Showing posts with label meaning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label meaning. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 20, 2022

The critic America deserves, if not the one it needs

I'm going to blog about this year's Best American Short Stories, although I said I wouldn't. That I couldn't. That I needed to move on from literature and do something more practical with my life. After a year or so of sticking to that resolution, though, I think that all things considered, blogging about literature in the way I do might be one of the less futile things I could do with my time. 

A lot of that has to do with what I chose to blog about, how I approach it, and how few others are doing something similar. I analyze stories based mostly on nothing more than a close reading, a passing familiarity with theoretical approaches, and a heavy influence from having listened to thousands of sermons that were built around textual analysis. My goal is to create readings of stories that intelligent laypeople can understand, enough that they feel their experience of a story was deepened by what I had to say about it. If possible, I try to find some practical application of the reading, just like a Protestant pastor would with a Bible text. If there were thousands of people doing this for collections like Best American Short Stories or the Pushcart anthology, I likely wouldn't be compelling enough to rank high among them. But that's not the case. The numbers on my blog clearly tell me that there are still people in the world reading short stories, wanting to understand them better, and finding the resources out there slim enough they're willing to spend a few minutes with me. 

Literature may not be the most important thing in the world, but if becoming better at reading fiction that tries to capture the essence of life in its exasperating emotional and psychological agony makes people a little less prone to celebrating the maudlin, the mawkish, and the banal, then it's a useful way for me to spend my time. 

So I'm going to get back at it. It's not easy for me to write critically about the stories regarded as the best produced today. On a personal level, as a writer myself, I have two reactions, which are contradictory and come to me in alternating waves. Either I feel that I'm writing stories on par with those being hailed as the best, and my exclusion from them is an injustice, or I feel that I have been left out because I'm an inferior writer and that nobody should care what I have to say about stories I'm not good enough to have written myself. 

To analyze short stories, I have to ignore both of those voices, because whether I'm a good writer of fiction has nothing to do with whether the analysis I create is worthwhile. It's no exaggeration to say that at the very least, in relative terms, my literary analysis of these stories is worthwhile, because very often it's almost the only thing out there. (Although I'm not completely alone as long as my buddy Karen Carlson is still at it.) 

People have been complaining about the death of criticism forever, as one Times Literary Supplement article pointed out recently, but if you'd like proof that I'm not exaggerating, try finding good, professional criticism of the stories I'll be blogging about for the next few weeks or months, the ones from Best American Short Stories 2021. You'll see I'm not making this up.

I can guess at a couple of reasons for this. One is that most readers of short stories are writers themselves, as everyone knows, but since writers now are told that building social networks is nearly as important as writing itself, penning anything remotely critical about another writer is a risk not worth taking. 

It's also just plain hard work. Karen introduced me two years ago to a blogger who planned to try to blog through BASS with us, but he gave up after a few stories. That was just for one volume of BASS. Reading thoughtful, challenging stories in a way that does any justice to them is not easy. Doing it over and over is grueling, and it's not like anyone's paying me for it. If there's any result of it that I hear about, it's just as likely to be negative as positive. 

Nonetheless, this is a niche fate seems to have ordained I somehow fill, though I often feel slow of speech and slow of tongue and like fate should send anyone but me to do it. The more it seems like the world may not have as long a history in front of it as I once thought, though, the more it seems to me like I ought to tend the garden I have and think less about whether it's the one I think I ought to have. 

Tuesday, September 4, 2018

Since I've just spent five weeks deeply mired in reading David Foster Wallace, let's go ahead and talk openly about suicide

Thanks to a three-day weekend in which I ignored my family and friends almost completely, I finished Wallace's Infinite Jest. I got through the last pages this morning right after seeing my son off to school, then had to get through a day of work with that heaviness on the brain.

I'm going to attempt some kind of cathartic post on what the big ideas in the book are so I can move on with my life and do something else. I intend--unwisely, in all likelihood--to do this without a net. That is, I'm going to try to come up with my take on the book without referring to what the many, many experts and fans of the book have already said about it. I don't want to do either an academic-style analysis or a New York Times-type critique. The book's great. We all know that. It's also been studied to death, so if I'm going to say anything even close to new about it, it's going to have to be more personal.

This post is about suicide, about my relationship to the topic, about a book that deals extensively with it, written by an author who ultimately committed it.

Suicide in Infinite Jest 

Suicide is all over IJ. The meaning of the title within the novel refers to a movie about a woman who seems to softly promise the release of death. The movie has become weaponzied because people who watch it become essentially lobotomized, unable from their first viewing to desire anything but to watch it again. Beyond that, the book spends roughly half its pages on the down-and-out, the addicts and recovering addicts of Boston. This is a population that includes some who are tormented by the shadow of the black wing of aggressive depression. (If aggressive depression is anything like it is described in this book, let me say I feel nothing but sympathy for those who suffer from it, and I do not in the least bit begrudge anyone wanting out.)

But the link to suicide goes deeper still. It isn't just an option for the mentally ill. The book is, as the title suggests, deeply indebted to Hamlet, a play we teach to moody teens every year for some reason even though suicide is all over the play. Of course, there is the "To Be or Not To Be" soliloquy, which is an extended meditation on suicide. It's an option that Hamlet eventually only weakly opts out of because he is concerned about what kinds of dreams may torment him in that undiscovered country from whose bourn no traveler has returned. There is also Hamlet's even more direct wish that "the Almighty had not fix'd his canon 'gainst self-slaughter."

Hamlet's reasons for considering suicide in many ways contradict those given in IJ. The shifting narrator of IJ at one point notes that generally, people do not seriously consider suicide because they decide that "life's assets and debits do not square." But that seems to be exactly what has led Hamlet to consider it. He is disillusioned (but not, I think, depressed) that life seems to have moved on after his father's death so quickly. If his father can be forgotten like that, what is the point of life, if it's so fleeting? Why would anyone put up with the million annoyances, big and small, just to endure to the end of a thing that means nothing?

Perhaps this isn't the kind of suicidal thinking, though, that brings action. It's not enough to override the animal impulse, the instinct to survive. Hamlet may deride himself outright for being a coward, but that's not enough to make him do what he thinks he ought to do and end his own life. His abstractions do not bring action.

And that's a key theme of IJ. Intellectuals are capable of seeing through the many holes in the answers proposed by others of how to make life meaningful and worth living. But they are only able to show the holes, not to propose something better. They're just smart enough to be miserable.  It's a theme Jonathan Franzen has picked up in his work.

Geoffery Day is one of these just-smart-enough-to-be-miserable characters. He has come into Ennet House, a halfway house for those recovering from addiction, but just can't abide the cliches that AA wants him to repeat. Don Gately, although stunned nearly to silence by Day's verbal wit, manages to make one thing clear: Geoffery is completely right that everything AA tells you is garbage, but it is also completely right that if you do what AA wants you to do, it will work. It's a complete paradox (although Don wouldn't call it that), but it's true. But Day is too smart to unlock the magic.

The Antidote to suicidal tendencies in IJ

There are a couple of classes of people who might consider suicide. There are those tormented by psychological maladies or addictions that make life so painful they override the will to survive. These kinds of motivations lead to action. IJ compares these feelings to those who are so afraid of dying in a fire they jump from a burning building, preferring the certain death of the fall to what so terrifies them. People in really awful depression are in pain, pain that's greater than their fear.

There are also those whose problem with life is more a philosophical one. Hal, the novel's rather obvious teenage simulacra of Hamlet ("Prince Hal," a janitor calls him, rather too pointedly), is one of these. He is gobsmacked one morning when he imagines a pile of all the food he will eat from that morning to the end of his life, then pictures next to it a pile of all the shits he will have to take when he eats all that food. It gives him the screaming fantods, and it's all too much to take in. He spends the rest of his few moments on stage lying down, watching his father's movies. We are left to wonder if his coming seeming madness, alluded to in the chapter's opening scene, one in which every facial expression and word he says is misunderstood, is real madness.

Both those suffering direct psychological torment and the less direct, existential kind are offered options. For the recovering alcoholic, drug addict, or depressive, there is the magical compartmentalizing cliche of AA: one day at a time. Build a wall around the day, don't see beyond it. Build it over each second of the day if you have to. Yes, it's a cliche, but cliches tend to become cliches for a reason. You cannot eat that entire pile of meat or defecate all of that shit. As Joelle van Dyne discovers, if you try to think of all the days in front of you, they will feel like they are too big a hurdle, like each day is a car you have to jump on a motorcycle, Evil Kenevil-style. But a series of jumps over one car, repeated each day, is possible.

For those who have talked themselves into an intellectual state of uncertainty, until they feel that all the uses of this world are dull, stale, flat and unprofitable--maybe not actively considering suicide, because their thoughts cannot ever obtain the name of action, but nonetheless supremely indifferent to life--for these, the options are maybe a bit more complicated. The magic of cliches might not be available to them. So what do they turn to?

One thing they shouldn't turn to, according it IJ, is a sense of world-weary, ultra-cool ennui or weltschmerz. IJ constantly reinforces for us the idea that the never-ending cycle of smart-ass American irony is not, as we tend to believe, proof that we are wise to our own foibles; it's the cause of many of our most profound social anxieties and pathologies. It's natural to yearn for earnestness. (Here, I will cheat and bring in a video that explains Wallace's thoughts on Irony, one I was aware of before reading the book):




Early on in the book, we read a paper Hal has written for school on how America's police hero evolved from Hawaii Five-O to Hill Street Blues. It went from the man of action, who moved endlessly toward a conclusion we all saw was right, to post-modern hero Frank Furillo, a man struggling to figure out his murky way in a complex bureaucratic landscape. Furillo is not a hero of action, but re-action. Hal wonders if the future of the hero will give us a hero of "non-action, the catatonic hero, the one beyond calm, divorced from all stimulus..." By the end of the novel, Hal is on his way to being this very thing.

The last remaining vestige of the hero of action the novel sees as possible is Hal's brother Mario, a strange mix of birth defects and Yoda-like wisdom. In a touching (i.e. schmaltzy and utterly un-ironic) scene, the trainer who comes to the tennis academy where Hal and Mario live was moved to come there when he (the trainer) was conducting a social experiment living as a homeless person. Instead of asking for money, he asked for someone to just touch him. He held out his dirty hand and asked for human contact. When nobody did this for weeks, he (the trainer) began to despair, and almost forgot his real identity and became homeless. But Mario hears him (the trainer) asking for someone to just touch him and, unable to think it is just some weird argot for "please give me money," as everyone else has, shakes the man's hand.


But let's get real here

I haven't used scholarly sources here, because this book's been gone over by scholars and fans to death. I'm not going to produce something new through doing a lot of homework. In the spirit of Wallaceian earnestness, I'd like to talk about what this book made me feel.

This book is better than anything I could ever do. If I quit my job, abandoned my family, lived to write, I'd never touch the jaw-dropping wonder of this book. And yet, the guy who wrote it killed himself at about exactly my current age. A big part of me doesn't understand Wallace's suicide. I'm like the tennis students at Enfield Tennis Academy. I think that because he wrote a book that was ten times better than anything I've ever written, he should be ten times happier.

Of course, this is nonsense. No sooner do tennis players make the big time than they begin to worry about losing their fame and sense of being special when they stop winning. Tennis is a symbol for the American dream in IJ. Once we achieve it, our options are: enjoy it (often too much, which makes us lose our edge), or work tirelessly and paranoiacally to maintain it, which begins to feel like a grind, and leads some athletes to seek refuge in drugs, alcohol, etc.

There is retrospectively unnerving foreshadowing of Wallace's death in the book. The character in IJ who is most like its author is the film-maker, a man referred to by his family, suggestively, as "Himself." Himself "de-maps" himself by sticking his own head in a microwave.

I haven't extensively looked into Wallace's life. In grad school, I was still part of the generation that believed somewhat that details about the author's life were as likely to mislead you as enlighten. I don't believe that anymore, but I still wanted to try to connect purely with the book before I learned too much about the author. It turns out that Wallace probably killed himself more out of the psychic torment and addiction sorts of problems than the existential malaise kinds.

Thankfully, these are torments I've been spared. I'm not depressed, and I'm not within a million miles of addicted. But I have thought about suicide often since I was a teenager. I've almost always thought of suicide in terms of a cold calculus, the "credits and debits" of the novel. For now, I've put the question of suicide out of mind, because I feel--for reasons I can't quite describe--that it would be wrong to go while my parents are still alive and while I still have kids to get established in life. But man, I've seen my grandmother and my mother-in-law die in nursing homes in the last ten years. I do not want to go that way, surrounded by the eye-burning ammonia stink of urine until I don't notice it anymore.

I don't want to go too early, but when the time comes, I don't want to lose the name of action and go too late. I'm worried I won't have the stamina to put up with life until I've made it long enough, but I'm also worried that when I've made it as far as I want to make it, I'll be too scared to give it up. It's a difficult balance I want to achieve between clinging to life and being ready to leave it. The thing about Infinite Jest is this: I don't think IJ goes far enough to make a convincing case for sticking around.

Instead of tennis, life just seems to me like a kind of semi-interesting board game, but one that goes on way too long, well past the point of being amusing. I have no real grudge against others if they enjoy the game, and in fact wouldn't mind making room for them at the table by bowing out myself, if it weren't for the fact I think it would hurt the chances of others I feel responsible for helping to enjoy the game themselves. So I keep playing well past the point of diminishing returns for me, until life just seems like a big pile of tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrows I have to endure.

I know it's an ad hominem to say that what DFW offers in IJ must not be a good method for getting myself as far in the game as I want to go, since it didn't work for him. But doesn't that mean something? Doesn't it suggest something about the usefulness of the solutions offered in IJ for finding a way to keep getting up every morning without de-mapping oneself?

It seems absurd to say Wallace underestimated the role humor can play in survival, because I can't remember reading a funnier author. But in taking irony out of play, DFW is really taking a major weapon in the humorist's arsenal, one that can help to cope with life. Sometimes, irony is better than earnestness. Not always. I'm glad DFW made an earnest plea for earnestness, and that it seems to have had an impact on our culture. But sometimes, yes, it really is better to evade your true feelings and use humor, even douchey world-weary ironic humor, than it is to come in contact with real feelings.

Me, I use some combination of fuck-you-universe rage, emotion-dodging humor, dopamine I get from occasionally being able to help others or finding something genuinely fun to do, and bits of occasional hopefulness that somewhere in the things in heaven and earth not dreamed of in my small philosophy might be something that could make this whole tale to be told by someone other than an idiot. There is no right formula. You get through life telling yourself whatever you need to tell yourself. If I tell myself enough things to get to a point where I feel pretty sure I've played long enough, I win.

I loved this book, but I'm not sure in the end it was enough of what I look for that I'm going to keep going back to it. I don't think I'll be one of those annoying DFW acolytes I've read about, sort of the literary equivalent of the worst of the Rick and Morty fanbase. Maybe that's for the best, since those kinds of fans seem to lead to the kinds of snarky, ironic critiques of themselves that DFW would have hated.

In the meantime, should the wraith of Wallace ever feel the desire to slow down enough to sit atop my monitor and share its thoughts with me, he's always welcome at my desk. I hope his wraith is happy wherever he is. 

Saturday, April 21, 2018

Asking the right kinds of questions of literature

There are two things about my life I've beat to death on this blog: that I used to be a rather devout evangelical Christian, and that when I stopped believing, literature partly filled the gap in my life where Christianity used to be. I ask a lot of literature. So I was intrigued by an essay that appeared on Lithub last week by Rachel Vorona Cote, who confessed to a similar habit. As she put it in her essay ""The Complicated Comforts of Marilynne Robinson,": "I have a nasty habit of asking too much from books."

Her essay is a personal look at her own pain and an attempt to use literature to overcome it. In late 2017, she was discouraged by the first year of Trump's presidency and personally undone by her mother's death. She was in a place where people often turn to religion, but knowing ahead of time from personal experience that heading to church would end up fruitless, she was looking around for something religion-like to fill the void. 

Gilead




She tried Marilynne Robinson's Gilead. It is a very well-regarded novel about an aging Congregationalist minister, John Ames. I read it last year. Almost nothing happens in it in the present. There is some action that takes place in flashback, but much of the action in the novel gets sidetracked by Ames' own theological musings. Still, it's not like being preached to for the length of the novel. Ames, in fact, is a bit too introspective to be a fire-and-brimstone preacher. In one of the few passages I highlighted from the book, he says of himself that "...there is tendency in my thinking, for the opposed sides of a question to cancel each other more or less....If I put my thinking down on paper perhaps I can think more rigorously. Where a resolution is necessary it must also be possible." 

But Ames never really quite succeeds in achieving his resolution. The conflict of the book, if it can even be called that, is that Ames is concerned that the ne'er-do-well son of his lifelong best friend is going to try to move in and marry his much younger wife when Ames dies. But the conflict more or less takes care of itself. 

Cote found comfort in reading the book. She had hoped that Robinson could be her Virgil, "a woman of faith to guide me through her theological web--and who could believe in my stead what I feared couldn't possibly be true. That I would find my mother again. That she had not been obliterated by death. That our shattered country might stumble onto a path of progress, however slow and aching." 

Although Ames asserts that the "purpose of a prophet" is to "find meaning in trouble," you won't find that meaning explicitly stated in Gilead. I found reading it to be akin to looking at a painting for an extended period of time. I was left more with a continuous mood or feeling than with what you might call a discursive kind of impression. 

This was enough for Cote, at least mostly:

 "Gilead could not entirely soothe my despondence: it couldn’t assure me that Mom was peeping into my apartment’s darkened windows, or directing her love-filled gaze at Dad while he slept. It couldn’t even convince me that her soul awaited mine in some obscure afterlife. But John Ames would have believed this to be the case, and somehow, that was enough for me." 

She found that simply vicariously huffing off the faith fumes of someone else was close enough to the experience itself to bring comfort. She read another Robinson novel, Housekeeping, which I have not read. But then, she did something I find telling: she read a book of essays by Robinson. As Cote put it, she was hungering "for a more explicit manifesto." She had been comforted by living in Ames' head for a bit, but she was looking for something that offered a less poetic sense of meaning here in the modern world. 

But Robinson's refusal to be more certain of herself in her non-fiction is a double-edged sword for Cote. Robinson is not an agitator; she is too circumspect about her own conclusions for that. On the one hand, this is the hallmark of a rational thinker, but on the other hand, too much self-circumspection can lead to inaction. 

It's a familiar conundrum for liberals. Cote nicely sums up this conundrum in the concluding paragraphs:

If Robinson’s nonfiction feels insufficient in the face of a political crisis, it’s because certitude seems foolhardy, and a bit smug. The agnosticism that plagues me in mourning strikes me as productive, even necessary in the political sphere. We do not have the luxury of always being sure, especially when we are a solitary voice within a purportedly democratic cacophony. To achieve anything worthwhile we must writhe and grapple like blind animals in a net, stumbling upon deliverance without the satisfaction of knowing it’s within our reach.
          Still, too much fear and doubt becomes unwieldy...


Truth and Comfort


"Too much fear and doubt becomes unwieldy?" Tell me about it. Agnosticism seems to me to be the most intellectually honest position to take, but the thing about agnosticism is that its adherents are, well, agnostic. Which doesn't mean, of course, that they are "indifferent," as many people are now starting to use the word. It means they just don't know what's right. An agnostic can look at the faith of a true believer and be genuinely jealous. Look how that person seems filled with certainty. Look how much she accomplishes. I wish I could believe like she does. 

I don't think it was wrong of Cote to expect a lot from a book. I keep reading because I am constantly hoping I will find something that can help me resolve my honest uncertainty with my desire to be more certain. But I'm not sure Gilead is the right place to look. Musicians and prophets may both have been inspired by the gods, but they bring different things. Musicians--and Gilead is more like music than a sermon--bring comfort. Prophets bring truth that demands action. 

There's nothing wrong with comfort, but even an agnostic like me can see the wisdom in C.S. Lewis's warning: "If you look for truth, you may find comfort in the end; if you look for comfort you will not get either comfort or truth--only soft soap and wishful thinking to begin, and in the end, despair." That's the reason Cote found herself wanting to read non-fiction: she wanted truth. 

In fact, I'd say that it's only because Cote was steadfast in wanting truth that she found any comfort in Robinson at all. It wasn't a deep and satisfying comfort, but it was a small comfort. It was enough to keep going on. And maybe that's the most an intellectually honest person will ever get. The most you can hope for is to string together enough moments of hard-won comfort until you reach a point, like John Ames did, where you live long enough "to outlast any sense of grievance you may acquire." 

Thursday, April 13, 2017

The Doubt Trilogy, Episode One: What good is an artsy story?

Self-doubt so deep, it's going to need some sequels...

I read a really great short story a couple of weeks ago, so of course I've kind of been feeling like shit since then. The story was "The Devil's Triangle" by Emma Duffy-Comparone. Karen Carlson, who just keeps doing her thing at A Just Recompense, was nice enough to point at that Duffy-Comparone is also the writer of "The Zen Thing," which, like "Triangle," won a Pushcart Prize. I thought both were great stories.

I don't feel shitty because she's far more successful than me. That's true of zillions of writers. It's complicated. I'll try to unpack it. I tried to get all the overlapping zones of uneasiness I'm feeling into one post, but it was impossible. Let's start with one more or less consistent thought.

It's good in a way I can't be good...

She has a knack for punchy and imaginative metaphorical language. I can go to almost any page to find an example:

"Claire's guinea pig, Pam, sat on chicken wire, breathing rapidly. Mika had taken her when she moved out of the apartment. Now the animal was barely recognizable, polka-dotted with scarlet sores like sucked cough drops, her nails brown and corkscrewing into her feet, her left eye oozed shut, the right cloudy as if rinsed with half-and-half."

...but that's not the problem

I just don't write like that. Which is fine, everyone writes to their strengths. A lot of writers I admire don't write like that. But I guess I've lately felt shamed into thinking I should want to write like that. A friend recently sent me this interview by David Vann, in which Vann praised "the quiet and beautiful books, Latinate in style, not violent, slow-paced..." The literary equivalent of Manchester by the Sea, let's say. Sometimes, I feel like that kind of writing is the only "serious" writing. Or at least the only writing that is taken seriously.

but what's the point of that kind of narrative?

I liked Manchester by the Sea. I really did. Okay, not for like the first hour. But eventually, I liked it. It was "quiet and beautiful," to use Vann's phrase. It was also very "slow-paced." The subdued tones, the attention to small things, made the few outbreaks of raw emotion far more poignant when they broke out. I'll admit, I found that scene, when Lee and Randi finally try to talk about the loss of their children, extremely moving. There were two characters I found very believable for the way they tried with so much earnestness to say the unspeakable to one another, and it's hurting them that they can't find the words, so they strain harder to get the words out, but they just can't.

Duffy-Comparone's story had a similar emotional approach and outcome. It is the story of triplets, but one is gone and, by now, beyond just "presumed" dead. The other two, who are now just "twins," are trying, each in their own failed ways, to move on. After pages and pages of slowness, of cloudy-brained wandering through a landscape of sharp details, we get an explosion in the last few pages. The ending, when they both seem to have hit their rock bottom and appear ready to maybe eventually take some baby steps toward moving on, is probably close to how the actual getting over something like that would be. So maybe the reader has experienced vicarious loss and redemption on a microcosmic scale by reading it.

But what has all this emotion accomplished? St. Augustine mistrusted poetry for causing these very same kinds of vicarious emotions:"forgetting my own wanderings, and to weep for the death of Dido, who slew herself for love, while I looked with dry eyes on my own most unhappy death, wandering far from Thee, O God, my life. For what is so pitiful as an unhappy wretch who pities not himself, who has tears for the death of Dido, because she loved Aeneas, but none of his own death, because he loves not Thee?" 

To put it in a more secular way, what good does it do for me to feel emotion over a story if it doesn't result in a change in my way of living in the world? Or, barring that, at least a significant change in my thinking? Proponents of literature like to say that literature (and stories in any form) make us see life more sympathetically by living it through the perspective of another. Fine, I suppose Manchester and "The Devil's Triangle" did that. Moreover, maybe by experiencing the pain of another person whose life we can view with a blend of both emotion and objectivity, we can learn to better process our own pain. 

Those seem like nice things, but they can't be enough to give literature the honored place in world culture it has had for thousands of years. 

An example I can actually think of where fiction might have made me a better person

Here's an example of a story that changed my life: I was about to leave Chicago to come to Maryland and start my job after graduate school. I saw Monster, which is based on a true story, but parts of it were obviously imagined. Aileen Wuornos just has bad damn luck. Most of the world shits on her. A few people are kind to her, but their kindness is not enough or not timely enough to make a difference. The movie doesn't really excuse Wuornos for becoming a serial killer, but it does make one wonder how things would have turned out for her if she had received a little more kindness when it might have still done some good. The last murder she commits is of a man who picks her up and, when she offers to have sex with him, says he'd rather offer her a meal and a place to stay. He and his wife have a room, he says. But it's too late for her. 

I left that movie wondering what difference it would have made if he'd been there ten years earlier. So I decided I would try to make enough money that I would have a spare room in my house to give to someone who needed it. 

I don't think that's the point of most current fiction

That's a pragmatic outcome of fiction. But I don't think that's the outcome most contemporary fiction is going for. A story is considered successful if it merely creates a simulacra of real emotion in the reader/viewer. It is, to use the phrase from Anis Shivani I've already quoted a few times, "cheap counseling for a bereaved bourgeoisie." 

Contemporary fiction often seems not to be offering anything to say about the nature of suffering its characters go through. It's trying to be, itself, a way to experience and overcome suffering. It's not a means to express something, it's the ends. The words and images and internal emotional logic of the fiction are a world unto themselves. The idea isn't to say something true about the world, to hold up a mirror to society. It's to become its own world. A story has succeeded when it becomes itself.

 Meanwhile, in the real world...

 One of my first workshop heretic moments came in 2003, when I openly wondered in class about what the point of writing the kind of poems and stories we were trying to write was. One poet got very angry with me. How could I say there was no point to writing poetry? A woman in Nigeria had just been acquitted of stoning to death for adultery because people wrote about it! I wanted to ask her how many poems she thought the judges had read. More than likely, they read about one document: an order from a government official to let her off. And that official had probably read a threat from a Western ambassador or two. No poems, I'm going to guess.

 I posted a few weeks back about the struggles of a woman I know to get medical care for her daughter, who has a severe medical condition. That post was partly the result of buzzed blogging, but it was also a result of listening to Chris Hayes' interview about his book A Colony in a Nation. He took time to talk about how the proposed changes to the Affordable Care Act would especially hurt mentally ill people. It was non-fiction, and I found it far more moving than any story I can remember reading lately. 

What story could I write that could be as necessary as Bandi's The Accusation, which is fiction but of a pointed political nature, a cry for a people and a finger wagging directly at a dictator?

But this book's coming out...

I have so much more work to do now that I have a book coming out. I have editing. I have decisions to make about the cover, the credits. I'm supposed to do readings and promote myself and send my book to be reviewed and get people to write blurbs for the back of the book and generally become my own literary pimp. Then, I need to write more so I can follow this up and keep marketing myself.

A friend of mine was once a chess player with a very strong rating. I'm jealous of that, because I like chess and wish I were as good as him. I'm always surprised he stopped playing. I recently asked him why, and he said, "I got to be better than 99% of players with X level of effort. But it would take X^2 level of effort to become better than 99.1% of players. I thought my time would be better spent getting good at something else."

As I think about jumping into the deep end of writing and whether it is a humanly enriching enough activity to justify a much deeper time and energy commitment than I have so far given it. How, for example, will writing allow me to keep that room in my house for someone to use? If writing can't provide something better for the world than that, what I am doing spending my time doing it?       

 






Tuesday, January 24, 2017

If you can't trust a great musical to tell you what life's all about, what can you trust: La La Land and selling out

Lest I be hauled in like Aziz Ansari in his SNL sketch for not loving La La Land, I'll just say up front: this is a great movie. It reminds me of Steve Martin's line about the movie Chicago. In a year where there was a lot of controversy about cheating to gain an advantage in Oscar awards, Martin claimed Chicago pulled the dirtiest trick of all: "They made a really great movie that everyone liked."

It's a simple musical about staying true to your dreams...

The movie is bookended by two big numbers: "Another Day of Sun," and "Fools Who Dream." The first one is an exuberant impromptu flash mob of struggling entertainers in a traffic jam belting out their indefatigable beliefs that they will make Hollywood bend to their wills to become stars:

I'm reaching for the heights
And chasing all the lights
that shine
And when they let you down
You'll get up off the ground

 In Mia's (Emma Stone) big finale, she affirms her faith in the meaning of chasing her dreams as part of the audition where she finally breaks through:

Here's to the ones who dream
Foolish as they may seem
Here's to the hearts that ache
Here's to the mess we make

...except that it's not

It's what's in between those two numbers that made the movie great, though. There's an almost-too-sweet love story played with aggressive cuteness by Stone and enviable cool by Gosling (as Sebastian). It's so sweet, I can't even hate it for being too sweet. After they fall in love, they attempt to understand one anothers' dreams and support each other, but both are sledding uphill for a while.

Mia, having gone through a wonderful scene early on in which she manages to summon up instant pathos from inside herself to cry convincingly at an audition only to have the scene callously interrupted in a manner destined to make her cry for real, faces the reality that she perhaps ought to give up. She posits to Sebastian that she ought to have been a lawyer. "Like the world needs more lawyers," Sebastian answers. Mia's response is forged from a thousand rehearsals with no call-backs: "Well, it doesn't need more actresses." It's these kinds of exchanges that, as the Village Voice put it, "movingly weight the film with adult loss and disappointment."

Selling out within in the La La Land universe

It's Sebastian who breaks through first, thanks in part to Mia and a friend Keith who help him to move out of his rigid conception of success. Mia first chips away at his stubborn dream to own one particular jazz bar and renovate it into the terribly named Chicken on a Stick, a jazz bar that also sells chicken. Keith convinces Sebastian to come on the road with him and play good music that just isn't traditional jazz, because what made the original giants of jazz great was their willingness to look to the future, to embrace change.

It's all going great until the movie's best scene, a classic case of two people talking past each other. Mia is wondering how long Sebastian will be on the road, when he will parley his financial success into buying his dream jazz bar. Sebastian, confused and hurt because he thinks Mia is accusing him of having sold out, says he thought he was supposed to do this, that he should have been happy to be on a stage where people were finally happy to hear him play. "The difference between selling out and breaking through is not always clear, and “La La Land” is not so hypocritical as to pretend otherwise," as the New York Times put it.

Did Sebastian sell out? Did he just make a logical course correction? The question gathers more urgency as Mia's push to live her dream by writing and performing in her own one person show ends in a humiliating failure. She goes home, convinced the dream is over.

Deus (dea?) ex cantione--whatever the Latin is for an improbable extraction from difficulty by way of a song

Mia's dream is resurrected from the dead, though, when Sebastian, against all odds, gets a call from a casting agent looking for Mia. She saw Mia's one-woman show (she must have somehow gone unnoticed among the nine people in the crowd). Mia rushes back to Hollywood, sings the big "Fools who Dream" number at an audition, and goes off to Paris to become famous. For some reason, she doesn't end up with Sebastian, even though he drove all the way to Idaho or something to bring her back to the audition and found her without knowing her address.

That might be how the movie seeks to keep its emotional authenticity. Not everything is a perfect happy ending. Sacrifices were made. Sebastian has his jazz bar, but his special song is now kept in reserve, only to be brought out one night when he sees Mia, now married to someone else, in the crowd.

So what exactly is selling out?

We never see Mia's struggling friends again after a certain point. Presumably, some have gotten jobs as bankers or teachers or married well. There isn't room for them all to succeed. I once knew a guy who worked in receiving at a crappy drug store for $8.25 an hour as he neared 40. He played bass in a metal band. Last I saw him, he still hadn't given up the dream. He lived with his mom, which is fine; there are sacrifices for that kind of commitment.

Much like Thoreau's experiment in Walden, there are certain levels of artistic commitment that just can't be sustained if a family is involved. By the end, Mia has both family and career, but the career came first, and luckily while she was still young.

La La Land doesn't try to force too many answers. It allows itself out of answering tough questions, even the tough questions the movie itself has raised, by allowing Mia to improbably luck out. It's a musical, so it's allowed to do that.

Me, I get up and go to work every day in the white hot center of what you might call plan B. I still work at writing. I've written what I think is a novel worth reading. I've written short stories, and some have even been published. But I'm a few steps beyond Sebastian playing pop funk for money when it comes to abandoning the artistic high road.

Do we need artists?

Mia sings in her big number that "a bit of madness is key/to give us new colors to see/Who knows where they lead us?/And that's why they need us." It's sort of an unexpected thesis out of no where: artists don't just do what they do according to their own lights they reach for; they do it because it is their essential social function to do something perceived as possibly useless. This very act is restorative to society, the "they" who need "us." This might be reaching a bit too far. It's enough to do it for your own reasons. No need to invent messianic, selfless reasons for what you do.

This is where I leave off. The movie is beautiful enough for me to let it have its cake and eat it too, to both present the struggle honestly and to blink at the moment of truth. Maybe it's best not to think too deeply on the possibility of deep and final failure to achieve one's dreams, to be ever like Han Solo crying "Never tell me the odds!"

Friday, October 24, 2014

My first ever review

Blake Kimzey is getting a ton of publicity from this blog--or will, when more than five people read it--as a result of having been the guy who was randomly assigned to edit a story I sent to Carve magazine. I recently read his winner of the 2013 Black River Chapbook Contest, Families Among Us. 

I've never done a book or story review on here, and I'll think I'll do one now. But since this blog is supposed to be mostly about writing, I'm also going to be looking at it from the view of craft (getting ideas of what to do, developing an aesthetic, uncovering strategies, etc.)

One of the most striking things about this slender book (six short stories, four of which are very short, 32 pages total) is that for a book of short stories, they mostly fit together pretty well. A lot of short story writers joke about how they try to come up with convoluted ways in which they can present their short stories as a coherent, related collection when it really isn't (because, of course, nobody publishes short stories).  Four of these six are so closely related, I really hope they were written with each other in mind. Otherwise, Kimzey uses the same idea an awful lot in his short fiction.

Because the stories work together so well, it's nice to consider this chapbook as a text to be taken whole. In this manner, we end up with an interesting structure (spoiler alert times a million, although I don't think it will ruin the book much--in most of the stories the surprise is given away early on):

Story One: A family crashes on a jet, sprouts gills and lives underwater for a long time. They decide to come to the surface to re-adapt to life on land after an indefinite amount of time. It doesn't take, and the boy and girl cast off their clothes and return to the sea.

Story Two: A boy is born with a "beetle back" and wings. He learns to fly, although he is otherwise normal. He eventually sheds his clothes, flies off, and is never seen by the family again.

Story Four: A boy is born with what seems to be a worm-like mid-section. The boy eats dirt. The boy eventually casts off his clothes and squirms away, never to be seen again.

Story Five: A boy turns into a bear. Before he completely transforms, he casts off his clothes, heads to the forest, and finds a bear companion after hibernation.

Stories three and six are the change-ups. Story six actually acts like a nice ending to stories 1,2,4, and 5. It's the story Kimzey had published in Tin House for "Flash Friday." Here, a village has gone out to seek a lost child, and they find him after he has apparently fallen from the stars. What happens next is up to interpretation.

Story three is the one story that doesn't quite fit. It was also my favorite, although I have to say if Edward Said read it, he'd probably go ape shit. (Let me save you some time. Orientalism is a million pages of stodgy prose that basically says that people tend to read themselves into the "other.") An American bicycle tour guide in Paris is fascinated by the owls who live in his neighborhood and by the burka-clad woman who lives upstairs. Turns out, the burka-clad woman who lives upstairs is hiding a part-owl body beneath her covering. He is mesmerized, but the girl's father takes her off to the forest to lay her oeufs. 

I have to admit that by story four, I was a little tired of the story cycle. The most exciting moment came for me in story #2, "Up and Away." In the first story, "A Family Among Us," we get a perspective that might technically be third-person objective: we see all the actions of the family, but do not enter their thoughts. "Up and Away," though, gives us a nice use of third-person omniscient, a now rarely-used technique that stole the spotlight of this story. Because here, we get a truly family-level perspective of what is probably the core legend of this clan. We jump from mother's brain to sister's brain to father's brain in the same paragraph, much like one might hear a family tell one of their favorite vacation stories by talking over one another.

The final story, "And Finally the Tragedy," strikes me as a fitting ending to all the stories except three, because it is as if the village has gone to try to find all those children who have gone feral and ventured off into the wild. They have found the child, but the child brings back a revelation, something indecipherable: he opens his mouth, but instead of speaking, his mouth is "as cavernous as a two-story movie theater," leaving the narrator (the only first-person narrator in the book) to fear "he would swallow us whole."

Yet this first-person narrator, the town's reverend, still feels it is his duty to interpret the meaning the boy brings: "It was up to me to make sense of the boy." And so we, as readers, must make sense of Families. 

When reading magic realism, a form to which these stories undoubtedly belong (story four even has a boy who eats dirt, a la Rebecca in One Hundred Years of Solitude), I like to think that one key to unlocking the cipher is something that George McDonald said in The Miracles of our Lord: many of the miracles of Christ were just exaggerated versions of something God does all the time in nature anyway. God always turns water into wine (okay, you need other stuff, too). God always makes fish and bread. God always  makes fig trees wither and die.

So in the magic realist story, you have an element that is like the world as we know it, but stretched out of proportion. Children may not have beetle backs or fly or have gills, but they are a part of the natural world, as much as we parents try to convince them they are not. (Is there anything more savage than the birth of a baby? How did we ever get to celebrating this event with soft blue and pink balloons?) They do eventually leave (unless they major in English).

The first story is a slightly different story arc. The family actually begins by leaving the fuselage of the plane, where they have lived, as inside a womb, beneath the sea for who knows how long. But the children chafe at wearing clothes, and long before they even see civilization, they are playing a dangerous game of seeing how long they can hold their breath beneath the ocean, wishing to re-grow their gills to get back. So we all somewhat reject being taken from the womb, and long to return to  breathing our air through gills.

Rather than emerge from pre-life and wish to go back, the boy in the final story has returned from post-life and brought something of the terrible mystery back with him to trouble civilized folk.

The stories have much more harvest to yield than this, and the best thing I can say about them is that they brought me enough of joy that I am willing to keep trying to reap from them. I have said before that I like a story that has a point, that says something a cashier or a bouncer or a Marine can carry with him or her that will make life richer or maybe even just tolerable. But I don't always need to be able to fully realize what that thing is. I want there to be something to eat. If I enjoy the atmosphere and the appetizer was appealing, I am willing to wait for the main course, even if the main course does not come for decades. Whatever treasure is hiding in these stories (enough metaphors mixed in one paragraph?), there is enough of a map here to spend some time enjoying looking for it.