like in Child of God by Cormac McCarthy.

If we take Dostoevsky and Poe as illustrations, we might find there is kind of a spectrum here. Dostoevsky dwells deeply on the rationale of his killer. We may not get to any final cause for Raskolnikov and why he kills the pawn-broker and her half-sister, but it's not for lack of trying. The enjoyment of the novel is in its ability to sink deep through its imaginative and sympathetic power into the mind of the killer. "The Cask of Amontillado" is not at all ambivalent about its killer's motives. It's a revenge story. "The thousand injuries of Fortunato I had borne as I best could, but when he ventured upon insult I vowed revenge." It's right there in sentence number one. We apparently love this kind of story, because they can't seem to make enough movies like this. We might be a little shocked at the method of death the killer chooses, but we secretly love it. 

The same can't be said for "The Tell-Tale Heart." We get attempts at an explanation: something about the old man's eye bothered the killer. But that's not really much of an explanation, is it? We want to know why it bothered him so much. But this half-explanation defies more peeling away. It's more terrifying than no reason at all, because no reason leaves us to assume we are just missing information. A reason like that makes us think the real reason is ineffable, and that human behavior and thinking is not rational and therefore beyond our control. That's the same territory as Child of God. 


The Plan of "The Plan" 


Nunez kind of pulls from all of these models. There are plenty of attempts to give us a motive for the killer, and we get a lot of deep looks into the mind of the killer, Roden Jones. But the sheer surplus of possible explanations almost serves to leave us with none, or possibly one that isn't really all that interesting. What are the possible explanations? For most of the story, we are led to believe his victim or intended victim will be his wife, Harley. This changes at the last moment, so most of the thoughts Roden has don't really apply to his eventual target. 

1) Explanation Number One: He's just a born killer, and it was only a matter of time before he did something like this. 

He has a hard time pinning down the exact moment he decided to "subtract" his wife, and he thinks that "sometimes it seemed as if the idea had always existed." Later, as he is running down his list of reasons he wants to kill her so he doesn't get distracted, he ends with this: "And there was something else, something that had started long before he'd ever met Harley. By high school, it had already become a habit. He'd pick out a certain person because of something about her, maybe the way she talked, or the way she dressed or wore her makeup or her hair...And he'd feel a flood of venom and think, She is a candidate." 

This is the closest the story comes to going the "answer that is no answer" route. He wants to kill because it's just always been in him. He thought he'd grow out of it, but he didn't. And when he thinks about how much he wants to kill, "the wildness of his own imagination shook him to the core." This possible reading moves the story from a thriller to a horror story. The reasons people do terrible things are ineffable, even to those who do them. 

2. Explanation Number Two: He thinks Harley is in the way of him developing as a person. 

This is actually the first reason he gives himself. He is trying to keep his mind focused on "the reason Harley had to die," and the first thing he puts out is that although he is "on the verge of an important discovery," he also feels that "Harley was in the way. Her very existence was holding him back, preventing him from being who he was meant to be."

3. Explanation Number Three: His own pride dictates that he murder her. 

But he so sooner proposes explanation two than his mind overwrites it with what he claims is the real truth: "The truth was, he couldn't bear to live with the mistake he'd made, the humiliation of it." That is, he realizes he shouldn't have married her, but it would be humiliating to get a divorce, so it's better to kill her. That's narratively a lot more interesting. It would get us into ineffable territory--it's a humorous reason to an outsider to kill someone, because it's such absurd overkill to solve a small problem of embarrassment through murder. However, it's also so hard to imagine how he could actually take action based on this reasoning, we're left with a scary, inscrutable mind. But this explanation is also, like #2, wiped away as soon as it is proposed. The final explanation he gives is #1, that "he'd pick out a certain person" habit he's had for a long time. Maybe he was just born that way. 

So far, we have three explanations, none of which the killer himself is quite committed to in his own psyche, as the narrator has presented that psyche to us. Ultimately, he ends up ambivalent to what his reasons are: "She has to die because he has to kill someone, and she is the obvious candidate. He isn't going to waste a lot of time thinking about whether or not she deserves to die." 


I can think of someone who would have been really good at guessing the end of this story. It's about the same script he sees every week.  


4. The boring explanation: he's a misogynistic atheist. 

We have a number of interesting possible explanations, all competing with each other. But I'm afraid there's a much less interesting explanation that seems to outweigh them all from a textual evidence standpoint, one the killer himself isn't so aware of, but which the reader picks up on through a multitude of thoughts and actions. Roden hates women, hates them so much he's only focused on them as his targets. There are a number of passages in the book that highlight his hatred of women.

From the moment we meet him, sitting alone outside the Lincoln Center, he is worried about whether a man by himself looks suspicious. He's got the incel unjustified male martyr complex down. On the train, he and a number of other men are watching a girl's thighs as she sleeps while wearing a short skirt. She wakes up and gives him a dirty look for leering at her, which he immediately chalks up to what hypocritical whores women all are. "Wearing a skirt that all but exposed your crotch when you sat down, being outraged when men took notice--that was women." It's like I'm reading a version of men based on an angry person's Facebook page.

There are a number of other cliches. He's ashamed of having sex. He visits a prostitute. At his wedding, he is warned that women stop putting out when the wedding happens. He only dreams of killing women, not men. At a friend's wedding, he thinks about the conspiratorial nature of women huddled together.

Add to this that he is an atheist. "He was not a child anymore, the fear of God has long left him. He hadn't believed in God since he was ten years old."

Maybe I'm just a little miffed from comments of the Attorney General the other day, another tiresome "Atheism is to blame for social ills" diatribe, but I found this detail about the killer annoying. It's commonly believed that atheists are more likely to be serial killers, but it ain't true. (That last link also suggests "spiritual" people are more likely to suffer from certain mental illnesses than atheists, although Barr suggested the rise of mental illness stems from abandoning religion.)

Roden ends up killing the prostitute he's been visiting, along with the old man who is in the reception area. That's because Harley leaves him before he can kill her, and he's got to kill someone. The closing lines could have come from any third-rate crime drama on TV:

"He didn't think Marilyn deserved to die. But he didn't feel bad for her, either. She was a whore, and whores got murdered all the time. It was one of the things whores were for."

That's some straight SVU shit right there. We had three interesting possible motives, but ultimately it dissolved into the guy's a woman-hating asshole. It's fine for a character to be something other than likeable, but he shouldn't be contemptible. Someone we feel contempt for isn't scary. His motives aren't ineffable, they're just not well understood by the narrator, which is different and much less interesting for a crime story. After teasing us with a character who might be worth considering, we are left with someone who isn't frightening or challenging or thought-provoking. He's just sad.

I guess you could argue that there really are sad people like this, and that the story is just presenting a real case of a murderer. They're not people to admire. They're just sorry pieces of crap who bide their time waiting for an opportunity, justifying themselves however they need to. Maybe that's true. I don't know. I'm not an expert on serial killers. But whether it's true or not, a story about a person who barely even rises to the level of meriting my hatred makes for rather dull reading, especially when the writing resorts to a couple of cliches along the way to try rather cheaply to excite my hatred.

Sunday, October 20, 2019

My semi-annual crisis over whether literature has any social utility: "Anyone Can Do It" by Manuel Muñoz

If it's true that fiction can get around the prejudices people carry with them and subtly change hearts and minds, then our culture now ought to be full of the best, most empathetic people in history. We have more literature available to us than any culture in history, with many of the great works available for free online or on Kindle. There are resources to help understand that literature. And then there's the Golden Age of American Television, with streaming services giving us quality programming to challenge and stretch us. (Yes, there is plenty of good stuff to go along with the straight-to-Netflix Adam Sandler movies.)

When I read a story like "Anyone Can Do It" by Manuel Muñoz, my first thought is whether a short story is actually good for anything in the face of a massive social issue. This is the second year in a row Best American Short Stories included a story from the point-of-view of illegal immigrants. Last year, it was "Everything is Far From Here" by Cristina Henriquez, which I didn't care for, largely because it didn't seem to say anything about the border and incarceration that hasn't already been said a million times. (Incidentally, most of the traffic I get on my site seems to be from students who are assigned Best American Short Stories in school. I can tell which stories are the ones they want to write about by following which of my posts they click on. Henriquez's story is by far the least-clicked link from 2018 BASS.)

This year, "Anyone Can Do It" is a solid piece. It's not clear whether the protagonist is actually illegal. She claims throughout to be from Texas, although, because the characters in the story talk about Texas as though it were still part of Mexico ("the Matamoros side of Texas" as well as the "Texas side of Mexico"), it's not clear that her claim would be recognized by the INS. (And I do mean the INS rather than ICE, because this seems to be set a few decades ago.) What the story does right is take a big social issue like illegal immigration and the socially useful work done by immigrant labor (picking fruit, in this case) and look at it from an intensely personal lens.

Delfina's husband doesn't come back from the orchard one night. Nobody's husbands in the neighborhood do, and everyone is worried they've been rounded up. A woman named Lis from down the street cons Delfina into using the family car to take the two of them to go work in the orchards while Lis's daughter watches Delfina's son. Delfina is suspicious, but eventually gives in. Lis steals Delfina's car, takes their joint daily wages, and runs off.

It's full of suspense for the reader as we watch the bad thing happen to Delfina in slow motion. We listen to her slowly talking herself into it, even though she is right to be suspicious, because what are her options? If she doesn't take a chance with Lis, she won't be able to pay the rent in a few days.

We see the "law" contrasted with "justice," as Delfina's son steals a toy car from a store while she is on the phone with her family. We know he shouldn't have done it, but given his life, who would want him to take it back? Even a reader who has particular political views about illegal immigration shouldn't fail to empathize with her as she struggles to take care of her kid. And the possibility that she might actually be from Texas, meaning she might be legal, means that at least that one objection can be held at bay.

For that matter, because Delfina is cheated by another member of her own community, while the only person who is kind to her is an old white man, a white reader can read the story without feeling personally attacked. So if any story is going to change how a hardcore send-em-all-back immigration hardliner feels, it would be this one.

But I don't think it will. The actual human cost of our current social policy isn't hidden. There are signs all around of what it means. Even if "change" from this story isn't measured in people changing their political views--because I can believe someone might feel genuine empathy and still think it's important to secure our borders--at the very least, the story ought to challenge the comfortable belief that immigrants are lazy and soaking up our social services. The title "Anyone Can Do It" has a double meaning. On the one hand, it's what Lis tells Delfina about work in the orchards, that it's both "easy and hard." Which it is. It's a simple thing to learn, but repeated thousands of times in the heat. The other meaning of "anyone can do it" is what skeptics of immigrant laborers might say, that their lives aren't really that hard, that they've actually got it easy.

Will this story make anyone stop saying that? Because I feel like with the advent of this surplus of great stories our culture is currently experiencing, we're also experiencing a sudden stubborn refusal to be emotionally moved by stories. Maybe we're so used to stories that stimulate empathy in us, we're actually building up an immunity to empathy.

If you're a student looking to this blog for help with meaning or theme or whatever from this story, I doubt you even need my help much. This isn't a difficult story to understand. The meaning is all right there. It's about the tough lessons experience teaches us, about how you can't survive without trusting someone but it's also a great risk, and about the real human cost of abstract political policies. Nobody could read this story and miss those things.

But even if we set the bar incredibly low for what "changing hearts and minds" might look like for a story like this one--if we say, for example, that it's a success if just one person reads it and does not, in his next conversation about immigration, immediately assume the lives of immigrants are easy--will this story succeed? Or is it just written for those who already believe?

It's not the fault of an individual fiction writer that we now live in an age where people can so insulate themselves against beliefs they disagree with that they become impossible to convince. But that's our age. Given how difficult it is to change anyone's mind, what am I actually hoping to accomplish when I write a story? What is anyone?

I don't believe in giving up. We have to keep trying, because to stop trying, to give in to some nihilistic impulse, is to be okay living in a world where nothing we do matters. So people should keep writing, if only to not live in that world. But I don't want to support the false hope that if someone can only write the right story, things might get better. While we have to maybe give ourselves that hope in order to get on with our daily lives, I don't think we can avoid the conclusion that it's probably a fool's hope. It just that it's a fool's hope that's about the only hope we've got.

Friday, October 18, 2019

The Life of William Cowper: The Musical...."Pity and Shame" by Ursula K. Le Guin

The world loves to pander to the nostalgia of my generation, at least while my generation currently comprises the top earners in America. One of the products of this pandering to our nostalgia has been the proliferation of musicals based on the greatest hits of bands people my age tend to like. There's been Steppin' Out, featuring the works of Mr. William M. Joel, Head over Heels, featuring the works of The Go-Gos, Mamma Mia!, and, oh, just a ton of so-called "jukebox musicals."

They aren't good. They wouldn't get green-lit if people my age weren't such saps, but we are. We're indulgent of things that make us sentimental.

If you write great literature over a long lifetime, maybe one day you will have an idea that isn't that great. Something like, "I'll take some key lines from the poetry of William Cowper, then try to work a story around that." And, if you've had a truly exceptional career, like Ursula K. Le Guin has, Tin House will publish your bad idea, because the magazine is about to go out of print, and it's the last thing you wrote after not writing for a long time, and everyone wants another chance to hear from you before you die. Which you will do in early 2018.

Tin House will publish your story a few months after you die, and then the year after, still full of nostalgia, Best American Short Stories editor Anthony Doerr will pick it, even though there were doubtlessly more deserving stories published during the period in question. But you know what, you're Ursula K. Le Guin, and you've earned a little indulgence.

So I'm going to treat the story with the same indulgence. It's too long, has at least two dull expositional blocks, and it uses the word "pity" six times and "shame" or "ashamed" eight times, just in case you missed what the title was. It's August one minute, and then it's July (I can prove it), and not because we flashed back. But there's something worth cherishing at the bottom of this story.

Necessary background


One of the two main characters is William Cowper. Not the British poet of the 18th century, although his work is often quoted and the character is deeply aware of Cowper's works, but a William Cowper in California at some undetermined period late in its gold mining boom. William gets smashed by a cave-in at the mine, and he spends a lot of the story hallucinating. 

While hallucinating, he drifts into some of the poetry of the British Cowper. In particular, he is thinking of "Lines Written During a Period of Insanity." The poet Cowper was temporarily put in an asylum, during which he wrote of feeling like he was sinking beneath the Earth. In the poem, the poet Cowper alluded to Abiram, which brings us to another key allusion in the story. In Numbers 15, Abiram challenged Moses, and Moses basically asks God to make Abiram and his entire family sink into the Earth to show how mad God is that they challenged Moses and God. God obliges. Hence linking Abiram to the feeling of falling frighteningly beneath the Earth.

Finally, there are references to Cowper's "Light Shining Out of Darkness," from which we get the oft-quoted phrase that "God moves in a mysterious way." The first two stanzas of that poem go like this:

                  God moves in a mysterious way
                  His wonders to perform;
                  He plants his footsteps in the sea
                  And rides upon the storm.

                  Deep in unfathomable mines
                  Of never-failing skill,
                  He treasures up his bright designs,
                  And works his sov'reign will.

Now you pretty much have the soundtrack Le Guin is going to work into a story, including turning those "mines" into literal gold mines.

Pity and Shame...and pity and shame and pity and shame

The story never touches on another Biblical moment, the story of Adam and Eve being thrown out of the Garden of Eden, but it could have, because that is the original moment of shame and pity mingled. Adam and Eve eat the fruit and are suddenly ashamed. God becomes angry and casts them out of the garden, but not before he takes pity on them and clothes them to cover the very nakedness of which they have just become ashamed. There is, perhaps, an intricate link for humans between these two emotions, with shame on behalf of one person engendering pity in the other. 

As I've already said, the text does not let the reader forget either the title or the thematic core of the story, as both "pity" and "shame" are written many times each. When the ideas appear, they are typically paired. That's the way it is from the beginning. Rae is nursing William Cowper and comforting him when he has night terrors, when William is still not able to understand what has happened to him. Rae is pitying him. Meanwhile, he hears himself crying, but cannot even tell what the sound is. "He heard something whimpering like a dog. It made him ashamed."

When Doc hires Rae to care for William, he tries to tenderly bring up the subject of how she will have to help him use the chamber pot, meaning she'll have to deal with his genitals. Doc gets embarrassed, and Rae's reaction is measured because of this: "She might have been angry or embarrassed except that he was embarrassed..."

We tend to think of pity as a terrible consolation prize for someone when they are in love and hoping to be loved in return. But Rae discovers that pity can be a stronger emotion than passion: ""...holding and handling the hurt helpless man all the time, she was as close to him as she had ever been to Pete, but in a different way. There was no shame in it. There was no love in it. It was need, and pity. It didn't sound like much, but when you came to the edge between life and death where he was, and she with him, she saw how strong pity was, how deep it went."

She then realizes that when she was making love to Pete, her bum of a man who mercifully takes off, leaving the story free of him soon after William shows up, the infatuation made her care less about other things. But pity makes her care more.

Moreover, pity for William has driven shame away. She has felt shame for much of her life because her mother spent some time as a prostitute. But with William, her pity for him has taken away the sting of shame. She actually loses track of her shame too much, and flaunts in front of one of a nasty visitor to William that although she had been living with Pete, but wasn't married. She gets all red, and thinks that "it didn't make any difference if she wasn't ashamed. Other people were. They were ashamed for her, of her, that she lived among them. They blushed for her. Their shame was on her, a weight, a load she couldn't get out from under." (SEEEE!!! It's like Cowper's load that buried him!!! Parallelism!!!))

We get some sections from Cowper's point-of-view, and he's feeling a lot of the same things about pity and shame: Much of what she had to do for him was embarrassing to him, shameful. It would have been unbearable if she'd felt the same way about it. She didn't. She took necessity for granted. She was grown up."

Somewhere in this onslaught of observations about pity and shame, we get introduced to the final allusion." MacIver first mentions the "God moves in mysterious ways" idea, although he's not aware of it coming from Cowper the poet. It's just something he says when he hears Cowper's life story.

But Cowper the miner is intimately familiar with Cowper the poet. He's got his book of poetry in his chest, along with a copy of Dickens' Little Dorrit. Rae reads Dickens one night, because they're tired of her reading from the Biblical story of Abiram, which brings on one last shame/pity pair as the doctor falls asleep listening to Rae read to William, then cusses as he wakes up.

Oh, also, somewhere in there Rae feels guilty for having looked in William's trunk, although she did it for good reasons, but her shame makes William feel "pity so sharp, so urgent, pity like a knife stab." Just to make sure everyone knows why the story was named thus.

The story comes to a close as William hears the local church singing hymns on Sunday morning. He can't stand it, so he sings Cowper's "Light Shining Out of Darkness" to a tune of his own devising.

What to make of all this pity, all this shame, God working mysteriously, and gold, gold, GOLLLD?


It's clear the story wants to say something about pity and shame. And why not? They're both incredibly strong human emotions. Shame, in particular, doesn't get enough credit for being socially useful and an unbelievable motivator. When asked why they didn't run away under fire, most Civil War soldiers gave some version of not wanting to feel ashamed as their answer. And pity is very close to empathy, which is quite possibly the single most basic human emotion, without which no other emotion worth having is possible.

But I'm not sure what the story wanted to say or make us feel about pity and shame. The story felt like it threw a bunch of strong elements into a stew and hoped they'd make the reader feel something. The most obvious passage where I felt this was when William was thinking about the mine collapse that maimed him: "Men dug tunnels after gold, he thought, but they didn't build them right. If they'd take pity on each other and themselves, they'd build right. At least shore up their ratholes with timber you could count on." This was a rather awkward attempt to bring together disparate elements in the story: gold and God's mines, pity, the mysterious ways of God, etc.

In the end, this is a story with three very skillfully drawn and likable characters, characters who interact in some way and think thoughts about pity, shame, and God's will. It gives us a happy ending, as if to agree with the notion that God is working all things out according to His will for the good of those who love Him.

I don't know if it was an earned ending. But it was an earned ending to a career and life for Le Guin. This story would never have seen the light of day if it had been written by an unknown, but I'm willing to accept it as the imperfect last attempt of a great mind to say what was still unsaid as the end drew near. Pity, shame, empathy, strong binds that seem to apply even when we meet strangers...there's something there, and if we don't get a story that quite unearths the gold of what that something is, we can at least enjoy knowing that treasure exists somewhere.