Sunday, January 24, 2021

Don Draper diplomacy: How the U.S. could move forward by going backwards

It's probably always a little dangerous to apply principles from interactions at a personal level and apply them to nation-states. For example, drawing lessons from the economies of individual families and suggesting countries should do similar things is usually an imperfect analogy, because debt means different things to nations and families. When I was an evangelical, most believers I knew would twist themselves into knots trying to show why "turn the other cheek" was an individual principle, not one for countries to apply to their militaries. Whether their hermeneutics were sound, I can't say, but it's clear they knew somehow that this had to be the way to read it, because reading it the other way would have meant the end of the American way of life they enjoyed. 

While respecting that what applies at an individual level may not make sense at a macroscopic, national level, we can still use metaphors and similes from everyday life if we're just using them the way metaphors and similes are meant to be used: figures of speech of limited value, meant only to illustrate one particular ground (point of the comparison) through a specific vehicle and tenor (thing and other thing it's being compared to). 

Mad Men and America


I have a fondness for reading the show Mad Men as an allegory of America, or at least a fairly extended metaphor for America. Don Draper especially seems to me like a microcosm of the United States in many ways. His past is poor farm life, but he pretends the real him is flash and dazzle and top-of-the-line new products and Madison Avenue. He tells himself his past doesn't matter, and that through thinking only of the promise of the future, he will find salvation. In the clip from the show that Netflix used over and over for its preview segment, Don waxes rhapsodic about happiness, which he seems to understand well when he needs to use happiness in a cynical way to sell something, but doesn't understand at all when it comes to finding his own happiness. 

One important characteristic to Don Draper's America is that every generation has its war. It's just assumed you have one, and admission to the grown-up table in America means you have to be able to talk about the war you were in. Roger Sterling has World War II, and is, therefore, the one who feels most entitled to his creature comforts, because World War II was obviously America's greatest moment. Don had Korea, the "forgotten war," but even forgotten wars mean you get to consider yourself a man in America with all the benefits that brings. The show takes us from the end of the fifties to the end of the sixties, and Don's identity crisis that becomes progressively more difficult for him to manage mirrors the identity crisis of America. Part of that identity crisis is a country asking itself the question of whether every generation really needs to have a war. 


(Like a lot that Don Draper says, I tend to think this speech sounds more profound than it actually is. A lot of his dazzle is bullshit with a high production value.)

The firm loses the cigarette business


For a long time, the firm Don works for has Lucky Strike as its biggest client. The company does some humiliating and even immoral things to keep the horrible client and the business he brings, but eventually, Lucky Strike abandons them. The firm is worried about losing the income from the account, but even more worried about how they will be perceived. If they're seen as a smaller firm that just lost its biggest account, they'll have a hard time getting other accounts to take Lucky Strike's place, because other clients will assume they're on life support. 

Don comes up with a unique strategy, one he doesn't clear with the other partners in his firm. He puts a full-sized ad in the Times, one that says, "Our company is never going to work for another cigarette company. Cigarettes are bad for you. It's a poisonous product. Our company will be happy to work for companies that don't sell cigarettes." 

His other partners are furious. Over the course of the show, the strategy does backfire a few times, as some clients are leery of working for the company that bad-mouthed a former client in the press, but overall, Don's gambit does what it's supposed to: it changes the narrative of how his company and Lucky Strike parted ways. As Don's future wife puts it: "I get it. She didn't dump you. You dumped her." (Applying yet another metaphor from personal life to something on a larger scale.) 



America might be losing Lucky Strike soon


America has been a great world power my entire life. They've been a great world power for the entirety of my parents' lives. We're so used to being a great world power, we've forgotten the country could get along just fine without being one, but we likely could. We might even be better off. 

It's already been a long time since America has been THE world power, if there ever even was such a time. The term "post-hegemonic world" has been around for decades, and if anything, it's a truer phrase now than it once was. Perhaps the only thing making it less true is that China is stronger now than when the phrase was originally introduced, and China also seems to have achieved something of an alliance with Russia, making both stronger. Meanwhile, the U.S. has temporarily, at least, weakened some of its own alliances, although probably not irreversibly so. Nonetheless, the U.S. holds even less of a share of total power than it once did, and long-term, may keep losing ground.

Presidents promise different paths to regaining some of this lost power in the world: either through strength (military, economic) obtained after a competitive struggle, or through cooperation, a cooperation in which America is always the lead partner. 

But why this obsession with being seen as a world power? Will it really be the end of us if we aren't in the same position of solitary strength we are accustomed to? Aren't there plenty of countries in the world that have a great standard of living without being world powers? In fact, isn't the lack of burden of being a world power part of what helps them achieve that standard?  

Artificially extending the era of America as a world power isn't buying us time for us to weather the storm of the latest challengers, after which we'll come out back on top. If anything, it's just going to make the landing harder. It's driving up our debt on things that won't make us better in the long run, which robs us of the improvements in infrastructure, education, health care, and public-funded science and technology research that could improve our long-term outlook. 

We could also include soft power projects in the list of things that could help re-shape the new America and its role in the world. Increasing the amount of foreign aid we give could be one way to offset Chinese influence in parts of the world. U.S. companies do partner with those in the developing world, but not in a strategic way designed to increase U.S. influence the way Chinese state-owned companies do. The only way for the U.S. government to offset the coordinated Chinese effort is to launch one of its own. We can't tell a U.S. company to build roads and power in Zimbabwe, but we can pay for these kinds of projects directly, giving countries an alternative to giving the Chinese footholds all over the world. 

The point here isn't to shift competition from the military arena to soft power, but to change America's basic outlook on the world from a sphere of militaristic competition to one where we seek to share the benefits of an essentially non-militaristic people. For most of America's history, we have actively sought to stay out of world affairs. We became a country strong enough to alter world history precisely by not seeking this strength until we had to. 

I'm not talking about naivete. China wants power. Russia wants power. They're willing to push the boundaries of what's acceptable to get them. They both have ways of life that involve invasions of personal liberty we consider unacceptable. We need a strong enough deterrent to be taken seriously, but we don't necessarily need to match one-for-one every strength China has. 

Much of America dreads the moment when we are no longer a great world power. I actually kind of look forward to it. Obsession with world power is a distraction for us. The Constitution shows no trace of a desire for world power. It's not in our political DNA, and the only way we've been able to sustain our quest to keep our power has been to continue to ignore the spirit of the Constitution, giving the president far more power than anyone ever dreamed of in 1776. 

If we start this shift from preservation of our clout world-wide to concern for our own character and prosperity now, while we still have enough power to be taken seriously, we can claim we did this on our own because of an awakening on our part. We will be seen as a country that willingly changed its interactions with the world in order to be more consistent with the better angels of our nature. In a future world looking for alternatives to whatever the dominant power to come may be, America is more likely to be seen as genuine and good, a partner countries would want to have, if we start this exit from world power status now. 

We can spend the next decade or two in a quixotic but futile fight to preserve our status as a world power, for reasons that have to do with little more than our pride, or we can try to navigate an exit from that precarious position strategically, so we end up, ironically, stronger precisely because we have stopped worrying so obsessively about our strength. There is a window, though, on when America can change its view of the meaning of power and world power on its own, and when the decision will be thrust upon it, willing or no. 

Sunday, January 3, 2021

Social media and the writer's happiness

Every writer knows you've got to be on social media if you want to sell books. Some would even suggest it impacts your ability to get published in the first place, and I'd say this isn't too far out there as an idea. I've definitely come across publishers I've sent my book proposals to who cared at least as much about my social media reach as the book itself. 

A few weeks ago, I turned my Facebook off, as I often do at the holidays in order to avoid adding to the melancholy I always feel at how little I think I've achieved in my life by seeing how much other people have done. However, a publisher who seemed interested in a book I pitched to him asked last week about whether I was on Facebook. He told me they published authors as well as books. I thought he was concerned about my social media reach for its ability to sell books, but turns out what he really wanted was just to know more about me and what kind of person I am. Either way, I turned my Facebook back on, and all the benefits I'd been enjoying of being off went away. 

Facebook is really nothing, though, compared to Twitter when it comes to creating anxiety. With Facebook, I at least mostly know the people I'm looking at feeds for, which limits how personally I take what I see. If I know the guy posting something is a knucklehead from Canton, I can kind of write it off, but on Twitter, I'm subjected to a non-stop cross-section of thoughts from random people. Mostly, it leaves me with the impression that democracy is doomed. Rather than the questions of whether I'm a personal failure Facebook gives me, Twitter makes me ask what it matters whether I accomplish anything, because the whole world's screwed, anyway.

I've never been on social media to sell books. I was on Facebook back before I even tried writing seriously. My Twitter account, on the other hand, only exists for writing, but my goal isn't to get rich as a writer. The only reason I ever write anything, whether it's a story, a blog post, an email at work or a love note, is to say: the world seems thus to me, am I missing something? I generally write out of a sense that the world is fucking with me, that I'm being gaslit, because conventional wisdom says one thing, but that's not how I perceive the world. I write, generally, out of a sense that either the world is crazy or I am, and I genuinely want to know which it is. I don't necessarily want to SELL books, but I do want readers, because without someone to respond to what I'm observing, nobody can enter into a conversation about whether things seem the same way to them.

Given that I need readers to fully scratch the itch that made me write in the first place, I've figured that having a social media account was a necessary evil, a tradeoff of a little bit of sanity for the more critical big of sanity that comes from being able to talk about what matters to me with someone. (This is why I'm sometimes surprised when writers don't respond at all after I tag them on Twitter about a positive review. Like, you write literary fiction. It's not like you've got thousands of people reviewing your work. I know, because often, my blog is the top Google result for your story. I'm on Twitter to find readers who think seriously about the things I write. So aren't you happy enough to hear from a serious reader that it means at least something to you? I realize I'm offering it gratuitously, but I'm surprised, I guess, that only maybe one in four posts gets even a thumbs-up.)

I'm not sure, though, that Twitter is a good bargain overall. At least one publisher out there has written a pretty convincing argument for why authors shouldn't be on social media. I agree with all three of their reasons: 1) people don't pay much attention to writers on social media anymore, 2) it takes away time from writing, 3) the anxiety it causes will hurt you personally and as a writer. 

Most writers probably need a fair amount of solitude. That doesn't mean they're necessarily "introverted," a word I increasingly think is stupid, just that thinking about the things they think about means the world needs to shut up sometimes. Certainly, there are times when the author doesn't want solitude. For centuries, writers have sought out other minds to challenge them and shared drinks, drugs, and bodily fluids with those other minds. I'm certainly willing to sacrifice solitude to engage with a thoughtful reader, but Twitter seems like an increasingly bad bargain. 

Does this mean I'll be able to ditch it sometime soon? I don't know. Like I said, just last week, someone was interested in something I wrote, and that interest was at least partly conditional on whether I had some sort of social media existence. If I weren't a writer, I think I'd likely be the sort of person who surfs back and forth between having social media and not having it. It's convenient for some things, but it does have an impact on my happiness. 

It's not like I have a ton of followers or anything. I have 71 followers on Twitter. I don't really seek them out, which I guess defeats the purpose of being on in the first place. I'm just motivated enough to do Twitter badly, I guess. I should probably either be all-in or all-out, but I don't really see my relationship to it changing soon. 

Saturday, December 26, 2020

The limits of literary fiction: a wrap-up of Best American Short Stories 2020

I believe this is the eighth year I've read Best American Short Stories now, and I'd put the 2020 edition in the top three of those eight in terms of quality of stories.  One of the unique merits it had, which I'll credit to guest editor Curtis Sittenfeld, was something I alluded to in my post on the last story in the anthology, "The Special World" by Tiphanie Yanique. That is, the volume worked better as a whole than any other edition I've seen. It was amazing how much the stories, none of which were written with the other stories in the volume in mind, responded to one another. Nonetheless, in spite of the excellence of many stories individually and how well they worked together (in fact, perhaps because of how good a volume it was), BASS 2020 also kept reinforcing for me a number of limitations of literary fiction that have more or less been in the back of my mind since graduate school. Sittenfeld's own introduction to the anthology served to crystalize a few of these limitations in my mind:  

1. Literary fiction moves slow: BASS in any given year looks at stories published in the year before. The basic model seems to go something like this: series editor Heidi Pitlor picks 120 stories from however many stories she starts with--likely several hundreds that were originally published between December of the year prior to November of the current year. Pitlor then gives those 120 stories to the guest editor in several batches between November and March of the next year. The guest editor finishes picking twenty by the end of March, the proofs get ironed out, and it gets published in October (COVID-19 made it late this year). 

That means the 2020 BASS featured stories originally published as far back as December 2018, which means the stories themselves could have been written as far back as 2017 or even earlier, since once a story is written, it can take over a year to find a market to publish it, and then another several months for it to be published. 

Both Heidi and Curtis mentioned COVID-19 in their remarks on this year's anthology, but because both wrote those remarks in the early spring, by the time BASS came out, their thoughts were completely overtaken by events. Naturally, none of the stories in Best American Short Stories 2020 is aware COVID is a thing, which means the short story anthology bearing the name of the year the pandemic struck doesn't address the pandemic. That will have to wait until the 2021 anthology. Or maybe 2022, since most of the stories published in literary magazines in 2020 were written in 2019, also before the pandemic, meaning nobody was aware of it in those stories, either. (I wrote a pandemic story in the first weeks of the outbreak. Four of the journals I sent it to have not yet looked at it, to give you some idea of the speed at which literary journals work sometimes.) 

Roxane Gay, writing in a BASS introduction a few years ago, defended fiction writers for not being able to crank out the definitive story on the meaning of the Trump election in the months after it happened. She pointed out that fiction writing doesn't work like that. You can't just say "here is crisis X" and expect writers to produce work on that crisis. Great work takes time to process events. Sometimes, it takes a very long time, in order to get enough distance to get control of the subject. (Here, I think of the first chapter of Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse Five, where he discusses how his anti-war novel was the first novel he tried to write, but he kept failing at it for decades, until he'd written many other books, before he finally knew how to write it. It's worth noting that BASS 2020 had one story in it about the fallout of the 2016 election, "In the Event," reflecting somewhat how long it can take for art to reflect changes in reality.) 

I understand all of that, and maybe it is enough to be able to point, in an emergency, to a book written earlier though the slow-cooking process that seems to respond to something similar. Maybe there was no great novel in 2020 about the pandemic, but there is The Plague by Albert Camus. 

Still, it feels sometimes like how long it takes to create work that responds to current events is a huge limitation of literary fiction. There are TV shows now that work COVID into the story lines. If a TV show, with all the massive logistics that go into it, can respond on that fast a timetable, why can't literature, which really just requires the ability to transmit text? 

Journalism relies on a two-tiered approach. It does both breaking news and longer-term, in-depth reporting. Both are needed to give a democratic society the information it needs to make good decisions. I can't help but feel that literature could also benefit from stories written from the gut in the middle of a crisis, stories that have limited editing and are turned around quickly. 

There are some places where this exists, some journals that turn things around on a dime. But with so many journals out there, it's difficult for any one story to gain enough traction culturally to have an impact on the public psyche. Fiction writing is failing to inject itself into public discourse meaningfully. For better or worse, anthologies like BASS are required to give a busy public the essential reading they need. Even I rely on the anthologies, because there are thousands of journals, and I'm not going to read through them all or even more than maybe a small handful of them, although I likely read more literary fiction than about ninety-eight percent of the general public. But the time lag with anthologies means the stories people read in them are always going to be unaware of today's events. It has the effect of making literary fiction always feel behind the times, maybe even a little irrelevant. 

I have no doubt editors are always working hard, but books get published on slower schedules than the ones used by general contractors. 



2. Literary fiction as a business suffers from both hegemony and post-hegemony. Sittenfeld wrote in her introduction about being "disenchanted with the so-called literary industrial complex," even while admitting she benefitted from being on the inside of this complex. She felt the industry has a penchant for producing buzz not in line with the quality of a work. Everything is supposedly spell-binding or mesmerizing, while Sittenfeld often finds herself bailing on these supposedly spell-binding works early on. 

The reason every work must be praised to absurd levels is because the supply of quality literary work far outstrips the demand. There are still a few gatekeepers with the power to sell enough books for a work to succeed commercially. Oprah. To a lesser extent, Roxane Gay. High-profile reviewers still have some influence, although not nearly as much as they once did. Awards also tend to give book a much-needed shot in the arm. Outside the few lucky writers blessed by these gods, there are hundreds of finely crafted novels every year languishing for the attention they deserve, along with thousands of short stories. It's like an electronics market in Seoul where everyone is selling the same things; the only thing to distinguish them is how loud the person hawking his wares is. 

BASS is definitely inside the literary-industrial complex. It tends to feature more big-name authors than, say, the Pushcart anthology does, and the guest editor is unfailingly a big name. Being in BASS is one of the few gifts the industry can still bestow on an undiscovered author to give her career a shot in the arm. (Although some of the writers I follow on Twitter were published in BASS and now still seem to be struggling.) BASS helps overcome the lack of hegemony in publishing by providing one place where writers can rise above the noise of the marketplace somewhat. It's hard to sell your work as a writer, but if you've been in BASS, you have a somewhat better chance. In that sense, the power of the few remaining outposts of literary establishment strength are of great value to writers. Hegemony is helpful. It might not be great for those outside it, but at least there's a goal to strive toward that, once achieved, will provide writers with some semblance of what they were hoping for. Without an establishment, there could well be a sort of law of thermodynamics of the marketplace in effect in which there are thousands of writers, none of whom can gain enough notice to sell more than a handful of books. 

Or would it? Are markets really not able to self-regulate? Aren't there always a few outsider books that succeed without the help of the establishment, through word of mouth? 

The establishment's effect on aesthetics 


Sittenfeld listed, as most guest editors do, a sort of "what I look for in a story" summary in her introduction. It's pretty similar to what I'd have said while I was an editor with The Baltimore Review, or what I now say as a fiction editor for the Washington Writers' Publishing House: "My favorite feeling as a reader is the confidence that the writer is in control, is one step (or more) ahead of me, possesses a knowing sensibility that he or she is unfurling as the narrative demands." In other words, as readers, we like to have a feeling we're in good hands. I completely agree. 

There's something else I look for in a story, though, that I would describe as the feeling the writer could not help but write this story, that it was eating a hole in her gut, and that she is personally invested in it in much more than a professional sense. Occasionally, this leads to a story, or at least parts of a story, where it seems to me the writer is not totally in control, where it seems the narrative has become so full of fury or passion that the writer is now throwing punches with all his might, heedless of technique or the need to keep his own guard up. Writing with no technique and all passion is unreadable, but writing that's all technique and no passion is unmemorable. 

The literary establishment is useful in that at least some writers can succeed commercially nowadays, but it comes with a cost. The cost is that there is a way to write to get into that establishment and a way not to write. I don't think it's true, as some people charge, that everyone with an MFA writes the same, and I don't believe all the stories in BASS sound the same, but there must be some real thing people feel that makes this such a common statement. 

Maybe it would be accurate to say there is a general center of gravity for the "literary establishment aesthetic." There are certain things a writer does to give editors the feeling of being "in control" of the story, and there are, perhaps, certain political viewpoints that are considered safe, certain topics one is at least advised to stay away from, if none that is specifically recommended. 

On the other hand, the editors of the Pushcart anthology have expressed that a certain unpolished rawness is something they actively seek out. Stories in Pushcart more often seem to speak to issues that affect me on an existential level. They feel more like they were written by people thinking things I think and living the kind of life I live, whereas BASS sometimes has a more rarified feel. (NOTE: This year, Pushcart and BASS overlap on FOUR stories, something I've never seen before.) Not that BASS never allows in outsiders. Clearly, they do. I think every editor strives for balance when putting together a volume, and part of that balance is picking new voices. But the very careful selection of that balance sometimes feels a little contrived, and I might actually prefer something a little unbalanced. The best BASS I've read yet was that one put together by Roxane Gay, which was the one that made the least effort to spread around the demographics equitably. 

Sittenfeld spoke of a middle ground between wide-eyed wonder at the excellence of stories and cynicism about the marketplace. I think there is also, maybe, a middle ground between the well-polished, industry-approved story that makes no impact in the lives of its readers and the written-in-a-coke-addled-weekend raw story of existential dread. Of the stories I thought best from BASS 2020, some fit my "story that felt like the writer had no choice but to write it" criteria ("Godmother Tea," "This is Pleasure," "Rubberdust," "Kennedy," and "Octopus VII") and some did not ("Something Street" and "The Nanny"). Just like a writer can have a burning existential issue and seek to find the fictional technique to fit it, a writer can feel a story come to them from a more aesthetic than existential place, but find the existential importance of the story while writing it. All the stories in BASS 2020 that didn't work for me, though, (and where, unlike Sittenfeld, I don't think it's just a question of the story not being for me, but the story actually not being worth reading) felt like they were written by a professional writer straining to find a story to write about, "The Apartment" being chief among those. ("Liberte" I can chalk up to my own idiosyncrasies, as well, perhaps, as "Enlightenment.")  

I can indulge a writer in almost anything she wants to try, but I cannot abide a writer who does not consider that a reader comes to her work looking for answers to certain burning questions of how to make sense of the world, nor writing that seems as if the writer has left all those burning questions behind her, like only naive and pretentious freshmen like those in "The Special World" ask such questions. I don't have time for writing written by someone who isn't made dizzy continually by being in a world that ultimately makes so little sense. 

Perhaps these two limits of literary fiction, the lack of timeliness and the way establishment fiction sometimes fails to address the central-most questions of its readers, are related. The need for emotional distance needed for art always risks becoming a little too distant, much like the pastor who spends so much time preparing his sermon he is not aware that half his congregation was just laid off. There is both a prophetic role for authors as well as a pastoral one, if I may use that analogy, and in the best writers, the ones who matter most to me, the two roles work together. 

I do not write to indict the literary fiction establishment (which, let's be honest, struggles so much with commercial viability it's a little hard to think of it as an "establishment;" in the big picture, even the giants of lit fic are indie darlings). Obviously, the big names of literary fiction speak to me often enough I spend time every year carefully reading Best American Short Stories, responding to every entry. I mean only to suggest as a reader with existential needs that "establishment" stories tend, when they fail, to do so because they leave me a little cold when I consider why they matter, whereas "outsider" stories, if they fail, do so because the writer has not gained enough control over the thing that matters I learn anything new about it.  

Monday, December 21, 2020

The story I thought would never get published

Although I've been fond of this story since it came off my fingers two years ago, I really thought it would never get published. As a friend of mine I shared it with told me, even though it seems like I'm not making fun of #metoo, it's not so clear that an editor can be sure, so they're just going to be safe and reject it. I finally found one editor at the Maryland Literary Review crazy enough to take a chance on it. See what you think. Wonderfully fabulist tale of wrongs that can't be undone, or white guy spewing nonsense: 

I give you: Collision.  


Sunday, December 20, 2020

Hero's journey for the black man: "The Special World" by Tiphanie Yanique

Every year, when I read through Best American Short Stories, there are at least a few coincidences that make me think the order of stories was chosen on purpose, even though I know that the stories are put in the sequence they're in based solely on the alphabetical order of last names of authors. This year's collection has probably set a record for the number of times I've felt like the stories are doing a call-and-answer with one another, and the final story in the collection, "The Special World" by Tiphanie Yanique, does it more than any other story. Not only is it a story about a black character struggling with trying to understand what authentic blackness is when surrounded by white norms, making it a perfect bookend to "Godmother Tea," the opening story in the collection, it also contains a reference to a Mahalia Jackson song, like Carolyn Ferrell's "Something Street," and it plays with the notion of invisibility, much like Kevin Wilson's "Kennedy," the story just before "The Special World." If guest editor Curtis Sittenfeld intended to pick not just twenty stories she liked, but twenty stories that somehow actually worked well together in spite of not having been written with the collection in mind, she succeeded mightily.

This final story is playing throughout with a well-worn way of looking at classical literature known as the "hero's journey." Concocted by Joseph Campbell, it's an attempt to find common traits in many heroic stories in world literature. You can Google it and find a number of graphic representations of the stages of the hero's journey, but I'm going to use the one that seems to be the closest to that which "The Special World" is playing with. 



 

Obviously, some stories fit the model better than others. I first learned about Campbell's model in college when we were discussing Star Wars. It fits well for stories like The Odyssey or The Hobbit. As Yanique will point out in her story, though, it doesn't fit everything, and you probably wouldn't want it to, because "anything that follows a formula is useless anyhow." 

The basics of the formula are that someone is living their normal life, then there is a call to go on an adventure. The hero resists the call before finally answering it. Once on the journey, the hero faces a series of trials that begin to change the hero. Finally, he faces one, singular defining trial which changes him so profoundly, the old him dies, leaving a new, resurrected version of him in its place. This resurrected version then goes back to the ordinary world, but as a changed man, meaning the ordinary world around him is changed, too. 

I have to admit, I was a little leery of the story at first, because it seemed to be making more out of college than I think it deserves. College does, certainly, forever change most people who go, but it's also a rather ordinary part of life. To give college epic status seemed a little overstating its importance. (Also, it just reminded me of "A Different World," an 80s/90s Cosby Show spinoff about students at an HBCU.) 

But once I got to the end, I realized that this story was trying to appropriate Campbell's model for black men, to bend it and break it until it fit a little better, and the experiences of Fly, the main character, do fit this new model. Or, rather, they show why it's so hard to make a model for black men. 

The story is split up into nine sections, all of which fit some version of Campbell's model, with one exception. I'll follow that order while analyzing the story. 

Section One: The Ordinary World

In Campbellian theory, this is the status quo for our main character. In The Hobbit, Bilbo lives a life of quiet content, although he has adventure in his blood and doesn't realize it. His life is made up of peacefully moving from one meal to the next, punctuated by smoking his pipe. This is the world that will be upset and which the main character will have to leave. 

For Fly, the main character of "The Special World," his ordinary world has been the life he's lived with his parents prior to the first day of college, when his parents drop him off at the dorm. Unlike other students, Fly doesn't want them to come in. He goes to his room and skips orientation. 

Fly's ordinary world, his status quo, seems to involve an indelible loneliness. The night prior to coming to school, he'd felt "nervous, and alone in that feeling." His loneliness seems to be re-inscribed, rather than erased, by the situation in the dorms. Whereas many college freshman find themselves living for the first time with people unlike any they'd ever known, Fly has a single room. He's one of the few students who does. His RA, Clive, struggles to figure out why. He assumes it's because Fly has some kind of serious allergy.  

Section Two: Call to Adventure

Fly's real call isn't just going to college; it's being asked to go to church off campus. Suzie and Arthur, two white people, ask him to go. They're apparently very into their church. This doesn't seem like much of an adventure, either, on the surface: for many people, going to church is very much part of their "ordinary world." But we'll learn later why it's part of the "special" world. 

Section Three: Refusal of the Call

Things are going well for Fly at college. He's hanging out with people from his Intro to World Religions class, smoking pot at parties, listening to typical freshman pseudo-profundity and spouting off some of his own. He's got no time for church, because who needs it? 

One of the stoned comments of freshman insight bears looking at. It's the notion that religion provides a socially acceptable avenue for male homo-erotic behavior. This is going to come up again. 

Section Four: Traversing the threshold

In this section, Suzie, a.k.a. Sue, a.k.a. Suzanna, depending on which version of herself she's being, is walking away, and Fly is literally at the threshold to his dorm room, watching her leave for church without him. Fly's happy to let her go, but when Clive specifically tries to warn him that this church is a cult, suddenly, that is the intervention that spurs Fly to go. If Clive's against it, then Fly is for it. 

As soon as Fly enters the special world, the world beyond the threshold to the normal, he finds, somewhat Matrix-like, that the world he thought was the "ordinary" world was actually hiding secrets. At one point, while still in the ordinary world, Fly saw people of color eating together in the school cafeteria and wondered where they were all hiding all the time, because he hardly ever saw any. Once at church, though, he realizes that Suzie and Arthur were also people of color. In fact, the church seems, suddenly, once his eyes are opened, to be full of people of color: "All the people of color were camouflaged. Maybe they had been around Fly all the time, and he'd been too self-absorbed to notice. Maybe he was camouflaged too."

Perhaps Fly's essential loneliness can be cured, now that his eyes have been opened. He's not alone. There are others like him. Perhaps this is why Clive, the white dwarf who had tried to guard the threshold to the special world, wanted to keep Fly from attending. Clive pretended to be Fly's "brother," although not in the jive sense, but in reality, he may have been part of the white power structure trying to keep Fly feeling isolated. 

Section Five: Tests, Allies, and Enemies

Immediately after going to church, two things happen to fly: he is in love with Suzanna, now that he knows she is black, and he is tired all the time. We will learn in a later section that Fly had porn at home. The porn collection was magazines of black girls on the top and white girls on the bottom, as though he was secretly attracted to white women, but had to cover it over with an attraction to black girls. One of his first thoughts when he thought Suzie was white was that he couldn't bring her home to his parents. 

Suzie seems to solve the riddle for Fly of how to resolve his attraction to both black and white girls, because Suzie, the lightest-skin black girl he's ever seen, can be either. 

The "tests" in "Tests, Allies, and Enemies" are actual school tests. The allies are his new church friends. I was momentarily a little disturbed trying to figure out who the enemies are, because it seemed like the only possible enemies in the chapter are the Jews who claim they aren't really white. There's Clive, of course, but he's one enemy, not enemies, plural. Which means the only other possible enemies seemed to be the Jewish kids. However, once viewed from the end, it's possible to read the Jews as allies, albeit unexpected ones Fly can't quite get his head around, while Suzie and Albert are the real enemies in disguise. 

Section Six: Approach to the Innermost Cave, or, The Meeting with the Goddess

Any nineteen-year-old would take talk of an "innermost cave" in a sexual way, and that's exactly what it means here. Suzie, turned on that Fly is starting to be into God, first starts giving him oral sex and then, after he is formally "saved," allows him to partially penetrate her. It seems like typical evangelical hijinks, the kind of stuff that gets skewered in HBO's Crashing, how evangelicals will split hairs between vaginal sex and things like hand jobs or blow jobs. Maybe Suzie really just does want to maintain some kind of technical virginity out of a sense of Christian virtue. We don't learn until later that there was something truly awful about her refusal to let him fully inside her "innermost cave." 

Within this section, we once again get a hint that church is linked to homo-eroticism. After getting saved, Fly is hugged by a number of men, receiving "more male affection than he'd ever received." He's far more fascinated by the female hugs, but still, the idea that religion allows for male intimacy in ways that nothing else does is reintroduced. 

Section Seven: The Ordeal


Fly thinks he's found a solid answer to both his loneliness and also to constructing identity in church. He doesn't stop to think that his parents also met in church, that it was also the beginning to their sad story. 

Clive, the one who never wanted Fly to go to church and discover the place where all the colored people could appear as themselves, is the one who puts the seed of doubt in his mind. He says he's seen Suzie romantically involved with freshmen before. Clive, thinking he's finally figured out that the reason Fly had the single room is because he's gay, suggests that maybe it's some kind of conversion therapy, trying to turn gay men straight through Suzie's enormous sex appeal.  

This is the third time someone has linked the church to homosexual or homo-erotic behavior, but Fly is very clearly not gay. Clive has failed to understand that the real reason Fly got the single room is that for any black man who wishes to live as himself, loneliness is unavoidable. 

The cumulative effect for all this linking church with homo-eroticism is to cancel its appeal for heterosexual black men. What could have been a place for much-needed intimacy, a place to undo the loneliness that is the "ordinary" world for a black man, is negated by making it seem it is only for people not like him. 

Section Eight: Atonement with the Father

This is the section title that doesn't really correspond to Campbellian theory, although fathers are an archetype Campbell does discuss. Fly's father, we find out, has been dealing with mental illness his whole life. His father also, for some reason, kept a sex tape with a former girlfriend, a tape that ended up in the inner sanctum of Fly's porn collection. 

Fly has apparently had a lot of resentment built up against his father, and it comes to a head when the father decides to leave his mom. But when his father hands Fly Invisible Man by Ralph Ellison, there is suddenly a truly holy moment, the moment when the father is giving his son the real esoteric knowledge that the secret world was supposed to reveal to him, because he is presenting his son with the sacred text that can explain all the reasons for Fly's essential loneliness. There are limits to the applicability of the Campbellian formula for a black man, because the formula was never written with black men in mind. Rather than a cycle that can help relieve Fly of his loneliness, the hero cycle for a black man is more about understanding why that loneliness is somewhat unavoidable. 

Just as the story has altered Campbell's steps to meet Fly's needs, though, it has no intention of sticking closely to any model, even a model as revered as Invisible Man. As we'll find out in the next section, ""Anything that followed a formula was useless anyhow," so Fly needs to find a new template for the hero's journey, one that fits his experience as a black man in America in his time. 

Section Nine: The Road Back

Turns out his sleepiness was mono. Turns out, Suzie gets engaged to Arthur, the man she was saving herself for, the man God created for her. So maybe her "sluttiness" with Fly really was missionary sluttiness after all. Far more damaging to Fly's heterosexual black male image than Clive thinking he's gay is the fact that Suzie only was having semi-sex with him because she thought he might be. Fly has returned to his ordinary world, which is to say, to his fundamental loneliness: "So Fly was alone again."

Is he changed? Has he come back from the special world a different man, such that he can change the ordinary world around him? An important part of the Campbellian cycle is resurrection, the moment the character comes back from the special world, reborn into the ordinary one. We are told there is no resurrection possible for the father, but is it possible for the son?

It's hard to see how. Fly's self-image is even worse than it was before. It isn't that some people have thought he was gay, it's that being authentic and vulnerable and intimate is so automatically linked to homosexuality; since Fly knows he's not gay, he feels like all the other things that are assumed to be part of homosexual identity--things Fly really needs--are not for him. Fly has been made to think that his loneliness is because he longs for an unmanly intimacy, when in fact, it's got nothing to do with sexual identity. "Just because I was lonely doesn't mean I was gay. And was lonely what gay people were anyway?" 

If there is redemption for Fly, it isn't that he'll be able to escape being lonely. It's that he might have a greater understanding of what it causing his loneliness. 


Karen Carlson at A Just Recompense paid more attention to something I only alluded to, the importance of vulnerability in this story. For her take, go here. 

Thursday, December 17, 2020

Why we homeschool our son: "Kennedy" by Kevin Wilson

Like a lot of people, I had more time in 2020 to watch television than I've had in past years. We're supposedly living in the Golden Age of American Television, and every week there's another series on all the four main streaming services that gets rave reviews, so there ought to be a lot to interest me. But I sort of feel like the Golden Age has already passed. Most of the shows everyone is praising seem to me now like a reiteration of some earlier show, an attempt to recreate the magic that has the form but not the soul that made the original worth watching. 

Some of the exceptions are shows about adolescents, like Netflix's Big Mouth and Hulu's PEN15. Adolescent shows have always been built around humor that takes advantage of the awkwardness of being a teen. These shows aren't an exception, but they also don't overlook how deep and lasting the psychological damage of teen years can be. Particularly the fourth season of Big Mouth, which just came out this month, is equal parts sex/scatological humor and also a sensitive portrayal of how what we tend to write off as routine nuisances of youth can lead to long-term psychological disorders. 

Kevin Wilson's "Kennedy," the next-to-the-last story in Best American Short Stories 2020, is another in this line of stories about adolescence that take what happens in the teen years seriously. "Kennedy," however, doesn't share the humor of the best shows tackling the subject. (Although much like PEN15, it features two friends, one of whom is Japanese in a town where there are almost no other Asian kids.) "Kennedy" gets dark fast:

John F. Kennedy was a boy in our high school, but he went by Kennedy. For a brief time, he made things pretty bad for us. We’d started our junior year without ever having exchanged a single word with him, had only seen him as he stalked the hallways, his long, greasy hair covering his face, his Coke-bottle glasses. He always wore this olive green military jacket with the name KENNEDY stitched across the right breast. Underneath that, he seemed to have every single Cannibal Corpse T-shirt in existence, a never-ending parade of skeletons and knives and blood and people with the skin ripped off their faces. He wasn’t allowed to wear the T-shirts at school, since they were against the dress code, so he wore the jacket over them, even when it was hot out, and if he sensed your weakness, he’d open his jacket and flash the T-shirt at you as he passed you in the hallway.

You'd think that naming the kid JFK would mean there was some kind of idiosyncratic humor on its way, but it's mostly absent. The story is a recollection of how the narrator and his best friend Ben allowed Kennedy to abuse them, terrify them, and, ultimately, to come between them. It's reminiscent of a lot of stories sexual abuse victims tell, mainly because of the way the victims find themselves too shell-shocked to fight. The narrator, Jaime, thinks it's maybe because he was coddled by his parents, leaving him "without street smarts, with no sense of how to navigate high school." 

Charles Baxter said that hell is full of great stories, and for many people, the closest they got to hell was high school (or junior high). 

Whatever the reason, when Kennedy throws a backpack at Ben and Ben doesn't complain, the psychopathic Kennedy realizes he can have his way with the two friends. There are a number of reasons they feel they can't complain to adults. One is simply that it will "embarrassing." Another is the apathy the adults demonstrate; the teacher in the art class where Kennedy deals out much of his abuse is recumbent on a recliner most of the time because of the pain in her back. As caring as their parents are, they don't know how to ask the right questions to find out what is troubling their children. Ben's mother asks about the first day of school, but Ben and Jaime don't give her an honest answer. "How would we even begin to describe Kennedy? What could be done?" they ask themselves. " And that was that. It was like, in missing that moment when things were still normal, we had given up any chance of controlling Kennedy’s effect on our lives. He had us. If he wanted us, whatever he wanted, he could have us."

There's a lot more of this kind of language in the story, all of it consistent with what many other survivors of abuse have told, the difficulty of explaining why you found yourself unable to resist. I've taken "resiliency training" before, and a lot of it had to do with learning to "get off the X," meaning how to not be a target for this kind of abuse. Abusers are experts at knowing who they can abuse and get away with it. It's actually a very normal human reaction, this freezing up, which is why this story is so consistent with what so many abuse survivors have to say:

Looking back on it, I want to take myself and just shake and shake, like, What the fuck is wrong with you? Why did you let that happen? But I can still remember those moments, when it felt like I was paralyzed inside my own body, like I had to pull myself deeper and deeper inside of myself, away from the surface, in order to stay alive. I think Ben felt the same way. We tried not to talk about it.

Invisibility

At one point, the narrator claims that now, as an adult looking back on it, he understands why he was unable to fight back. (He also claims at other points that he doesn't understand, but that's to be expected. Looking back on a traumatic event, you're likely to feel both epiphanies and subsequent undoing of the epiphanies.) He feels that he and his friend Ben had practiced being invisible for so long, they didn't know how to ask for help, because that would have involved trying to be noticed: "Now I understand it: we had stayed invisible for so long that we weren’t used to people noticing us, and so when Kennedy noticed us, shined a light on us, we simply froze, simply sat there and took it, all these little indignities, and hoped that he would fuck up in some other class and get suspended, a temporary reprieve."

Jaime likely meant that most high schoolers, unsure of who they are and terrified of the scorn of their peers, which seems to whirl around with the caprice of a prairie wind, find it safest to just keep quiet, go along, and not make noise. This is, in fact, the safest thing most of the time in high school, which is why it's so hard to realize when it's the thing that is putting you in danger.

But Ben and Jaime aren't the only invisible ones. The word "invisible" appears twice in the story. The second time, it's about Kennedy. "I wondered how he’d made it this far in school when it was so clear how little he cared, how he would dare anyone in authority to do something about it. But it was like he was invisible to people in charge. I couldn’t figure it out."

The narrator allows us to see reasons to have empathy for Kennedy without letting on himself that he feels this empathy. Maybe it's not the job of the abused to feel empathy for their abusers, but through Jaime's eyes, we, the readers, see plenty to pity Kennedy for. He has an abusive father, and he is obviously entirely alone. He desperately wants to connect, but has no idea how. When Jaime suggests killing Kennedy, Ben is there to immediately talk him out of it, but Kennedy has nobody to talk him out of it when he decides to kill his abuser. 

It's easy to see why the boys love video games so much, why the sense of power and competence they feel in their virtual world is so much more appealing to them than the real one. But at least they play together. Kennedy's escape, meanwhile, is to wear a fetishist's leather mask while he is sleeping, something that no doubt makes him feel he can disappear, but also something that increases his isolation.

Bug, not a feature


We decided at the end of eighth grade to homeschool our son, rather than send him to high school. For the last year, this decision has been moot, but before that, we definitely got an earful of gratuitous opinions on whether this decision was good for him. Most of the concerns were that our son wouldn't be ready for the real world, because he would have missed out on the interactions with peers, teachers, and administrators, both the good and the bad, that would prepare him for life. 

I understand this concern, and believe me, Mrs. Heretic and I thought long and hard about what he'd be missing out on. But I think all too often, society tends to treat the bugs of high school like they're features. Schools aren't supposed to be ignorant of abuse going on. Students aren't supposed to feel like they have no good options to stop it. This doesn't teach coping skills for later in life. It gives people pathologies that make it harder to survive later in life. It's like saying the best way for a military to prepare for a firefight is for everyone to practice getting shot. 

Teenage life isn't supposed to be like high school. High schools are insane asylums. We shouldn't act like some of the truly terrible things about it are the way it's supposed to be, like it's great preparation for the real world and that it's really part of the design to high school.

We overuse the word "trauma" in America (especially us political liberals). And even I am annoyed sometimes by how much hysteria is attached to some behavior that is actually normal teenage behavior, calling it "bullying," when in fact it's just annoying. I probably never faced actual trauma in high school, but I did learn unhealthy coping strategies. I vacillated between hiding by trying to be invisible and trying to hide in plain sight by being outlandishly weird, hoping I could become so weird that picking on me would seem redundant, because I did so well at picking on myself. Along the way, I learned some of the same things Jaime did, like how not to speak up when someone is treating you badly. That probably helped lead to other decisions after high school, like joining the Marine Corps, where I also learned that being invisible was a good strategy, and also vacillated between striving for it and trying to hide in plain sight by acting eccentrically. 

Good things can come out of bad experiences, of course. But there's good adversity and bad adversity, and just because high school makes students face terrible behavior doesn't mean it's good for building character or whatever we try to pretend it's good for. 

In the story, Jaime and Ben's friendship to one another is what allows them to survive. They fail each other in some ways, and although as readers, we can forgive their failures and even find they make the small courage the boys show for each other far more affecting, as adults, they've lost touch, possibly because to see one another would be to remember what Kennedy put them through and how they failed. One cannot see their friendship as a silver lining to the abuse, because they were friends before and stopped being friends not long after. It didn't make them become closer. The fire of adversity did not burnish the gold of their relationship.  

Is there hope for Jaime?


I'm no expert on trauma, but it seems to me that there are two things that might help Jaime, at whatever point in time he is looking back on this story, to heal from it. One is finding empathy for Kennedy and maybe forgiving him, and the second is coming to some kind of closure concerning Ben. The first might actually be easier than the second; Kennedy might be dead by now, or at least not living a happy adult life, and wherever he is, he can't hurt Jaime anymore. In Jaime's own recollection, we, as objective readers, see all we need to see in order to feel some empathy and forgiveness for Kennedy, so the seeds are there in Jaime's mind. But the final words of the story are about how much Jaime misses Ben. The reader wants to kick Jaime in the pants, much like while reading all the scenes of his abuse. Just do it! There's social media now! People are usually easy to find! Reach out! You're writing this story, so you must have some part of you that wants to find him, that's ready to remember. But Jaime still seems unable as an adult to get off the X, to take action, even when it's clearly what would make him happier. He's still so trained by the warped microcosm of society we call high school to not do what he clearly should do. 

I put a lot of myself into this look at "Kennedy," and even though that's not unusual for me, I did more of it here than in any other story I can remember analyzing. This is probably because of how personally and emotionally invested I was in this story. I read it with the same single-mindedness to get to the ending I've heard readers of suspenseful beach reads put into their books, but has never happened to me before. Once I saw what the story was about, I had to get to the end quickly. It's an utterly superb short story. But the fact that the dysfunction of American high schools around the time I was in them led to the creation of a great short story doesn't justify the dysfunction. 


For Karen Carlson's take on this story (she thought it was equally compelling), go here. 

Wednesday, December 16, 2020

And now, my post of great shame: "Enlightenment" by William Pei Shih

 My blogging pal Karen claimed that I didn't really take a pass on a story earlier in BASS this year when I claimed I was taking a pass, but this time, I really am taking a pass. It's getting harder and harder for me to blog on stories I don't like, and I don't like "Enlightenment" by William Pei Shih at all. I'd actually read it before BASS came out, when it appeared in Virginia Quarterly Review. I didn't like it then, but I hoped when I got around to reading it a second time as I was blogging through Best American Short Stories, I would find something a little more to like about it. I didn't. There are some stories where I find trying to come to grips with what I didn't like about them to be nearly as interesting as a close reading of a story I did enjoy, but I'm not feeling that way right now. The longer I'm a writer myself, the more I think how shitty it is to do a negative reading, especially of stories that aren't going to get a lot of other critique written about them. As backwater as my blog is, there aren't many other folks blogging on BASS (or short stories in general), so if I write that I don't like it, that's likely to be what a lot of students of BASS find when they look for help on Google. I'm okay doing that with someone who's already had a successful, long career, like T.C. Boyle, but I really don't want to do it for someone like William Pei Shih. 

Essentially, I think there is a mismatch in the story between form and function. The main character mentally inhabits a world of 18th-century writers who almost all indulged in verbal excess, but the prose is ultra-pared down, like reading Carver or some other hard-edged, no-nonsense 20th century writer. I believe the point of the story is supposed to be that its main character, Abel, studies the enlightenment his entire life, but never achieves his own enlightenment. Instead, he pointedly relives the lives of the cautionary tales from the very texts he treasures. He battled himself to overcome institutional prejudices, but failed to help the next generation to overcome the prejudices they faced. 

Which, fine, but it seemed to me like a lot of the story was a summary of a story. It had the feel of an "Introduction to the Age of Enlightenment" seminar, where there was a felt need to talk a little bit about every major thinker from the period, instead of focusing on one or two key texts. It all left me feeling like most introductory courses do--like I haven't really learned much about anything, but did hear about a lot of things I wish I'd learned more about. 

That's all I can say. It's not fun for me to do this. I'm not Tweeting this post, I'm not talking about it anymore, and I'm posting it here quietly in the middle of the day hoping nobody ever reads it. I feel like I have to at least post something to say I read it, because it was in BASS, but that's really all this post serves to do. 


While it does nothing to remove my feelings of having failed at this story, Karen Carlson at A Just Recompense kind of felt the same way.