Sunday, September 27, 2020

MCAM seems more in line with human nature than ACAB

I've loved Lebron James since I first saw him put on a Cleveland Cavaliers uniform, and it confounds me how many people seem to hate the guy. More than just the fact that he has haters, what gets me is who the haters are. I get it if you're a fan of a team he's taking apart and you're sick of seeing him score against you. I hated Michael Jordan in a limited sense back when he used to tear up the Cavs. But fans who rip on him for everything from his hairline to how square he is to how he's 3-6 lifetime in the finals--never mind how without him, none of those teams would have even been in a finals--make no sense to me. Lebron James should never be getting real hate from his own community, whether than community is Black people, people from Ohio, or basketball fans. 

Lately, he's also been getting some hate from outside his community, namely whatever politically conservative pseudo-celebrity Fox News can get to say something negative about James in front of a microphone. James, if you don't know, has been mildly critical of police and American systemic racism in general. He isn't really that radical in what he's said. For example, he doesn't condone violence toward police at a time when some really are claiming it's time for violent struggle against the enforcers of state control. Still, because James is the best player of his generation, when he takes a stand like criticizing the police who shot Breonna Taylor, people pay attention to him more than they do to other players. Which means when some UFC fighter wants to play to his base, he goes after James, calling James a spineless coward for being woke. (I'm not linking to a story about this idiot. James has dealt with it with the same dogged perseverance and ability to ignore haters that have made him the best.) 

I don't understand why any politically conservative person would attack James. If you're conservative, you have no beef with James. He's the opposite of everything you worry about. He's a family man. He respects women. He doesn't wear his pants low. (These are, by the way, all reasons he sometimes gets grief from his own community.) He might disagree with you politically, but if you are on the side of maintaining order, you want people who disagree the way James disagrees. You ought to promote James, ask why more people objecting to police can't do it in the civil way he does. 

Why some white people are so incensed with James

I was just talking to a relative from Ohio who said she was more concerned about racial tension in America than coronavirus. She told me she "hates Lebron James" and hates all athletes, because she's tired of athletics being a platform for athletes to make political statements. I think the hatred comes from two places. First is the maybe understandable and instinctive dislike for what sounds like complaint from people who are better-off, financially, than the fans watching the sport. But that's always been true, and it's only now some people are suddenly waking up to it. The second reason, though, is deeper, more convoluted, and based on assumptions that are harder to confront head-on.

Okay, Lebron maybe works the refs a lot, although maybe his feelings of being picked on on the court are an overflow of how picked on he is off the court. 


Traditionally, we have rightfully respected those who do dangerous jobs on our behalf. That healthy respect, though, has occasionally broken containment and gone right into hero worship. First responders are heroes, and the thing about a hero is that if you say anything bad about heroes, they can't be heroes anymore, which means to make any kind of criticism doesn't just mean you're saying they're human, you're saying there is nothing about them to admire at all. 

The prevalence of slogans these days like ACAB ("all cops are bastards") is itself an unintended consequence of our culture's long worship of first responders. When people learn, through ubiquitous video footage previously unavailable, that police aren't perfect, the way we expect heroes to be, they sometimes assume that only the opposite pole is possible: if cops aren't heroes, they must be evil. 

That flies in the fact of human nature

But any kind of assumption that follows the formula "all _____ are ___" is likely to be untrue. I don't have to be either naïve or an apologist for police to think this. It's not an ideologically extreme position; it's a position that comes from even the most casual observance of human nature and the most basic understanding of statistics. 

What is true about human nature is that most people are somewhere in the statistical middle of ability and effort that combine together to give output. They exhibit average amounts of moral courage and ethical integrity. That's just mathematical reality. It's tautological, even. An average human is average at most things. All cops aren't bastards. All cops aren't anything. But most cops are mediocre, just like most people are. 

You can sometimes cheat statistics by providing an environment where you only attract those who are good at certain functions. The New York Philharmonic doesn't have 100 members of average ability such that only one of them can play anywhere near well enough to perform at the level needed. They have screened for the best of the best of the best, music-wise, and even a bad player in the Philharmonic is better than almost anyone else in the world. It's like that in the NBA, too. The guys Lebron makes fools of every night are people who would destroy an average division-one college player. They'd score on me without even knowing I was there trying to stop them. "Average" in the NBA isn't "average" in absolute terms. 

Ideally, we'd like it to be that way in all professions, but I'm guessing it isn't like that in the profession you, gentle reader, work in. It's certainly not true in mine, although I work for a company that does a lot more screening than most. Most of us have at least a few truly average people at our work, people who aren't any more suited for what we do than a person randomly picked up off the street might be. 

What kind of "average" are the police? 

If the police don't do a good job of screening, then an average police officer is more or less an average person, which is to say, pretty mediocre. That's not the case, though, because the police screen candidates. The question, then, is how tough the supply of officers relative to the demand allows police departments to make the screening. Are the police like the NBA, where even their worst are so much better than normal people at the skills that go into police work we regular folks couldn't even begin to question their ability to do the work?

I doubt it. There are a few hundred NBA players. There are a few thousand professional musicians in city orchestras in the country. But there are about 800,000 sworn police officers. It's hard to image that many people spent their whole childhoods trying to perfect the skills that go into police work the way pro basketball players or musicians did. With greater repercussions for screwing up than most of us face and pay that is a living wage but not enough to get past mid-middle-class, the police just aren't going to be able to make "average" for a cop mean what "average" for an NBA player means.

I've heard a lot of folks these days who are critical of police compare police to airline pilots. They say that the repercussions of a police office making a critical mistake are so dire--involving human lives as they do--that we have to get to a place where no critical mistakes are made. 

I understand where this thinking is coming from, but it also runs against facts, facts having to do with sticky things like averages. An average airline pilot can go her whole life without a fatal accident. An average police officer, however, is less able to avoid mistakes. This isn't a judgment of police, it's just a very obvious statement of facts. There are many more accidental shootings of people who weren't a threat than there are airplane crashes. 

When I explain what systemic racism means to me, I say that for me to go to college and end up in the middle class means I just did what nearly everyone I went to high school did, but for the students Mrs. Heretic taught to do that means they'd have to do what almost nobody they knew did. You can't use a few high performers who beat the odds as examples and say that proves there isn't a problem with the system. Your system is only working if it works for most people, if an "average" person can succeed in it. 

The same is true of police work. If an average cop has to do work that requires more than he can deliver, is the fault really with the officer? Or is the fault with a society that sets up an average police officer to fail? Have we tried to fix issues in our society with the cheap band-aid of police work, then ended up wringing our hands when our cheap fix doesn't work? 

We can criticize cops like this, but don't we all have days at our work like this? And don't most of us still succeed? Police work has to be such that an average officer can succeed at it, just like our work is. 

The effect of average cops on good ones

The police try to set themselves up so that an "average" officer can succeed through regulations and rules. There is a standard procedure for everything. But the procedures are meant for the mediocre police, and even more for the bad ones. For good police--and there are good ones, just like there are high performers in everything--the rules are just another impediment to doing work well. They're there because some dumb guy ruined it for everyone. We all face this in whatever work we do. Of the many things a good police officer likely has to deal with, bad co-workers are probably at the top of the list. 

I've heard a lot of people claiming that good police are just as complicit as bad ones if they don't spend their whole lives trying to stop the bad ones, but I don't find this realistic. It's one thing to report clear bad behavior when you see it, but trying to change an entire culture that's not really working (and does anyone work in a job where the culture doesn't seem set up to keep everyone from accomplishing the main objective?) is a lot to ask of someone. To be able to both perform well at one's core function in a system that makes it difficult, then also to pay attention to all the other bad performers who are a big reason why your job is so hard, well, that's something only the very best of humanity can accomplish. And we've already established that people like that are going to be rare in a police force. They're rare anywhere. We can't criticize cops for not being the superheroes our society has always claimed they are. The idea isn't to have a job only heroes can do. It's to set up the work so an average worker in that field can do it. Ideally, you'd like to have the average ones succeed while not messing everything up so the good ones can't do it better. 

That's the society people are really calling for when they're advocating for police reform. Not one in which police are unrealistically forced to be heroic everyday, but one where they can do the work needed at a sustainable level for the average person the police are capable of recruiting. This probably would mean fundamental change all over society. It could mean reimagining whole facets of civil society. It will almost certainly mean higher taxes. 

Simply calling for greater accountability won't cut it. That's like demanding your city's basketball team play better when I'm the point guard.  

Saturday, September 19, 2020

Pulled in too many directions

I've probably posted the "I'm done with writing" thing a half dozen times in the last few years, and so far, it's never stuck. This isn't that post, because I don't think it's going to stick now, either. This is just to let folks know why I'm not posting much nor will be posting much. 

About six years ago, when I wrote the first of a few "I quit" posts, I referred to a monumental decision I thought I'd made in my twenties, one I later repented of. I vowed then that I'd care more about making great art than about having a family, because anyone can have a family but only a rare few can make great art. Or something like that. I don't really know what I said, because the text in question no longer exists, which is probably for the good. I wrote a lot of strange things in the years after I got out of the Marine Corps. The Marines scrambled my brain a bit, and it took me a few years to get it scrambled back. 

Anyhow, what I'd decided by my thirties was that the "art first, family second" philosophy was morally bankrupt. I'm not totally sure what changed my mind. Maybe it was several things. For one, yes, the people who produce art are rarer than the people who produce human beings, but there's still plenty of art to go around. There's not a shortage of supply relative to demand. Or maybe it's just that I didn't want to be like William Faulkner, drinking on my daughter's birthday when she'd asked me not to because, "Nobody remembers Shakespeare's daughter." Or maybe I just thought that I have a limited time on Earth, and being good to the people around me is a more guaranteed way to use that time well than writing a novel is. Whatever the reason, while I have occasionally had to fudge family responsibilities in order to write, I've never forgotten that family is more important. If I write a novel people are still talking about in a thousand years but fail as a father, then I've wasted my time.

Given that those are the rules I've set up for myself, it's been really hard to find time to write. Not just write, really. Anyone can probably carve out a few hours a week to slap down some kind of prose. Finding time to write seriously is what's hard, meaning to not just write but read good writing, think about good writing, write about good writing, make drafts of my own writing that I strive to make as good as the best of what I'm reading. Maybe even participate in the literary community a bit and also pay attention to some advice on the best way to find places to publish what I've written. It's a lot. Professors are always grousing about not having time to write, which I understand, but it's family, not work, that is the real strain on a writer. 

I've avoided putting this out there for the public to see, but now that COVID-19 has all children in America home-schooling, I don't worry so much about it now. We pulled our son from school at the end of the 2018-2019 school year, and we've been home schooling him since. He was massively under-performing relative to what standardized tests said he should be able to do. A lot of it had to do with him being bored, and therefore not paying attention to what he was supposed to do, then when I emailed teachers to find out what he was supposed to be doing, not getting answers so I didn't know how to make sure he stayed on task. I figured however hard it would be to do it myself, at least I'd know what he his work was.

So for a year and half, when I get home from work, I spend a few hours working with him. He still doesn't do the greatest work for me, but occasionally, he does something that lets me know the lights are still on up there for him. I'm relatively certain he'll be able to pass a GED in a few months when he turns sixteen, and then he can be free to find his own path a little bit. At least, that's the dream. 

Until then, I'm still really straining to keep up. We can't work a full 5-6 hour day every day, so I have to settle for 2-3 hours days that we also do on weekends and holidays (and the summer). We just do a little bit every day, and in that manner, we've kept up with more or less a high school workload. 

Add to my family responsibilities that I have begun to feel lately that I haven't focused enough on my skill as a translator, meaning I've been reading Korean texts instead of fiction in English, and you can see why I don't feel like I'm really working as hard as I need to with writing to get anywhere. Yes, reading Korean literature is probably helpful to me as a writer, because it makes me think outside my own linguistic box, but it takes me a long time to get through Korean literature. My reading time is more than double in Korean what it is in English, and I'm not a fast reader in English. 

Which is why this is just to say I'm not really quitting, but since half-assing it isn't any better than quitting, I don't know what I'm doing with writing, either. I've had to stop my analyses of Pushcart stories. When Best American Short Stories come out in a few months, I don't know if I'll do those, either. 

That's a shame, because I really like doing it. I think it's an important contribution to the literary world, because there's a paucity of online resources for people to go to for help when they feel a little lost by the stories they read in the top anthologies. More than that, I know it's been good for my own fiction writing to focus so deeply on some of the best writing that's out there. Even when I don't like a story, that helps me refine my own ideas of what it is I do like and what I want to do as a writer. 

That's all just a long way of explaining why I haven't been around much and might not be for a while. Maybe it'll get better when the boy passes his GED. Or maybe I'm so into Korean things now, I never get back into writing. I don't know. I'll at least help the world to a gratuitous political rant now and again in the next few months, no doubt. 

It's been great how many people have tuned in for stuff I've written about short stories, especially BASS. Even if those folks just help themselves to an explanation or two and then run off without saying high, it's always great to me to see that a hundred or so folks stop by every day, mostly for short story explanations. Something I wrote became a part of the day of people I don't know. That makes me happy, and probably will never stop making me happy.  

Saturday, September 12, 2020

Cancel culture isn't new, but it does feel different

I lurk on a lot of writers on Twitter, usually to my own great sadness. Writing-community-Twitter isn't any less stupid than the rest of Twitter, and it's maybe even sadder to see certain social pathologies you'd expect of dumber people being repeated by those I'd hope would know better. There are exceptions. I'm happy to say Danielle Evans, who has written two of my top five favorite short stories I've looked at on this blog, has never written a dumb tweet. But a lot of people whose writing I admire or who are icons post ignorant stuff all the time. 

The subject of cancel culture comes up a lot on Twitter. The consensus of the writing community is that it's neither new nor a violation of anyone's rights. It's just, as a friend of mine put it the other day, "voting with your wallet with better alliteration." And in a sense, she's right. There have been books banned and records burned and tea dumped for a very long time. 

Something does feel different, though, about some cycles of cancellation that go on, and I think it's related to a more fundamental change in our culture. We have less tolerance now, I believe, for what my law school (that I attended for three weeks before dropping out) referred to as "things reasonable people might disagree on." 

There are a lot of terms in law where the definition seems a bit circular, but with no word is this more prevalent than "reasonable." Essentially, the definition of "reasonable" in law comes down to "thoughts or actions that reasonable people might hold or do." Well, how do you know if someone is reasonable, then? Because other reasonable people hold them to be so. It's one of the most frustratingly tautological merry-go-rounds I've ever experienced. 

The difficulty of defining the word doesn't mean we don't have some practical sense of what we mean by it, though. A belief is reasonable if one can explain why one believes it with inferences from facts. I take a pretty broad interpretation of reasonableness, at least for issues that concern shared life with others in a democracy. Beliefs I'd call "reasonable" include a lot of beliefs I think are pretty obviously false, but for which one can at least construct some kind of string of logic. For example, a Christian who thinks Christ literally rose from the dead, and who uses some form of apologetics to defend that belief. A more fundamentalist Christian who thinks the universe is 7,000 years old strains reasonableness a good deal further, but even then, I'm not sure I'm willing to say the person who believes such a thing could never be reasonable. There are probably Young Earthers out there who could score higher than I have on cognitive tests. I'm sure there are Young Earthers who make good doctors or engineers or mechanics, things that take a good deal of logical deduction. 

What I'm getting at is that there is a difference between an unreasonable belief and a belief I happen to think is wrong, even if I think it's really obvious it's wrong. In a civil society, we probably need to maintain a fairly broad view of what is reasonable to believe. 

Alas, I think we're headed in the opposite direction. People are tired of arguing for their views and having others reject them, so we're now much less tolerant of even countenancing the existence of those who think differently from us. Their very existence is an affront to us: We've given our best argument, and still they aren't convinced! Clearly, something is wrong with them!  

The latest "cancel Netflix" flare-up is a good example. Some people thought the movie sexualized young girls, while some critics loved it. Clearly, if people who make a living evaluating the quality of movies, people who have earned financial support from the community for their ability to evaluate those movies, think something had merit, then it is at least a reasonable thing to think it has merit. That doesn't mean they're right, only that they are not insane to think so. For someone who disagrees, the proper action is to raise your own argument that the movie sexualizes girls, not to demand that others take action. Calls to action should be reserved for clear wrongs, when something is going on that defies reason. A movie that reasonable people disagree about is not a place for such a call to action. 

A lot of people were especially upset about this ad for the movie. I can understand that, although there are girls this age sexualizing themselves much more flagrantly on Instagram. 


I suppose one could say that by such a standard, nobody would ever act on anything. One problem in the Internet age is that every belief, no matter how cockamamie, has its defenders. You can find YouTube channels full of people arguing for a flat Earth. Does that mean those people are reasonable, since they are at least arguing from logic, albeit badly, for their position? Should we not work to enact environmental legislation because some people out there produce "evidence" for why climate change is a hoax? 

That's essentially just saying, though, that defining reasonableness is hard. The existence of an argument doesn't guarantee reasonableness. But just because something is hard to identify doesn't mean it doesn't exist. That's why serious analysis of art is so useful, because it's all about terms--beauty, insight, excellence, hell, even whether a movie or book is "good"--that are difficult to define but that we understand in some way. Analysis of art teaches us how to think about these kinds of concepts, but in a sandbox environment where nobody gets hurt. We can then use what we learn from analyzing art to deal with real-world problems. 

The way to deal with the difficulty of establishing reasonableness is to patiently keep explaining one's view. That's what the best arguers do. A sign of someone who really knows something is that they are confident enough in what they believe that the existence of doubters does not trouble them. They don't need to call to get rid of doubters. 

All of American society seems to me to be acting a lot like the church youth group I was in as a teenager. We see those who think differently from us primarily as opportunities to evangelize, but once they reject our evangelism, our attitude is that we shouldn't cast our pearls before swine, that we should come out and be separate from them. What we have, then, is a nation intellectually balkanized into camps that not only don't talk to each other, that just don't like each other. 

The stupidest comment I've seen on writing Twitter lately was this: "Do Republicans even write poetry?" As if a moderate Republican who generally thinks market-based solutions are preferable to government-directed ones is incapable of being dumbstruck by the sublime. If it's true that conservatives don't appear much in the poetry world now, that says more to me about problems with the poetry world than it does about Republicans. 

If we think those who disagree with us are so fundamentally broken they can't even understand and love poetry, how can we ever respect one another enough to run something as complicated as a democracy? 


Sunday, August 30, 2020

The quest for a better kind of lie: "The Last Voyage of The Alice B. Toklas" by Jason Brown

One of the best things about The Pushcart Prize anthology every year is the way the editors choose works which compare or contrast well with other selections in the anthology. By doing this, the anthology isn't so much seventy to a hundred separate, individually-wrapped treats as it is a real snapshot in time of what bright, literary minds were thinking about, arranged in such a way that the stories call unto each other, each to each. There's a conversation. There's even something which is lacking in actual literary society, at least online anyway, which is meaningful divergence of thought. 

The big three anthologies--Best American Short Stories, The O.Henry Anthology, and Pushcart--all strive for diversity. BASS and O.Henry usually accomplish it in a rather rudimentary way, it seems, trying to make sure the identities of the authors meet a number of the intersectional markers: race, gender, sexual orientation, etc. This partially succeeds at its goal of displaying a wide variety of compelling voices, but sometimes it's a little light on the "compelling" part. Pushcart features writers who are usually somewhat less established and less big-name, writers who are still figuring out what they want to say and who therefore might say anything. It's exciting. Pushcart aims for compelling writing first and tends to get diversity in the bargain, while the others aim for diversity first and struggle sometimes to also get something compelling. The writing in Pushcart reads like stories the writers HAD to write, things they'd die if they didn't say. Some writing in the other journals comes across as what a professional writer felt she OUGHT to write. 

Jason Brown's "The Last Voyage of the Alice B. Toklas" did not have Malerie Willens' "Scandalous Women in History" in mind when it was written, but juxtaposing the two, as Pushcart has, makes both stories more interesting. By mining what American literature produced in a given year, the editors have added value to both stories for the reader by making the reader aware of how two stories were in unintended conversation with one another.

So what was this conversation?

Like Willens' story, "Last Voyage" is about that time-honored idea that we have some control over our own realities through the stories we tell ourselves. John Howland is a fifteen-year-old kid living on the coast of Maine with his grandparents. His lives with his grandparents because his mom left for no more apparent reason than she was bored, and his father is gone for reasons the family won't talk about. His family are the stubborn kind of New Englanders one hears about, the kind who refuse to even mention certain words:

"In our family, if you wanted to speak of John Updike, you spoke of “the stove,” not, as Uncle Alden sometimes called it, “the Aga.” Likewise you could say “Lewiston” but nothing about the dowel factory my great-grandfather had bankrupted. Nothing about China Lake, where my father spent most of his time, nothing about my mother, who had gone to live among the Rarámuri of Copper Canyon."

In other words, his family deals with things they'd rather not exist by pretending they don't. It's a fascinating and often somewhat effective human adaptation to an unfriendly reality. John is working a summer job bringing the mail from the mainland to Howland Island, named, you'd think, although it turns out the reason it's named Howland Island is another one of those things the Howland family doesn't talk about. His grandparents spend most of their summers on the island hating the tourists who live around them for driving up their property taxes. 

There's a writer living for the summer in the small house in the back of John's grandparents' place. He gets a letter from his publisher, which starts the action in the story. John is at an age where he's trying to learn for himself how to adapt this habit for re-making the world as he'd like it to be by making things up. He's starting with telling stories about himself, but he's not that skilled at it yet. He tries to convince the writer that he's bonded for the mail he delivers by skiff from the mainland, but the writer's not buying it: "No, you're not. You're a kid. Kids don't get bonded." 

Throughout the story, John learns the art of remaking himself through artful bullshit. He doesn't learn it from the writer. He learns it from his grandfather. Grandpa's got a couple of good, time-tested classic saws he keeps coming back to. John already knows not only how Grandpa tells the stories and that they're fake, he knows how Grandpa tells them. One story is that the giant stove in the kitchen used to belong to John Updike. Another is is that Grandpa went to Harvard with Updike. Others have to do with the boat they take the writer for a tour of the island on, the eponymous "Alice B. Toklas" from the title. 

Grandpa also pulls some new bullshit out of his pocket John hasn't heard before. He convinces the writer he's some kind of bucolic literary scholar. He does this by fobbing off especially insightful phrases concerning Don Quixote to the writer. John later learns that these are all cribbed from Nabokov. The writer is so blown away by Grandpa's literary insights, he encourages Grandpa to write a book. Word then gets out all over the island that Grandpa is writing a book, when in actuality, he's just writing an old-man-crackpot letter to the Tax Assessor of Georgetown, Maine, complaining about how his property taxes keep going up. 

John eventually learns a few tricks from Grandpa. He takes the Ray-Ban sunglasses given to him by the writer and puts them on at the end. They make him feel like a different person, and he decides to actually become a different person, too. When a girl he's been eyeing from afar notices him and asks, "John, is that you?" he responds with: 

"No," I said in a voice I didn't recognize, and voice I'd been waiting to hear. "It's not." 

"Finding your voice" is a pretty common narrative arc for characters, but for John, it's important that finding his voice means actually finding a new one, one that will allow him to break free from his provincial boundaries while still cherishing them. He's learned to re-make himself into what he wants to be by simply believing his own bullshit. 

I could end it there with what is a pretty simple narrative arc, but that doesn't do justice to the story, which is a lot like Updike with its cast of quirky characters interacting with unintended humor and regional flavor. Every line of it oozes with such charm, I felt like one of those annoying tourists reading it, oohing and aahing over every little idiosyncrasy that, to these characters, would have just been their normal life. There's a reason Karen Carlson loved this story so much. I don't usually write much about how enjoyable a story is to read, but the enjoyment and fun of this story was so much up front while reading it, I can't ignore it. The reader gets as swept away as the writer in the story does by Grandpa's tales. It's great regional fiction that can stand with the best American short stories we're all raised on in 10th grade American Lit. It can stand with Twain or Updike or Irving. 

Friday, August 28, 2020

Capitalism might not be the worst thing ever: "Scandalous Women in History" by Malerie Willens

My expectations about this story were wrong twice. First, the title lead me to believe it would make some kind of strong feminist statement, but that's not what the story was at all. Secondly, once I realized it was about a young woman who works at an upscale makeup counter, starting with her first day as she learns the business, I thought it would be a scathing critique of the industry, and maybe of capitalism itself. 

This second possibility hangs on much longer, as "Scandalous Women" doesn't shrink from depicting the false hopes, false claims, and phony science that hangs like fog over the makeup counter. Even the characters' names are false. Kim, the protagonist, is rechristened "Kendra" for her job, while her mentor Dane was actually once Douglas. At the outset, the Remy counter at Saks Fifth Avenue is a place to tell gullible people lies about "intrepid ribosomes and their unctuous promises," to hawk "the soothing emulsion, the stalwart pentapeptide, and the light-deflecting pearl." 

The cast of characters is basically three, with Jade, the manager, thrown in as a stock character. There's Kim/Kendra, who has come to the job after a summer off and a past full of petty theft she learned from her mother. There's Douglas/Dane, who has gone from closeted gay to over-sexualized gay to now semi-balanced gay who is the star of the makeup counter. He always makes customers believe the crap he's saying. Kendra wonders whether they aren't taking advantage of the suckers who come to them, but Dane doesn't give it a second thought. His attitude is that if they walk away feeling better, then they got what they paid for. Dane believes in "whatever helps," and it's clear he thinks that he is, in his way, helping. He himself claims to take anti-depressants, although he's not depressed. He believes in not overthinking things. 

Then there's Nadia, who is from Romania but hates it when people hear that she's Nadia from Romania and think of gymnast Nadia Comaneci. Nadia's mother is the closest thing to a "scandalous woman" the story really gets to, unless we consider Kendra's mother scandalous for the way she stole things. Nadia's mother is a poet and a bit of a political activist in Romania. 

Shopping therapy...works?

So I thought we were all set up for the fake world of the makeup counter to come into conflict with the "real" world, the one Kendra tries to speak up for when she goes out to drinks with Nadia and Dane: 

"Do you ever feel bad?" Kendra asked him.

"About what? Why should I feel bad?"

"I think she means about lying to the people," Nadia said.

"Lying, schmying. The people feel great when they leave me. Everyone knows confidence makes you prettier."

But selling something awful and expensive that you know doesn't work?" said Kendra.

"Please. Nothing works. Name one thing that works."

It's interesting to read a story that sort of takes the side of the dispensers of untruth at a time when so many people are worried about the Barnum-like manipulation of voters right now. 

So I thought we had a triangular relationship between Dane, the apostle of bullshit, and Nadia, who might have enough grounding in the real world to not get sucked into the bullshit, and Kendra, stuck between the influence of the two. I thought the conflict would be about which way Kendra would go. But it wasn't that at all. 

Instead, a note Kendra receives changes the narrative completely. It's a weird note someone left on the counter for her, possibly a secret admirer, although the note is kind of strange as admirer notes go, so it's not really clear what the intention was. The note says things like, "I am the indentation on the pillow just after you've left bed." Or, "I'm the cowlick you comb down, the cleavage you hoist up, the wart that keeps growing back on your thumb." 

Kendra isn't sure what to make of the note. She thinks Dane might have sent it to her and made it look like it came from an admirer just to mess with her, so she repackages it and gives it to Dane, also disguised as a secret admirer note. Dane doesn't seem to react to it, but later, it turns out he gave the note to Nadia, mostly to make her feel better. Which it does. Kendra notices a marked changed in Nadia's behavior: "Her posture seemed straighter and she moved even more briskly than usual. She even spoke more assertive English with her customers." 

Dane confesses to Kendra that he secretly gave the note to Nadia, not knowing (unless he's playing an incredibly brilliant con) that Kendra first gave it to him. Which means Kendra really did get a note from an admirer. (One could, I suppose, concoct a reading in which Jade, the unnoticed manager, is actually the one who wrote the note, because she is playing six-dimensional chess with her employees' psychology, but I don't think that reading adds much to the action.) Kendra realizes that this has been a positive experience all around: 

"Kendra's relief felt like a tropical breeze. She really did have a secret admirer who was not Dane; neither Dane nor Nadia knew the note was originally hers; Dane was kind and generous for giving the note to Nadia: and she had made them both feel desired. They had all three been given the same note."

Kendra, in other words, realizes that it doesn't matter what the truth of the note is if it has the desired effect, which is pretty much what Dane has been saying. When a second note arrives, one that is somewhat incoherent, making Kendra realize her admirer is probably deranged, it doesn't make her value the experience less. Instead, it strengthens her realization that truth is what we tell ourselves it is.

The final scene is Kendra helping an older customer get ready for a date. Kendra makes the woman feel far more ready for her date than she would have been, helping her to overcome feelings of intellectual inadequacy. The woman leaves feeling "dangerous." Kendra has just been told by her manager she's doing a good job. She feels she might have found her calling. She has suffered for a long time from feeling not so much vain, but guilty about her vanity. Her job has taught her that everyone has this problem. Like alcohol in Homer Simpson's proclamation, marketing's promises about beauty are both the cause of, and solution to, all of Kendra's problems.

It's not unlike Joshua Ferris's And then We Came to the End, which seems for much of the novel that it's going to be a harsh critique of advertising, but in the end, makes the most sympathetic character the manager of the advertising agency who decides to keep working at her job through a terminal disease. The narrator says he set out to write an anti-advertising book, but in the end, found that sympathizing with the industry and those in it felt truer. That seems to be the arc of "Scandalous Women in History," too. The name of the story comes from a line of makeup the main characters have to push to customer. The line has colors named for women like Jezebel and Delilah and Eva Braun. It's commercialism at its crassest, using transgressive icons to reinforce conformity to commercial values. But dammit, it works. It makes 58-year-old Bea feel "dangerous." 

It's not a new theme, the idea that humans have a unique ability to shape our own reality by what we tell ourselves about the world, but it's told in a fresh way. (Karen Carlson has more to say here about this theme.) Moreover, it's nice, when the whole world is zigging with "capitalism is killing us" messages, to get a story that zags a bit in the other direction. Whether it's saying capitalism is actually somewhat good and there's a reason we choose to live this way or simply that it's possible, given the inevitability of the system we live in, to find happiness within it, is a matter of interpretation, but either way, it's at least a message not being broadcast much these days. It's the Pushcart Anthology at its best, showing an intellectual independence the other anthologies rarely exhibit. 

Thursday, August 27, 2020

Two kinds of fool: "The Entertainer" by Whitney Collins

America has a long racial history of wanting minority groups to entertain the majority. The cliche, which remained prevalent in acceptable American discourse up to the mid-20th century, of the black minstrel is an example of this. According to the cliche, black people are intrinsically good-natured, happy, and ready to sing and dance, which white people encouraged them to do for the enjoyment of white people. Given this long history, I assumed, at the beginning of "The Entertainer" by Whitney Collins, that the protagonist was a person of color being asked to entertain a rich white family:

"Mrs. Billingsley asks Rachel's mother, not Rachel, if Rachel would like to accompany them to the beach for two weeks. 'There's no television, no A/C. It's almost embarrassingly primitive, but Rachel is just so entertaining. Such a delight. I know she'd make my girls happy.'"

But this is different kind of minstrelsy being forced on Rachel here, one based in class, rather than race. Rachel has come into contact with wildly rich teens Devlin and Davenport Billingsley at a tennis camp--a camp Rachel's mother had to pay for with a credit card--and apparently, Rachel did something there to catch their interest, or at least the interest of their mother. We don't learn exactly what it is she did, but it's clear the two rich girls enjoy experiencing Rachel's "normal" life vicariously. Rachel, who did not want to go but was forced into it, understands her role as a "jester to the elite," someone who can "introduce the joyless to the concept of joy--if not in a way they can experience, at least in a way they can witness." 

The jester, or fool, can work in two ways. The fool can be the butt of jokes, but the fool can also "punch up," as we say nowadays, speaking truth to power through humor in order to get away with saying what needs to be said. The fool can have an important social role by subverting the social order and questioning power structures. 

Rachel doesn't seem to have much power over whether she is going to be a jester, but she might have the ability to control what kind of jester she becomes. Will she be the object of jokes or will she be the one doling out the punishment?





It turns out Rachel's not the only joker in her family. Her father left in order to follow his dream of being a comedian. He seems to be largely unsuccessful at it, working on catch phrases in front of small audiences, some of whom heckle him to "give it up, man." But her father has stuck to it, believing "he deserved--his word--applause." Her father, then, aims to be the kind of jester who punches back, but usually ends up as the punching bag. 

We only see the first day of Rachel's trip with the Billingsleys. They fly by private jet to a private Caribbean island. The Billingsley girls are terrrible--think Kardashian or Hilton-level of decadent and wasted. 

"Devlin and Davenport lean across the narrow aisle to punch one another in the upper arms for a time, back and forth like papier-mahce marionettes, until their arms are red and welted from shoulder to elbow. It's as if both have been grabbed and shaken by a middle-aged lover who's discovered he's been jilted for a pool boy.

'Trucey-trucey?" Devlin asks.

"Vodka juicy," Davenport answers.

Rachel isn't sure how she is going to fulfill her role as designated entertainer for the girls, but her first success leans in the direction of being made fun of rather than making fun of others. She eats while the girls, who are starving all the time so they can one day marry rich men, practically achieve orgasm watching her. After polishing off a huge lunch, Rachel takes three bows as the girls watch.

It looks like it's going to continue like that, with the girls playing a game where they try to say things poor people would say, and Rachel judges whether the things they say are accurate, eating Skittles for their entertainment if they get it right. Then the girls ask what Rachel's father does, a question she dodges by saying he's an entertainer. The girls say that their own father also likes to entertain, throwing parties with magicians or piano players. Once, he brought an owl. Davenport remembers being stunned that the thing was so beautiful. 

The girls then pass out, drunk and high, but Rachel can't stop thinking about the owl. Did it get startled and start to fly around the room? This is the moment of Rachel's transformation. (Karen Carlson looks at this transformation in terms of intrinsic and instrumental values here.) She doesn't want to be like the owl, giving the rich their money's worth while she gets her feathers petted. The denouement has Rachel speaking to Mrs. Billingsley, who is getting hammered in Rachel's bed and trying to tell Rachel to do whatever it takes to marry well. Mrs. Billingsley also asks Rachel to teach her girls something--anything--useful. Rachel, now just annoyed and seeing through the ruined rich for who they are, says she can, then imagines the surf sounds like applause. It seems to me at this point that she's imagining herself one day eviscerating people like the Billingsleys and being applauded for it, turning herself from object of joke to the one dishing it out to those currently laughing at her. Even though it's not a first-person story, one could potentially read the narrative as her origin story of how she came to be the Robin Hood of derision, stealing esteem from the rich to give to the poor. 

A few quibbles

It's a tight story, well-conceived and well-plotted out. The main theme, which asks the reader to answer the question of what kind of jokes you're going to tell to those with everything, is good stuff. There were a few small issues I had with the structure, which I point out more as an example of how hard it is to write a perfect story than I do to suggest the story isn't solid. 

First, the story is cut up into sections separated by line breaks. There's nothing unusual about that, but two of the first three sections have an omniscient POV, navigating between Rachel's mind and her mother's mind. After that, it's all third-person limited from Rachel's POV. Given that we don't keep coming back to Rachel's mother and she's not a character who undergoes any change in the story, it feels a little like cheating to jump inside her head at the beginning in order to flesh out Rachel's world a bit more, only to abandon the mother once she's no longer needed. 

Secondly, Rachel notes at one point that the Caribbean "sounds different from other oceans." If Rachel is, in fact, from a family struggling a bit, so much that tennis lessons set them back, I wonder how many oceans she could have been to and how often in order to be able to compare the Caribbean to them. 

Last, while I understand the principle of punching up, and the Billingsleys, as the worst form of America's debauched rich, deserve it, the story seems to rest a little too easily in the notion that rich people turn out to be morally reprehensible. My own experience is that while it would be nice to think the rich are always repugnant, the fact is that rich people often turn out to be really wonderful people. When you have the luxury of not worrying about how you're going to make ends meet, you have time and space to develop things like empathy. It's us who scrap for everything with each other who have a hard time being magnanimous sometimes. Rich people aren't the ones who are astounded owls even live somewhere other than a forest in Germany. They're the ones using their wealth to save the owls, because they went on some amazing vacation as kids and have never forgotten their encounter with the owls there. 

Those are minor things, though, and don't take away from my admiration for how the story said so much with so little space. 


Wednesday, August 19, 2020

"Reading other writers will affect my voice while I'm writing" is a baseless fear for most of us

This blog used to be full of either complaining about the difficulties of advancing as a writer or occasional advice to developing writers on the rare occasions when I felt like I'd figured something out. In the last few years, it's tended to lean more toward my own idiomatic version of literary analysis, one inspired by literary theory, literary criticism, and the genre of Protestant sermons. Occasionally, I've looked at movies, TV, or novels, but mostly, I've been focused on short stories. 

I don't know if my readings of short stories are good, but I know this much: the deep concentration on the stories that's necessary to write something at least halfway sensible about them has made my own short stories better. I know this from the empirical evidence, such as writing provides. I've been accepted in more journals and a few more highly regarded journals than I used to. I've also gotten far, far more positive feedback from the elite journals than I used to. (They completely ignored me for years up until a few years ago.) But I also know it because my own inner reader looks at what I write now, especially after I've had time to get away from it, and is just a lot more satisfied with it. Sometimes, I've even surprised I wrote it. 

I could really sum up everything I've learned about writing in the last seven years with some really obvious advice. If you want to be a writer, read a couple of books on how to write, then read a lot of whatever genre it is you want to write in. More importantly than reading a lot, read closely. 

And I could leave it there, but there's a concern a lot of writers have. Some really good writers even have mentioned it. They're concerned that if they read a lot of other writers, especially while they're deep in the process of writing something themselves, the voice of the person they're reading will bleed into their own writing. Some writers have said they completely cut off input once they start writing for this reason. 

It's an understandable concern. Writers want to have their own style, not just imitate someone else's. Certainly, when I'm writing, I tend to cut off input, although for me it's more because when I feel the urge to write something, I don't want to interrupt it with anything else. It's more about striking while the iron is hot than it is about keeping my voice pure. I've only got so much time, and when I've got words to put down, I tend to make that my priority. 

But let's grant it's a valid concern. I still don't think it's a reason to keep developing writers from reading broadly and deeply, even while writing. (In fact, if you're going to follow the advice some give to write every day, that would mean you could never read if you wanted to avoid reading while writing.) 

There are two reasons. First, while developing, it's unlikely that accidentally picking up influences from the best can do anything but good for your writing. It's a lot like how you suddenly play tennis better after watching Wimbledon for a couple of weeks. As long as you're not flat our trying to transcribe Pynchon into your own auto-biographical-based story, the influence is probably a good thing. It's not going to magically make you Pynchon, but it can help you unlock new levels. 

The second reason is that even after you've started to develop your own style and voice, you didn't develop it out of nowhere. It's always been a mix of what you've read and the unique impact that had on your psyche. It's always been a tension between what's inside you and what's coming at you, trying to change what's inside of you. That tension doesn't stop while you're writing, even if you avoid reading. Reading just makes it more overt. At least you'll know where the voices in your head are coming from.

All writing is a lot of hard work that you hope serendipity somehow takes a hold of. That's why it's so devastating to lose something you've written. People might think, well, you wrote it once, you can write it again, but it isn't like that. It's like how Sauron couldn't make a second ring because he'd put too much of his own power into the first one. Once you write a thing, you've kind of emptied that part of you into the work, and the things that were coming together to make the you who wrote that work will never coalesce in that same way again. Reading while writing might mess with your voice, but it's possible it will mess with your voice in a way that's interesting, that the new hybrid will be something you never thought was in you. Because it literally wasn't until the second you wrote it.