Sunday, January 24, 2021
Don Draper diplomacy: How the U.S. could move forward by going backwards
Sunday, January 3, 2021
Social media and the writer's happiness
Saturday, December 26, 2020
The limits of literary fiction: a wrap-up of Best American Short Stories 2020
![]() |
| I have no doubt editors are always working hard, but books get published on slower schedules than the ones used by general contractors. |
The establishment's effect on aesthetics
Monday, December 21, 2020
The story I thought would never get published
Sunday, December 20, 2020
Hero's journey for the black man: "The Special World" by Tiphanie Yanique
Every year, when I read through Best American Short Stories, there are at least a few coincidences that make me think the order of stories was chosen on purpose, even though I know that the stories are put in the sequence they're in based solely on the alphabetical order of last names of authors. This year's collection has probably set a record for the number of times I've felt like the stories are doing a call-and-answer with one another, and the final story in the collection, "The Special World" by Tiphanie Yanique, does it more than any other story. Not only is it a story about a black character struggling with trying to understand what authentic blackness is when surrounded by white norms, making it a perfect bookend to "Godmother Tea," the opening story in the collection, it also contains a reference to a Mahalia Jackson song, like Carolyn Ferrell's "Something Street," and it plays with the notion of invisibility, much like Kevin Wilson's "Kennedy," the story just before "The Special World." If guest editor Curtis Sittenfeld intended to pick not just twenty stories she liked, but twenty stories that somehow actually worked well together in spite of not having been written with the collection in mind, she succeeded mightily.
This final story is playing throughout with a well-worn way of looking at classical literature known as the "hero's journey." Concocted by Joseph Campbell, it's an attempt to find common traits in many heroic stories in world literature. You can Google it and find a number of graphic representations of the stages of the hero's journey, but I'm going to use the one that seems to be the closest to that which "The Special World" is playing with.
Obviously, some stories fit the model better than others. I first learned about Campbell's model in college when we were discussing Star Wars. It fits well for stories like The Odyssey or The Hobbit. As Yanique will point out in her story, though, it doesn't fit everything, and you probably wouldn't want it to, because "anything that follows a formula is useless anyhow."
The basics of the formula are that someone is living their normal life, then there is a call to go on an adventure. The hero resists the call before finally answering it. Once on the journey, the hero faces a series of trials that begin to change the hero. Finally, he faces one, singular defining trial which changes him so profoundly, the old him dies, leaving a new, resurrected version of him in its place. This resurrected version then goes back to the ordinary world, but as a changed man, meaning the ordinary world around him is changed, too.
I have to admit, I was a little leery of the story at first, because it seemed to be making more out of college than I think it deserves. College does, certainly, forever change most people who go, but it's also a rather ordinary part of life. To give college epic status seemed a little overstating its importance. (Also, it just reminded me of "A Different World," an 80s/90s Cosby Show spinoff about students at an HBCU.)
But once I got to the end, I realized that this story was trying to appropriate Campbell's model for black men, to bend it and break it until it fit a little better, and the experiences of Fly, the main character, do fit this new model. Or, rather, they show why it's so hard to make a model for black men.
The story is split up into nine sections, all of which fit some version of Campbell's model, with one exception. I'll follow that order while analyzing the story.
Section One: The Ordinary World
In Campbellian theory, this is the status quo for our main character. In The Hobbit, Bilbo lives a life of quiet content, although he has adventure in his blood and doesn't realize it. His life is made up of peacefully moving from one meal to the next, punctuated by smoking his pipe. This is the world that will be upset and which the main character will have to leave.
For Fly, the main character of "The Special World," his ordinary world has been the life he's lived with his parents prior to the first day of college, when his parents drop him off at the dorm. Unlike other students, Fly doesn't want them to come in. He goes to his room and skips orientation.
Fly's ordinary world, his status quo, seems to involve an indelible loneliness. The night prior to coming to school, he'd felt "nervous, and alone in that feeling." His loneliness seems to be re-inscribed, rather than erased, by the situation in the dorms. Whereas many college freshman find themselves living for the first time with people unlike any they'd ever known, Fly has a single room. He's one of the few students who does. His RA, Clive, struggles to figure out why. He assumes it's because Fly has some kind of serious allergy.
Section Two: Call to Adventure
Fly's real call isn't just going to college; it's being asked to go to church off campus. Suzie and Arthur, two white people, ask him to go. They're apparently very into their church. This doesn't seem like much of an adventure, either, on the surface: for many people, going to church is very much part of their "ordinary world." But we'll learn later why it's part of the "special" world.
Section Three: Refusal of the Call
Things are going well for Fly at college. He's hanging out with people from his Intro to World Religions class, smoking pot at parties, listening to typical freshman pseudo-profundity and spouting off some of his own. He's got no time for church, because who needs it?
One of the stoned comments of freshman insight bears looking at. It's the notion that religion provides a socially acceptable avenue for male homo-erotic behavior. This is going to come up again.
Section Four: Traversing the threshold
In this section, Suzie, a.k.a. Sue, a.k.a. Suzanna, depending on which version of herself she's being, is walking away, and Fly is literally at the threshold to his dorm room, watching her leave for church without him. Fly's happy to let her go, but when Clive specifically tries to warn him that this church is a cult, suddenly, that is the intervention that spurs Fly to go. If Clive's against it, then Fly is for it.
As soon as Fly enters the special world, the world beyond the threshold to the normal, he finds, somewhat Matrix-like, that the world he thought was the "ordinary" world was actually hiding secrets. At one point, while still in the ordinary world, Fly saw people of color eating together in the school cafeteria and wondered where they were all hiding all the time, because he hardly ever saw any. Once at church, though, he realizes that Suzie and Arthur were also people of color. In fact, the church seems, suddenly, once his eyes are opened, to be full of people of color: "All the people of color were camouflaged. Maybe they had been around Fly all the time, and he'd been too self-absorbed to notice. Maybe he was camouflaged too."
Perhaps Fly's essential loneliness can be cured, now that his eyes have been opened. He's not alone. There are others like him. Perhaps this is why Clive, the white dwarf who had tried to guard the threshold to the special world, wanted to keep Fly from attending. Clive pretended to be Fly's "brother," although not in the jive sense, but in reality, he may have been part of the white power structure trying to keep Fly feeling isolated.
Section Five: Tests, Allies, and Enemies
Immediately after going to church, two things happen to fly: he is in love with Suzanna, now that he knows she is black, and he is tired all the time. We will learn in a later section that Fly had porn at home. The porn collection was magazines of black girls on the top and white girls on the bottom, as though he was secretly attracted to white women, but had to cover it over with an attraction to black girls. One of his first thoughts when he thought Suzie was white was that he couldn't bring her home to his parents.
Suzie seems to solve the riddle for Fly of how to resolve his attraction to both black and white girls, because Suzie, the lightest-skin black girl he's ever seen, can be either.
The "tests" in "Tests, Allies, and Enemies" are actual school tests. The allies are his new church friends. I was momentarily a little disturbed trying to figure out who the enemies are, because it seemed like the only possible enemies in the chapter are the Jews who claim they aren't really white. There's Clive, of course, but he's one enemy, not enemies, plural. Which means the only other possible enemies seemed to be the Jewish kids. However, once viewed from the end, it's possible to read the Jews as allies, albeit unexpected ones Fly can't quite get his head around, while Suzie and Albert are the real enemies in disguise.
Section Six: Approach to the Innermost Cave, or, The Meeting with the Goddess
Section Seven: The Ordeal
Section Eight: Atonement with the Father
This is the section title that doesn't really correspond to Campbellian theory, although fathers are an archetype Campbell does discuss. Fly's father, we find out, has been dealing with mental illness his whole life. His father also, for some reason, kept a sex tape with a former girlfriend, a tape that ended up in the inner sanctum of Fly's porn collection.
Fly has apparently had a lot of resentment built up against his father, and it comes to a head when the father decides to leave his mom. But when his father hands Fly Invisible Man by Ralph Ellison, there is suddenly a truly holy moment, the moment when the father is giving his son the real esoteric knowledge that the secret world was supposed to reveal to him, because he is presenting his son with the sacred text that can explain all the reasons for Fly's essential loneliness. There are limits to the applicability of the Campbellian formula for a black man, because the formula was never written with black men in mind. Rather than a cycle that can help relieve Fly of his loneliness, the hero cycle for a black man is more about understanding why that loneliness is somewhat unavoidable.
Just as the story has altered Campbell's steps to meet Fly's needs, though, it has no intention of sticking closely to any model, even a model as revered as Invisible Man. As we'll find out in the next section, ""Anything that followed a formula was useless anyhow," so Fly needs to find a new template for the hero's journey, one that fits his experience as a black man in America in his time.
Section Nine: The Road Back
Turns out his sleepiness was mono. Turns out, Suzie gets engaged to Arthur, the man she was saving herself for, the man God created for her. So maybe her "sluttiness" with Fly really was missionary sluttiness after all. Far more damaging to Fly's heterosexual black male image than Clive thinking he's gay is the fact that Suzie only was having semi-sex with him because she thought he might be. Fly has returned to his ordinary world, which is to say, to his fundamental loneliness: "So Fly was alone again."
Is he changed? Has he come back from the special world a different man, such that he can change the ordinary world around him? An important part of the Campbellian cycle is resurrection, the moment the character comes back from the special world, reborn into the ordinary one. We are told there is no resurrection possible for the father, but is it possible for the son?
It's hard to see how. Fly's self-image is even worse than it was before. It isn't that some people have thought he was gay, it's that being authentic and vulnerable and intimate is so automatically linked to homosexuality; since Fly knows he's not gay, he feels like all the other things that are assumed to be part of homosexual identity--things Fly really needs--are not for him. Fly has been made to think that his loneliness is because he longs for an unmanly intimacy, when in fact, it's got nothing to do with sexual identity. "Just because I was lonely doesn't mean I was gay. And was lonely what gay people were anyway?"
If there is redemption for Fly, it isn't that he'll be able to escape being lonely. It's that he might have a greater understanding of what it causing his loneliness.
Karen Carlson at A Just Recompense paid more attention to something I only alluded to, the importance of vulnerability in this story. For her take, go here.
Thursday, December 17, 2020
Why we homeschool our son: "Kennedy" by Kevin Wilson
Like a lot of people, I had more time in 2020 to watch television than I've had in past years. We're supposedly living in the Golden Age of American Television, and every week there's another series on all the four main streaming services that gets rave reviews, so there ought to be a lot to interest me. But I sort of feel like the Golden Age has already passed. Most of the shows everyone is praising seem to me now like a reiteration of some earlier show, an attempt to recreate the magic that has the form but not the soul that made the original worth watching.
Some of the exceptions are shows about adolescents, like Netflix's Big Mouth and Hulu's PEN15. Adolescent shows have always been built around humor that takes advantage of the awkwardness of being a teen. These shows aren't an exception, but they also don't overlook how deep and lasting the psychological damage of teen years can be. Particularly the fourth season of Big Mouth, which just came out this month, is equal parts sex/scatological humor and also a sensitive portrayal of how what we tend to write off as routine nuisances of youth can lead to long-term psychological disorders.
Kevin Wilson's "Kennedy," the next-to-the-last story in Best American Short Stories 2020, is another in this line of stories about adolescence that take what happens in the teen years seriously. "Kennedy," however, doesn't share the humor of the best shows tackling the subject. (Although much like PEN15, it features two friends, one of whom is Japanese in a town where there are almost no other Asian kids.) "Kennedy" gets dark fast:
John F. Kennedy was a boy in our high school, but he went by Kennedy. For a brief time, he made things pretty bad for us. We’d started our junior year without ever having exchanged a single word with him, had only seen him as he stalked the hallways, his long, greasy hair covering his face, his Coke-bottle glasses. He always wore this olive green military jacket with the name KENNEDY stitched across the right breast. Underneath that, he seemed to have every single Cannibal Corpse T-shirt in existence, a never-ending parade of skeletons and knives and blood and people with the skin ripped off their faces. He wasn’t allowed to wear the T-shirts at school, since they were against the dress code, so he wore the jacket over them, even when it was hot out, and if he sensed your weakness, he’d open his jacket and flash the T-shirt at you as he passed you in the hallway.
You'd think that naming the kid JFK would mean there was some kind of idiosyncratic humor on its way, but it's mostly absent. The story is a recollection of how the narrator and his best friend Ben allowed Kennedy to abuse them, terrify them, and, ultimately, to come between them. It's reminiscent of a lot of stories sexual abuse victims tell, mainly because of the way the victims find themselves too shell-shocked to fight. The narrator, Jaime, thinks it's maybe because he was coddled by his parents, leaving him "without street smarts, with no sense of how to navigate high school."
![]() |
| Charles Baxter said that hell is full of great stories, and for many people, the closest they got to hell was high school (or junior high). |
Whatever the reason, when Kennedy throws a backpack at Ben and Ben doesn't complain, the psychopathic Kennedy realizes he can have his way with the two friends. There are a number of reasons they feel they can't complain to adults. One is simply that it will "embarrassing." Another is the apathy the adults demonstrate; the teacher in the art class where Kennedy deals out much of his abuse is recumbent on a recliner most of the time because of the pain in her back. As caring as their parents are, they don't know how to ask the right questions to find out what is troubling their children. Ben's mother asks about the first day of school, but Ben and Jaime don't give her an honest answer. "How would we even begin to describe Kennedy? What could be done?" they ask themselves. " And that was that. It was like, in missing that moment when things were still normal, we had given up any chance of controlling Kennedy’s effect on our lives. He had us. If he wanted us, whatever he wanted, he could have us."
There's a lot more of this kind of language in the story, all of it consistent with what many other survivors of abuse have told, the difficulty of explaining why you found yourself unable to resist. I've taken "resiliency training" before, and a lot of it had to do with learning to "get off the X," meaning how to not be a target for this kind of abuse. Abusers are experts at knowing who they can abuse and get away with it. It's actually a very normal human reaction, this freezing up, which is why this story is so consistent with what so many abuse survivors have to say:
Looking back on it, I want to take myself and just shake and shake, like, What the fuck is wrong with you? Why did you let that happen? But I can still remember those moments, when it felt like I was paralyzed inside my own body, like I had to pull myself deeper and deeper inside of myself, away from the surface, in order to stay alive. I think Ben felt the same way. We tried not to talk about it.
Invisibility
At one point, the narrator claims that now, as an adult looking back on it, he understands why he was unable to fight back. (He also claims at other points that he doesn't understand, but that's to be expected. Looking back on a traumatic event, you're likely to feel both epiphanies and subsequent undoing of the epiphanies.) He feels that he and his friend Ben had practiced being invisible for so long, they didn't know how to ask for help, because that would have involved trying to be noticed: "Now I understand it: we had stayed invisible for so long that we weren’t used to people noticing us, and so when Kennedy noticed us, shined a light on us, we simply froze, simply sat there and took it, all these little indignities, and hoped that he would fuck up in some other class and get suspended, a temporary reprieve."
Jaime likely meant that most high schoolers, unsure of who they are and terrified of the scorn of their peers, which seems to whirl around with the caprice of a prairie wind, find it safest to just keep quiet, go along, and not make noise. This is, in fact, the safest thing most of the time in high school, which is why it's so hard to realize when it's the thing that is putting you in danger.
Bug, not a feature
Is there hope for Jaime?
For Karen Carlson's take on this story (she thought it was equally compelling), go here.
Wednesday, December 16, 2020
And now, my post of great shame: "Enlightenment" by William Pei Shih
My blogging pal Karen claimed that I didn't really take a pass on a story earlier in BASS this year when I claimed I was taking a pass, but this time, I really am taking a pass. It's getting harder and harder for me to blog on stories I don't like, and I don't like "Enlightenment" by William Pei Shih at all. I'd actually read it before BASS came out, when it appeared in Virginia Quarterly Review. I didn't like it then, but I hoped when I got around to reading it a second time as I was blogging through Best American Short Stories, I would find something a little more to like about it. I didn't. There are some stories where I find trying to come to grips with what I didn't like about them to be nearly as interesting as a close reading of a story I did enjoy, but I'm not feeling that way right now. The longer I'm a writer myself, the more I think how shitty it is to do a negative reading, especially of stories that aren't going to get a lot of other critique written about them. As backwater as my blog is, there aren't many other folks blogging on BASS (or short stories in general), so if I write that I don't like it, that's likely to be what a lot of students of BASS find when they look for help on Google. I'm okay doing that with someone who's already had a successful, long career, like T.C. Boyle, but I really don't want to do it for someone like William Pei Shih.
Essentially, I think there is a mismatch in the story between form and function. The main character mentally inhabits a world of 18th-century writers who almost all indulged in verbal excess, but the prose is ultra-pared down, like reading Carver or some other hard-edged, no-nonsense 20th century writer. I believe the point of the story is supposed to be that its main character, Abel, studies the enlightenment his entire life, but never achieves his own enlightenment. Instead, he pointedly relives the lives of the cautionary tales from the very texts he treasures. He battled himself to overcome institutional prejudices, but failed to help the next generation to overcome the prejudices they faced.
Which, fine, but it seemed to me like a lot of the story was a summary of a story. It had the feel of an "Introduction to the Age of Enlightenment" seminar, where there was a felt need to talk a little bit about every major thinker from the period, instead of focusing on one or two key texts. It all left me feeling like most introductory courses do--like I haven't really learned much about anything, but did hear about a lot of things I wish I'd learned more about.
That's all I can say. It's not fun for me to do this. I'm not Tweeting this post, I'm not talking about it anymore, and I'm posting it here quietly in the middle of the day hoping nobody ever reads it. I feel like I have to at least post something to say I read it, because it was in BASS, but that's really all this post serves to do.
While it does nothing to remove my feelings of having failed at this story, Karen Carlson at A Just Recompense kind of felt the same way.


