It occurred to me today that there was a period of a few years when I was younger where nearly everyday of my life, I would listen to a commercial with these words:
Honeycomb's big
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
It's not small,
No, no, no.
So if I sometimes struggle during a key moment in a story to come up with a passage that seems sufficiently lyrical, I ought not to blame myself too much. Our society is meant to produce consumers, not artists.
This isn't going to be a scorch-and-burn attack. If I were interested in getting clicks, that's the kind of post I'd write. My son listens to enough of those kinds of things on YouTube--one YouTuber making a living off of attacking another one. Milo Yiannopoulos has become famous and wealthy exploiting this kind of thing. The subject, however, is too important to turn into an opportunity for chest-thumping.
I've been putting off posting this for a long time, because I can't see that anything personally good will come to me from posting it. But if I am really committed to writing about truth as I see it, this is a post I have to publish.
The rhetoric of those who claim to speak on behalf of racial equality is awful. It's conceited, it's condescending, it's preachy, and it's irritating. It reminds me a lot of the kind of rhetoric I encountered among evangelical Christians when I fell into that group for several years as an old child and young man. It slows racial progress by turning the focus from practical areas of improvement to a cultural war over language.
A recent blog post by a mother who seems like a very good person hits nearly every obnoxious trope of the priesthood of self-appointed curators of correct language on race. From its title, "The Kind of Racism You Don't Even Know You Have," I knew where it was going, and it wasn't going any place good. It used at least four of the rhetorical devices that are the worst, most logically inconsistent, most condescending tropes of the genre.
1. The title. "The kind of racism you don't even know you have." There are a number of problems with this, but some of them will be dealt with later, so I'll just stick to this one: It's in the interests of those who claim to have the truth on racial linguistic propriety to mystify it. If everybody feels uncertain about how to talk about race, then we need a Brahmanic caste to explain it to us. Believe it or not, there are people who make a living out of telling others how to talk about race. Government agencies usually have an EEO office, as do many larger corporations. There is a good deal of investment into keeping on the right side of racial policy, both for genuine, selfless reasons (it's good to treat people decently), and for profit reasons (nobody wants to get sued or boycotted). If it were easy to understand concepts of practical racial discourse, companies and governments might start to wonder if the investment were necessary. Best to keep it spooky: "You might be a racist and not even know it!"
There's a tone here reminiscent of eleven o'clock news "the silent killer" stories. To wit: "In fact, there’s an even more insidious
kind of racism than the Neo-Nazism we saw running amuck in
Charlottesville. It’s insidious because you don’t even know you’re
infected with it; it’s covert, it’s invisible."
The article opens with an insincere feint at sympathy: "Look, I get it. I totally understand your reluctance to discuss racism. I know that even hearing the words racism or worse, racist, feels accusatory – offensive, even." It then ascribes several thoughts to its hypothetical skeptical reader that I do not myself think, even though I am a skeptical reader: thoughts like affirmative action is reverse racism or that because I've never owned a slave I'm not complicit in systemic racism. But these things have nothing to do with my reluctance to talk about racism. My reluctance stems from the fact that we have introduced such a dumb vocabulary to talk about racism, and because the vocabulary is enforced with such blind vigor by those who think they've accomplished something by learning it. 2. The definition bait-and-switch: I get that there is an academic, pinpointed, specific sociological definition of racism. The article provides a pretty good example of this definition, citing Debby Irving. Racism is "the system that allows the racial group that’s already in power to retain power." That's fine. I have no objection to that as a formal definition. But that's not the definition people are usually expecting when they enter a conversation about racism.
Racism, like many, many concepts, has a formal, term-of-art meaning as well as a regular, everyday meaning. There's nothing wrong with this, and it doesn't mean that people using the everyday meaning are stupid or even wrong to expect that meaning when they hear the word.
There are a lot of science-minded people who sneer when they hear someone talk about wanting to steer clear of "chemicals" in their daily lives. You'll hear these people say things like, "Oh, yeah, you going to avoid water? Because that's a chemical!" To a chemist, all matter is made of chemicals, because all matter can be reduced to a chemical formula. But that's not what normal folks mean in everyday talk. "I want to avoid chemicals" means something like, "I want to avoid man-made ingredients and substances that might have side effects we don't fully understand yet." That's not a stupid thing to say. That's just how normal folks talk.
When you drop a title like "the kind of racism you don't even know you have," you are playing a click-bait game, because you know many people will read it thinking you mean, "You believe people of a different race are inherently inferior, and you don't even know it!" This, of course, means you're going to get push-back, but you've got that ace up your sleeve of saying, "But wait! You have to use the correct definition of racism!"
Yes, there is institutional racism. Yes, the choices that almost all of us make--intentionally and unintentionally--prop up a system that makes life generally easier for white people. So your formal definition stands. But it wasn't that long ago we were a lot more concerned about the man-on-the-street definition. When I was a kid, we were still trying to get everyone to agree that the informal definition of racism--thinking one race is inherently inferior--was a bad thing. That was still an important social war to fight. Not everyone is past that point yet.
In any event, is racism of this sort something you can actually "have"? It's something you can be a part of, but do you "have" it? No, you can only "have" the layman's form of racism.
3. Just plain using words wrong. The article calls out whites who complain about "playing the race card," but only focuses on one meaning of this term, and not the more common one. The article acts like it means using racial status to get advantages, like those offered by Affirmative Action. But the more usual meaning is "using racial status to get out of trouble," like when a black person who has really done something wrong tries to suggest he or she is being targeted because of racism. The article claims that playing the race card "is not a thing," but that's referring to the first, less common meaning. To prove that the second meaning really exists, you'd only need one example of it actually happening.
O.J. Simpson.
It's a thing. It may not be the most common thing, but it's a thing.
Wanting to brush it aside, like saying "there is not reverse racism although black people can be prejudiced against white people" but then not really wanting to talk much about how what black prejudice means to racial theory as a whole. White people who have faced considerable amount of prejudice, like Mrs. Heretic, who worked in Baltimore City Schools for over five years, might be willing to accept that they faced "prejudice" rather than "reverse racism," but that doesn't make the experience any more pleasant. Whether it was overt, like notes from students that said, "I hate white people," or hidden, like being shunned and passed over by black principals in ways that were hard to prove but felt real, it happened and it was wrong. Are we really telling her that because it wasn't systemic racism, we don't need to talk about it? That's what it feels like. I agree that white people often use examples of black people playing the race card--along with examples of black prejudice (or black-on-black crime, etc.) to distract and derail a conversation from the very real effects of racism. But that doesn't mean those things don't belong in the conversation at all.
4. Got a problem with white privilege? You must not understand it! I can't count the number of articles I've read that are written "for your white friends who still don't understand white privilege." This article does the same thing: "The next concept, white privilege, may be one of the hardest for my fellow white people to understand, but stick with me..." This is nails-on-a-chalkboard kind of condescension. I got this from evangelicals all the time: "You think evolution makes sense? You just need to read this creation scientist..." This would be ignoring the fact that I had already mentioned the same creation scientist twice in the same conversation and that I'd already offered a critique of that person's points. I can understand something you hold dear and still disagree with you.
At its heart, I don't object to the notion that white privilege is a thing, because it clearly is. Whiteness is one of those things that tends to have a beneficial influence on one's chances for material success. But there is a racial essentialism summoned by "The Racism You Don't Even Know You Have," which often wants to act as though whiteness is the only determining factor. This article itself cites in a positive way another, much better article, "Explaining White Privilege to a Broke White Person," which is an article that acknowledges that race is just one of many things people are born with that effect their chances in life. Others are: citizenship, class, sexual orientation, sex, ability, and gender identity. I'd add "skill of parents at parenting" to that list as maybe the most important. "Explaining White Privilege..." doesn't try to claim that whiteness will always trump all the other disadvantages one might have. It's possible to be born rich and black and have it better than someone born white and poor. It's just a statistics thing, which means we're dealing with averages. On average, whiteness helps. On average, the system hurts people of color. Other things being equal, whiteness yields better results. But that's not essentialism. It's not saying race is the only issue.
Ta-Nehisi Coates is America's best writer on race because he doesn't let America forget how important race is on that list. We should not lose that focus. It is. Institutional racism is much more pernicious, much deeper, lasted with legal sanction until much more recently, and has directed the landscape of the present much more than most white people are willing to accept. However, even he can sometimes make too much of race as the only issue worth considering. In his article on Donald Trump as the first president who was elected specifically because of his whiteness, he cited some voting statistics. (I believe his statistics match those here.) Coates points out that Trump won with every white group, debunking the notion that his was a "middle class victory," but Trump won non-college whites by 37% and whites with a college degree by only 3%, a fact Coates passes by without comment. Surely that means that there are other factors that have a profound impact besides just whiteness.
Along with explanations of how racism can to be in a thing in America that focus exclusively on use of race, I think there are other, useful ideas to consider. A neo-Marxist might make the point that those in power--largely white males--are happy to use racism as a tool to keep their power, but might also, under certain circumstances, abandon racism as a principle in order to keep power. The white slaveholding caste didn't race bait because it really believed black people were the inferior children of Ham, in other words; they invented the notion that black people were the inferior children of Ham because it was a useful way to keep power. Coates has sometimes objected to policies that attempt to deal with racism by sweeping them up into broader policies aimed at poverty in general, but someone who sees racism as one tool of in the tool chest of power--even if it's the tool power uses the most--might be more willing to compromise.
Where does whiteness fit in the complicated web of factors, unmerited, that contribute to one's fate? It's an interesting, complicated question. It's also one I can't see obsessing over if what you really care about is FIXING racism, not elaborating upon it to death. The obsession with proper terminology as a sine qua non to being accepted into the fellowship of those committed to a better world seem like something you do when you're trying to avoid the hard work of actually fixing the mess. The smugness in not just this article, but nearly every article from a writer frustrated with the intransigence of people like me to accept their terminology, is palpable. If we feel any sense of indignation while reading their rhetoric, that's not a sign that the writers are being superior know-it-alls, it's a sign that they're right, and I'm upset with how on-the-nose their keen insight is: "What is your knee-jerk reaction to being called out for “racism?” In actuality, insults only hurt deep down if they’re true." This reminds me of some Christians I knew who sometimes acted obnoxious about their faith, then blamed the reaction they got on the world's rejection of Christian truth. Sometimes, the reaction you get tells you more than you might want to admit. Not always--certainly, the mob can be wrong. But you can't automatically overlook the reactions you get without giving some consideration to whether the reactions are understandable.
I'm not hurt but this kind of talk, I'm annoyed. One group has stolen the megaphone and is shouting down anyone else who cares about racial equality. It's like the Protestants are in power, and they're insisting that us Catholics aren't even Christian enough to work with to feed the poor... ---- I'm going to end the list there, although I originally had a few more in mind. The point is, this is all very familiar to me. I have been in churches where to be a Christian was really nothing more than knowing how to use a few select Christian cliches in the correct context. I have been in churches that argued endlessly over pre, mid-, and post-tribulation schemes, and used varying answers to these abstruse questions as reasons to be or not be in fellowship with others. That's what this feels like. The writer of this article concludes by talking about how unpopular her views are, how often those who express them are attacked for them. I have not found this to be the case. Generally, I've found that if you want to avoid being called racist, the things she said are the things you have to say. This is the orthodoxy you have to stick to. I'm afraid to post this response. Mrs. Heretic is always warning me not to write about race. Some of my friends think that honest discourse about race is impossible in our culture and a waste of time to try. That's kind of how I know I ought to post this. The writer seems very certain that those who object to what she writes are acting out because they don't want to talk about race. I think that the very tone of this kind of insistence on orthodoxy is what hinders racial discourse, not unwillingness to engage in what's hard. I think the very false mystification, the insistence that only the gurus of racial thought, those who have been handed the sacred fire of the correct words with the correct definitions, is what prevents more people from being involved.
If you haven't seen this episode of "Lady Dynamite," watch it. "If you're white, keep it light."
I have avoided naming the writer of this article here. That would have made this into an attack. I don't want to call out the writer, with whom I am probably a natural ally. I want to call out the rhetoric. The writer felt her article was "reaching across the aisle," because of its awkward attempts to sympathize by putting the wrong words in the mouths of her would-be interlocutors. Rather, I think this is the kind of talk that has widened the gap.
The writer points out how polarizing race rhetoric and hate speech have become more prevalent since Trump took office. That's true, but the writer seems to want to only point the blame in one direction. In her mind, we went backwards not because some people felt so frustrated trying to meet the moving goal posts of what we were all supposed to think and say about race that they gave up trying, but because racism was pushing back against change to the system meant to protect power. That's certainly part of it, but I don't think liberals--and on race, I am one--should let ourselves off the hook for our own sins being part of it. I think we're partly to blame for the thing we hate.
I haven't believed in evangelical Christianity for over 20 years, but I'm always fascinated by how often sociological truths from church play out away from that environment. It's possible to be a Christian without really understanding much Christian doctrine at all, just by trying to love as Jesus did. You'd never guess that from the way some churches spend nearly all their time going over doctrine, though.
Similarly, I think the current liberal racial discourse is too focused on saying the right things, even though it's possible to have it all wrong and still do the right things. You can be a kindly old person who never got the memo about "white privilege" and "whitesplaining" who just knows that she wants to help, so she fosters black kids from poor communities and does a really good job of it. If a certain brand of liberal heard her insisting her kids try to overcome systemic racism and assume personal responsibility for their actions, the mom, unhip to the right terminology, might be accused of being racially insensitive. In fact, she's just a good mom.
I wish we were as obsessed with right action as we are with right speech. I wish that, rather than testing each other for the shibboleth of using the right definition of "racism," we tested to see what work we are doing to practically solve systemic racism. I know that old line about "as a man thinketh, so is he," but if I had a dime for every time that was used as a reason for a church to spend all its time studying the Bible and no time doing anything, I'd be as rich as Joel Osteen.
I'm done with my critique, and now that I'm done, I have no wish to keep fighting with people who do talk like the writer of this article. This critique of mine shouldn't be a reason to divide natural allies further. I hope it's nothing more than a call for liberals to self-examine how we talk. I feel that moderate conservatives and moderate liberals together form a true political majority in this country, and we've been kept apart from each other because we've been taught to make more of little things than we ought.
I get sent links in my email to columns about writing, because some algorithm has figured out I'll read some of them. The articles I read are a mix of good and bad, with both usually being pretty easy to spot early on. The danger is when you read an article that's good in general, but all wrong for you.
The other day, the algorithm sent me an entry from this little blog by a woman named Mary Jo Campbell. I knew nothing about her, but it was a focused entry on how to write micro-fiction, so I read it. I thought it was fairly well done; it contained some advice most writers already know, like the importance of details and creative use of language, but it was generally worth my five minutes. However, if I hadn't already known the conventions of literary fiction pretty well, I'd have been led astray by some advice she gave. Here's the 100-word story she wrote that she shared as an example:
What Brings Us Together
My
fingers are cold yet sweat drips down my armpits, under this black
polyester suit jacket. Mom’s smile is her phony-phone-voice as she
busies herself introducing the families that enter. The chosen groomsmen
are called to the front of the aisle, one brother taller than the next,
sleek in their dark combed hair, smooth complexions, pressed suits.
Solemn handsome faces contrasted by the pink blotches on the
bride-to-be’s cheeks. They are each handed a pair of too-small,
bright-white gloves. I swallow hard as my brothers line either side of
Bob’s casket.
I've said before I'm not a huge fan of 100-word stories, but they are a thing, and it's a way to get your name out there, so I guess I'd grudgingly write some if I thought I could do it well. But there's something about this story that doesn't sit right with me, at least as literary fiction. It seems to violate a critical aesthetic principle, voiced by Meg Wolitzer in the Introduction to this year's Best American Short Stories anthology. Wolitzer begins by discussing how the first short stories she was assigned to read in middle school were always the kind with a surprise ending, stories like "The Gift of the Magi." These stories conditioned her to always look for the big twist at the end, to consider it a sine qua non of a good story. Later, however, she came to realize that "if everything is surprising, then nothing is," and to dislike "an unearned surprise for a surprise's sake." She later comes to a more mature understanding of surprise: "...the idea of 'surprise' wasn't abandoned entirely; instead, it was given a shine and polish and a more mature translation. It's possible to see that a whole story--not just the ending--might itself take on what had been considered the function of an ending."
In other words, the whole story should shock one's expectations, should undo the reader's way of seeing things. As a reader, you will "find yourself in a place you didn't know about before."
Campbell, however, specifically recommends the shock ending, calling for "...a twist the reader won’t see coming. But after a re-read, they feel that gut-punch of realization." The story above seems mostly designed for the sake of the surprise ending. There are details given that are clearly meant to lead the reader astray, like the mention of "groomsmen" and a "bride-to-be." (Campbell writes in the blog that this was taken from a cousin who died just before getting married. That's nice to know, but the story as it stands is a little confusing. Why are groomsmen at a funeral? When I read it, I wondered if someone died at the wedding, and they just had the funeral right there that same day because the church was already booked.)
It's nicely written, it has good details, and the unexpected, jangling simile of the smile actually "being" the voice is nice. So is the alliterative word play of "phony-phone-voice." There's nothing wrong with the story, except that it's not literary fiction. I finally realized at this point that Campbell's blog clearly calls attention to the fact that she mainly likes YA fiction. I missed that up front, because I was assuming the algorithm was smart enough to know I write one and not the other.
The lesson is to pay attention to the advice you're getting and where it's coming from. Most writing advice is universal, like use good details. There are some principles, however, that change according to tastes and are genre-specific. So pay more attention that I did.
BONUS FLASH FICTION!!!
Just to give everyone a chance to shit on my writing, instead of me just picking on someone else's (even though I've said I liked her story), I hereby submit to you all the only 100-word story I've ever tried to write. According to the rules, the title isn't included in the word count
-----------
Professor
Mulkin Equivocates before a Greater Power
Professor Mulkin tried to be both seen and invisible in the Book Bonanza!; he hadn’t been in a bookstore since
Borders closed, hadn’t even known they still existed. He saw only DVDs of TV
shows and tween vampire fiction. His wife, recovering in the hospital, had
asked for an adult coloring book.
He had written for the Times
criticizing such fare and those who read them. They signaled the end. Now, he
asked for them out loud. He paid for his purchase with his card, finding it suddenly easy to
forgive every crime in history.
--------------
I have no idea if that's a good literary fiction 100-word story. Like I said, I don't know of any of these things that have really dazzled me. I think they're just an effort to be cute and prove literature isn't always stuffy--like churches telling us that Jesus is cool. This was my best effort to do something with the form. If it sucks, it won't really hurt my feelings much.
A few years ago, a friend of mine shared his draft novel with me, the one he's been trying to find a publisher for for years. I didn't think it was very good; it was a Christian novel that also had vampires in it. Just because I didn't like it doesn't mean it wasn't any good, of course: I thought all the Twilight stories were terrible, but millions of thirteen-year-old girls can't be that wrong. I think he realized that he was fighting an uphill battle trying to merge Christian themes and vampires in a way that would appeal to any audience an agent could sell the book to. But when we were talking about the odds of getting it published successfully, he told me this: "I can't give up. If I gave up, I don't think I could go on with my life."
I can relate to that feeling, as can a lot of writers who don't write fiction as our main gig. Fiction gives us a feeling that we exist for something more than our day jobs, much like every waiter/waitress in Hollywood is really an actor or every waiter/waitress in Nashville is really a singer. Certainly, in my case, after several false starts in life, when I really started to write seriously, it was a moment in my forties when I was asking myself if the life I was leading was really all there was to it.
Like dreams of making it as a singer or actor or professional athlete, one could find fulfillment in the activity even if one never really "makes it." For simplicity, let's say "making it" means being able to make a living entirely off the activity. Even if you can't sing on Broadway or at the Grammy Awards (is that still a thing?), you can sing at Karaoke nights or in churches. You can act in community theater. You can play basketball in a rec league. Even on this much smaller level, talent and hard work will produce better results, so you can still use it as an outlet for your desire to better yourself.
But what if you knew that was as far as you were ever going to get? I suppose it's easier to realize this at an earlier stage as an athlete. For one thing, sports gives us more objective feedback about our ability; zero points in a game means something in a way editors quickly winnowing down the slush pile doesn't. There's also the age factor in sports (and, let's be honest, in acting and singing to a great extent), which doesn't really exist in writing. This makes it possible for a writer to follow a false hope for much longer.
This is a subject I've possibly beaten to death already, but it continues to weigh heavily on my mind. I've had some success in the writing equivalent of community theater, but I haven't had my big break yet. I wrote some stories this year that I really felt were my best yet, and I sent them to the top journals I'd been avoiding. I've had zero breakthroughs. The "right" thing for a writer is probably to just roll with those disappointments and not give them another thought, but I've never been one for doing things the right way. It doesn't seem like an overreaction after four years to doubt that the big IT is ever going to happen for me. Borges' Secret Miracle
I've referred to this story before, because I can't stop thinking about it. If you haven't read it, there's a decent-ish translation here, but the synopsis goes something like this: Joseph Hladik is a literary critic in Prague of mixed Jewish ancestry who is arrested by the Gestapo in 1939 when they take over. He is condemned to death and spends a little over a week contemplating his life and impending execution. His life hits home for me:
HladÃk had passed forty years of age. Apart from some friendships and
many habits, the problematic study of literature constituted his life;
like every writer, he measured the virtues of others by what was done by
them and asked that others measure him by what he glimpsed or
outlined. All the books he had given to the press infused him with
utter remorse. In his examinations of the oeuvres of Boehme, Abenesra,
and Fludd, he had essentially taken part in mere application; in his
translation of Sephir Yezirah, in negligence, fatigue, and conjecture. The Vindication of Eternity
he judged to be perhaps less deficient; the first volume recounts the
diverse eternities that men have devised, from the motionless
Parmenidean One to Hinton’s modifiable past; the second denied (with
Francis Bradley) that all the deeds of the universe integrate a temporal
series. It argues that the number of man’s possible experiences is not
infinite and one sole “repetition” would suffice to demonstrate that
time is a fallacy... Unfortunately, the arguments that demonstrate this
fallacy are no less false; HladÃk used to go over them again with a
certain scornful perplexity. He had also written a series of
Expressionist poems; these, to the poet’s embarrassment, figured in an
anthology of 1924, and no anthology after that failed to inherit them.
From all of this equivocal and languid past HladÃk wanted to redeem
himself with the play in verse The Enemies (HladÃk praised verse because it impeded spectators from forgetting unreality, which is the condition of art).
So he's had some small successes, and he's been able to glimpse some big ideas, but hasn't really realized them. And now it's too late, because he's about to die.
So Hladik asks God to help him finish the one work he thinks will justify his existence. "In the darkness, he spoke to God: If I exist in any way, if I am not one of Your repetitions and errors, I exist as the author of The Enemies.
To come to the end of this play which can justify me and justify You, I
require one more year. Grant me these days, You who are the centuries
and time. It was the last night, the most atrocious, but ten minutes afterwards, sleep had washed over him like dark water."
In the end, God grants the miracle, but it is known only to Hladik. As Hladik stands before the firing squad, God halts time, but only Hladik is aware of the miracle. Hladik cannot move, but he can think, and, helped by the metrical nature of his play, he is able to write the play entirely in his head. It is slow going, but he keeps at it--what else is there to do?
Interestingly, he is not writing the play for God, who created the miracle: "He did not work for posterity, nor even for God, of whose literary preferences he knew little." For whom is he writing it, then? I think the answer is in Hladik's prayer: to "justify me and justify (God)." Merely to have written the play will accomplish justification. It is not necessary that anyone should read it.
That's a nice story, but do I really believe this?
A good friend of mine keeps telling me that since I seem to have a predilection for writing fiction, I should just accept that the odds are always going to be long that I'll "make it" and write for myself. Joseph Hladik, standing secretly in an alternate reality before the firing squad, would probably agree with my friend. But is this just mystical hogwash? What difference does it make if I write a story in my head, or--as has really happened--a novel and other stories I'm having a hard time getting published? Does this really justify my existence?
I've often stuck to the line that if I knew, through some divine messenger, that nobody would ever read what I wrote, I'd stop writing. Although I wonder if this is true; I write on this blog without a terribly large audience. I get between fifty and a hundred hits after each post, more or less. I assume half of those are bots or some other kind of Internet weirdness. Maybe there are a few silent folks from my target audience of struggling writers out there, but if I quit writing this blog tomorrow, the world wouldn't notice. For some reason, though, that really doesn't bother me with the blog. I write the blog to help people if possible, but also just to put words to thoughts stuck in my brain so I can then move on to other thoughts.
When I write non-fiction for this blog, I write like my friend would want me to: for the sake of writing itself. But when I write fiction, I take things personally. Rejections hurt--every damn time. Does that mean that I'm actually a non-fiction writer mistaking myself for a fiction writer? Since I can do the former without really caring about the results, is that my real "calling," the real thing that justifies me and the clunky creator who made me?
That's a possibility that occurs to me more and more as time goes by, but I still keep feeling compelled to write one more story. Blog posts generally feel breezy and--with some exceptions--come without me chasing them too hard. Most of the stories I write seem to run from me like Jonah ran from God. They cost me a lot of work to write, which is why I can't help but wonder why I write them when I fail so often to get anyone to read them.
The world seems a graver place to me every day, and I continue to get older. I may not be sentenced to die tomorrow, but the end will come sooner or later--sooner today than yesterday. In 2018, I'm moving in one direction or another with writing. I'm either going to take a long break from it to see if I still want to do it, or I'm going to double down and write a lot more. I haven't decided yet. Eighteen months ago, when I finished my novel, I thought I had already had my moment of justifying myself and God. Maybe God is just taking a long time to decide what to do with what I made.
Ask any lay person to recite a Shakespearean soliloquy, and I'd wager eight out of ten people would start with "To be or not to be." That speech is to Shakespearean literature what the opening bars of Beethoven's Fifth are to classical music. It's strange, perhaps, that one of the best known and most cherished passages in the English language is an extended meditation on suicide, one that takes a fairly agnostic position on the subject--it'd be nice to try, but the risks seem kind of high. Personally, there are only three Shakespeare passages I can quote more than a few lines of without looking at the script: 1) To be or not to be; 2) "Out, out brief candle," from Macbeth; and 3) The "seven ages of man," from As You Like it.
Curiosity about death and suicide pervades the first of these three soliloquies; the second one from Macbeth is imbued with a nihilism that welcomes a coming death. The third, after a number of comical references, ends with terrible force by describing the end of human existence: "sans teeth, sans eyes, sans taste, sans...everything."
Shakespeare scholars warn us not to read any character's words as the real thoughts of Shakespeare. The term "negative capability" comes from Keats' reading of Shakespeare. It means, among other things, Shakespeare's ability to lose himself in his characters, so it's impossible to tell where the author's real sympathies lie. But even if those passages in Shakespeare that talk about suicide or question the meaning of life aren't meant to be met with full acceptance, it's hard to deny that these passages are among the ones that hit us in the face the hardest when reading Shakespeare. They're the ones that knock us down with their truth. When people comment today with amazement at how someone writing more than 400 years ago understood people so well, I imagine they are thinking of passages like this. "Soft suicidality"; How weary, stale, flat and unprofitable seem to me all the uses of this world.
I'm not suicidal. (Really, Karen--you don't have to worry!) I just don't enjoy life that much, and often find it nearly beyond my ability to manage, in spite of my good fortune. I realize I have it very, very good compared to most humans born into the world today and throughout history. I ought to be enjoying myself more. It's an affront, perhaps, to the fates to not enjoy my good fortune more than I do. If it makes you feel any better, my own guilt about the fact that I don't enjoy my good fortune more is itself one of the things that robs me of my joy. But I think life ought to offer more than just relative gratefulness, more than simply realizing that I'm not a sex slave or a Murle child in South Sudan or a North Korean prisoner of conscience. Life ought to be something to be grateful for in absolute terms.
My good fortune does not mean the world is good
I know better than anyone the good hand I was dealt. I have great parents. I have a really nice family. Everyone around me, outside the province of Mrs. Heretic's teeth, has wonderful health. I'm in the upper-middle-class in income, even if I manage to find new and inventive ways to squander that income.
And just because I haven't faced the worst this world has to offer doesn't mean I don't understand how horrible it can be and the fate I've been lucky to avoid. I have what you might call a long and intimate second-hand knowledge of just how horrifying the game can get for some people.
But telling me to be thankful because the really awful things didn't happen to me personally seems like some strange cousin of Stockholm Syndrome. To whom should I be thankful? To the God/Universe/Fate that allows some children to be born into slavery but not me personally? The fact that it happens at all should make us question to goodness of things. Falling to my knees to give thanks that things aren't as bad for me personally as they could be is what happens in the Book of Job. God terrifies Job, rather than giving an answer as to why the wicked suffer, and eventually, Job is frightened into stopping his questions. Might makes right.
I'll eat your pumpkin pie, just quit telling me to be thankful
There's another element to it. Telling me that I've got it better than most people is like the teacher who calls on you to give an answer, but right before you give your answer, the teacher says, "This is an easy one." Suddenly, all your confidence melts away. You can't win now. If you get it right, it was an easy one. If you miss it, you're a total moron. This is one reason why I get so annoyed with those people in my social media who keep posting that video with the condescending description, "for the people who still don't understand white privilege." It's not that I don't understand it. It's an easy idea. And it's not that I don't think it exists. It's that it's really not a helpful idea to me. All it makes me feel like is that my life is the "easy question," and if I do well, I was supposed to, and if I mess up, I'm double the screw-up anyone else is. In this sense, my blessings are...well, not curses, but less blessed, anyhow. I hate being told my life is an easy question, because the answer sure doesn't seem to be coming easy to me. EVEN THOUGH YES, BEING WHITE, MALE, AND STRAIGHT DOES MAKE IT EASIER. It's still hard for me. Just because others are doing advanced differential calculus doesn't mean I find algebra easy.
But Thanksgiving as we tend to practice it asks us to reflect on these very advantages we privileged folk have. You might as well have a holiday called "All the Reasons you Ought to be Doing Better Than You Are Day."
Taking time to realize that we've got it pretty good--and most people in America are probably in this category--might help us to keep from catastrophizing our problems. It might be good for our mental health and happiness to some extent. Realizing that the latest unexpected expense setting me back isn't a calamity on the level of civil war or famine can help keep me from dwelling too much on it. So to the extent that "Thanksgiving" is calling for an attitude of balance, fine.
It is DEFINITELY important to say thank you to the people in our lives who make it better, both for our own good and also out of just plain politeness.
But I am tired of being told to make generalized, omni-directional thankfulness a perpetual attitude.
Life is hard. If it's not hard for you, I'd guess you don't think about it too much. Good for you. If that's true, feel free to ooze all the thankfulness you want. But the ubiquity of sentiments like those of Hamlet or Macbeth seem to me like a pretty good indication that it has always been recognized that life is a struggle, a struggle so trying it's not entirely clear that it's worth the trouble.
When I eat too much good food this year, surrounded by the people who keep me on the affirmative side of life being just good enough to keep going, I'll count myself incredibly lucky. But lucky doesn't mean thankful.
The subject of writing drunk--namely, whether it's a good idea for a writer--is one that pops up now and again on writing sites. Some really believe it helps with the creative process by freeing the mind of inhibitions and getting the brain to open up to new possibilities. Some think the benefits are imagined, and that in any event, drinking past a certain point will make your writing so incoherent, any benefits you've gained from freeing your mind will be offset by the nonsense of your prose when looked at in the cold light of the next day.
One common means of trying to marry the mental liberation of alcohol with the benefits of clear-mindedness is the old aphorism, often credited to Hemingway, of "write drunk, edit sober." That is, use alcohol as an aid to opening up creativity while slapping down that first draft, but then look at it later with a more critical eye, smoothing out the roughness left by your free-thinking drunkard. (At least one writing advice blogger tried this for a week.)
Just from a basic smell test perspective, this idea does make some sense. A lot of writers advise not censoring yourself too much during the first draft. Burroway's textbook on writing emphasizes the importance of "shitty first drafts," without which the stunning eleventh draft would never be possible. Just get it out there on the page. You can fix shit, but you can't fix nothing.
My writing relationship with alcohol
I do drink while writing sometimes. I don't drink much--maybe once a week--so it's easy for me to get a rapid buzz going. I don't so much drink because I feel it helps me write as I drink because I tend to write a lot on the weekends, and that's when I also like to drink. I don't want to write and then drink, because by the time I'm done writing, it's a little late to get my drink on, so I tend to just multi-task and do both at once.
I can't say whether alcohol helps with creativity. It's a little hard to tell, because I can't isolate alcohol enough to make it a controlled variable. There are some nights where Mrs. Heretic and the kids are happily doing their own thing, I have several hours of uninterrupted writing, and I get a lot done. If I happened to have been drinking during that time, I might credit it to the alcohol when in fact, it was more just the peace and quiet. Since I write around work and fatherhood, I sometimes get up in the wee hours of the morning to write before anyone else is up, and that can oftentimes be as productive as drinking and writing in the late hours on the weekend.
I don't think the alcohol makes me a better writer. But, it does probably have one very profound effect on me while I'm writing. The most frequent reason I stop writing before getting done what I'd wanted to is self-doubt. "This is shit, I'm wasting my time, writing is stupid and so am I." That's probably how about one in three writing sessions ends for me. But I'm invariably a happy drunk. It helps me get past my own self-loathing long enough to get something onto the page.
I took a long time getting to where I drank at all. My first drink was at 23. The first time I got drunk, I was 27. After that, I would still sometimes go an entire year without drinking any alcohol. I had a weird sort of philosophy. I believed life was shitty, and that it was the responsibility of a serious thinking person to face the full shittiness of life without pain killers. I think I was under the impression that if I dulled my senses at all, I'd end up thinking life was less awful than it is, and I'd see it in a less truthful way. In the last, say, five years or so, however, I've become far more flexible on the subject. I'm just trying to make it to fifty. If a little booze-backed vacation from my problems every now and again helps me get there, I'm no longer going to deny myself that. I'm like a mother who swore off taking an epidural during labor who finally, after two or three kids, gave in and got one. Now I just wonder why it took me so long.
Mark Twain and Uncle Remus are well-known examples of great American literature with a heavy use of dialect, but nowadays, excessive use of dialect is generally frowned upon. It isn't so much that you can't use it, it's that the generally accepted advice on dialect now is to aim for moderation.
Even in a novel that calls out for some use of dialect, like Colson Whitehead's The Underground Railraod, the dialect is very sparse, mostly not going beyond the occasional "ain't." Whitehead partly manages this by getting his main character, Cora, an education before she's too far along in the book. But even before that, the dialogue in the book probably doesn't very closely represent the actual speech patterns of Georgia field slaves in the 19th Century. A few examples:
-Ain't this a nice mansion?
-Mighty fine work. That a little bed in there?
-"Nothing today, Cora? Alice said. "Too early," Cora said.
-"Almost had it," Cora said.
The main technique Whitehead uses to achieve moderation in use of dialect is one common to a lot of modern high fiction: he just avoids using a lot of dialogue at all. The book really doesn't have any of those sections where you get through four pages in about sixty seconds because it's all back-and-forth. Not only is the dialect done sparingly, the dialogue is.
I wonder why fiction has chosen to go this route with both dialect and dialogue. Why are both treated almost with suspicion? One obvious hypothesis is that fiction feels the need to give its audience something different from drama or cinema/video. If you want dialogue, they can do it better, so a fiction writer would be wise to avoid going head-to-head with those media. Instead, better to try to render narrative using techniques only available to those who traffic exclusively in words.
It's funny to me that in this one respect, fiction seems to have tried to distance itself from cinema. When I was in graduate school, instructors often invoked language from film theory to explain ideas in narrative. The concepts of method acting were often used to explain how to determine authentic character choices. One instructor explained scene by talking about where to place the "camera." The fiction how-to books I've read are full of this kind of talk. So why the divergence here? If Hollywood was going to do a slavery-era movie and the actors didn't use dialect, we'd criticize the hell out of it. Being able to deliver a killer accent is considered a mark of a good actor.
I don't have a good answer to either why fiction is avoiding dialogue and dialect, nor to what you, as a writer, need to do to cope with this. In "A Cinnabon at Mondawmin," which is probably the best story I've written yet, I had a main character who was a young black man in Baltimore. If he was going to talk, there was a specific way for him to authentically talk. But I didn't think I, as a white, middle-class man, could really do justice to it. It felt like a literary form of blackface. So I came up with a narrative technique. It was an epistolary story in which the boy was writing in his school journal, but constantly asking his white teacher from the suburbs to "make it sound right" for white people. That allowed me to have echoes of the boy's voice, but mostly write in a way that is more like the way I, Jake Weber, actually talk and write. That worked there, but I can only use that trick once.
It's too bad that good authors are mostly staying away from using heavy dialogue and dialect these days. I see a lot of bad use of dialect as an editor, but that's probably because good writers know that these things are out of fashion and therefore hard to get away with. That means the only people still trying them are hacks. So the use of these things gets caught in a vicious cycle where we think only hacks use them, then hacks do, in fact, exclusively use them, and our prejudices are confirmed even more.
In conclusion, I don't have a lot of easy fixes if you're writing a story where it just doesn't feel right for the characters to be talking like the cast of Friends. Just know the expectations and be careful, I guess.