Showing posts with label rona. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rona. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 24, 2020

A survey question I don't know how to answer

I participate in surveys put together by the Pew Charitable Trusts. They keep asking me to answer their questions, although every time I do, I feel like the worst survey respondent ever. About half their questions make me stop and think, sometimes to such an extent I actually can't finish a survey because a question on it has stumped me so badly. The latest one I took had a good example.

It was largely a COVID-19 survey. There were some easy questions, like overall, how do I think the president is doing and overall, how do I think my state is doing, and overall, how do I think most states are doing. But then the survey wanted to go a level deeper. It asked me if I thought, in the context of the public reaction to the COVID-19 epidemic, that "most people can be trusted to do the right thing."

This brought to mind a Tweet I saw re-posted this week:




Here's why the question flummoxed me: on the one hand, I think "most" people, i.e. more than 50% of people, are probably trying to do the right thing. But there are two reasons I don't think this is really the critical question, nor what the people who wrote the question really wanted to know. Because it takes far less than a majority of people doing the wrong thing to screw things up for everyone. So the question isn't whether more than 50% of people strive to do the right thing, it's whether we're over the limit in our country of the number of people needed to screw it up for all of us.

And even that number of people trying to do the right thing--how hard do they have to be trying? Should we be doing everything in our power to minimize our potential to infect others by minimizing our caloric intake in order to stretch out the food in our houses and avoid extra trips to the store? If we go to the store and buy items we don't need to survive, didn't we just spread our germs to places in the store we didn't have to spread them? What level of doing the right thing do people need to achieve in order to be placed in the "trusted to do the right thing" camp? If you're just going to say it's whatever is reasonable, then you'd probably just be looking at what an average person does, in which case, well, just about exactly half of the people would be doing at least what an average person does or better. So it's a meaningless question.

And then there's the question of duration. How long will people continue to do the right thing? Most people likely don't go buying up toilet paper at a rate far greater than what they need at first, but once a few panic buyers start snatching it all up, others, who wouldn't have done the wrong thing on their own, are likely to follow suit, and before long, you have the quorum of bad actors needed to wreck things for everyone.

A question more to the point than what the survey asked me would be something like this: "Do you think that our society has the ability to act corporately in such a way as to minimize the negative effects of the COVID-19 outbreak?" Because my answer to that question is a lot different from my answer to whether I think the majority of people will try to do the right thing.

Monday, March 23, 2020

New old worries

On the surface, it seems like life in coronavirus times presents me with new ethical quandaries:


  • Yesterday, I went to the grocery store. Every cashier seemed to be above 60, including mine. My demand for food was putting these people at risk by making them be there. Should I not go to the grocery store?
  • If not the grocery store, what if I order food online from Amazon or a similar source? Am I not just changing the source of the threat for the worker supplying me from customers in a store to co-workers in a warehouse? 
  • Should I order take-out from local restaurants that aren't allowed to have sit-down customers any more, so they can at least continue to make some money, or am I just putting them at risk of infecting each other in the kitchen?
  • Is there, in fact, any way for me to continue to consume during this crisis that doesn't put these workers in jeopardy? I can, of course, try to reduce my consumption. I'm not going to buy the grass seed I need to fix my awful lawn this spring until the threat is over. But I also would like to try to keep about two weeks of food on hand at the house in case one of us gets the coronavirus and we all need to self-isolate. Which means I need to stock up every few days. Is there any ethical way to do that other than hunting my food, which I don't know how to do? 
These might be questions I'm framing in a new way or with a new urgency, but when I think about it, they're not that different from questions that mildly bother me every day. Should I patronize a fast food restaurant when the workers in it are underpaid? Does refusing to go there help them in any way, or does it just cost them the patronage that keeps them in a job they need, even if the job doesn't pay well? Does Amazon exploit its workers, and is it bad for the American economy overall? Should I not buy things from them, even when it's obviously the most economical and convenient way to get something? Is there any way for me to consume in a way that doesn't contribute to the unhappiness of others, especially when I think of the complete supply chain stretching all over the world?

I don't know another way to survive than buying what I need. I don't think I'm capable of becoming a subsistence organic farmer. (And even if I could, to do that would still require me first making enough money to buy a farm and everything I need to run it, which would involve decades of earning and consuming.) There doesn't seem to be a way out of the trap of my existence contributing to the unhappiness of others. 

Generally, I can only stand to consider these questions for so long. It ends with me just sort of blankly resolving to keep going and to try to be okay with not being okay, to live in the absurdity. But every act of consumption on my part feels like I'm numbing myself to how not okay the way we all live is. 

Most people who don't worry about low-paid workers figure that it's a free labor market, and if those workers want a job that pays better, it's up to them to do something to get one. We shouldn't feel bad for them if they don't. I guess I have a hard time buying that because of how long I was once stuck in retail work, how impossible it once seemed to me I'd ever escape, and how lucky I am to have been rescued from it. Things happen in life, and a lot of people end up in places they didn't mean to be. The free market is not a perfect mechanism, and it doesn't lead to a perfect meritocracy. The American Dream can get sidetracked by bad luck as much as by bad choices. 

In any event, for now, living through the crisis for me is shaping up to just be a time when it's harder for me to push aside thoughts I never quite fully succeed at pushing away even in happier times. I feel utterly parasitic, with no way to lessen the burden or share the risk of better people.